When I saw her
I thought she was hot
But it was dark
Now I know she's not
On the porch
In College Park
Should not have gone
She left her mark
Now I'm scarred
We went too far
I can't erase
What took place

She kissed me - didn't kiss her back
She's on the attack
Her comes butterface
Sha na na na nah - sha na na nah nasty
Butterface

In a moments time
I lost my pride
No where to hide
Images in my mind
I can't confide
They'll know I lied
When I think of that kiss
I wanna slit my wrists
I have nightmares
Shes in her underwear
Her face is busted
Man that's fuckin disgusting

She kissed me - didn't kiss her back
She's on the attack
Her comes butterface
Sha na na na nah - sha na na nah nasty
Butterface

Daddy warned me about girls like you
Better run like hell wehen they come after you
I think she fell from the ugly tree
Will someone please tell me why she's stalking me

She kissed me - didn't kiss her back
She's on the attack
Her comes butterface
Sha na na na nah - sha na na nah nasty
Butterface

I'm such a disgrace, hooked up with Butterface

Contributed by Elliot L. Suggest a correction in the comments below.

To comment on specific lyrics, highlight them