The band began when two friends, Jack Antonoff and Scott Irby-Ranniar, sharing a common love of music, began playing together. They busked in subways and alleyways in New York, and in 1999/2000 recorded a demo that garnered a large degree of record label interest. Despite the array of offers, the guys, now called Steel Train (after lyric in a Sublime song) eventually chose to sign with Drive Thru Records particularly drawn by the support but also artistic freedom the label offered.
In 2002, the band recorded their debut ep entitled 'For You My Dear,' recruiting Evan Winiker (formerly of NJ emo band Random Task) and Matthias Gruber to help with recording and touring. The two later became full members of the band, first Winiker (who was presented as a full member in the promotional pieces for that same ep, released in January 2003) and later Gruber, who joined with second guitarist Matthew Goldman to complete the band and create Steel Train.
Together the band went on to record the '1969' ep (a CD of cover versions of songs from that year that inspired the band and their sound), and their debut album 'Twilight Tales From The Prairies Of The Sun,' dropped a year later in 2005. In December of 2006 the band announced that they would be departing ways with Matthias Gruber (drums) and Matt Goldman (guitar) who chose to pursue other interests. The positions were filled by tour manager Daniel Silbert on guitar and Jon Shiffman on drums.
In 2009, the band left the Drive Thru label and in June of 2010 independently released their eponymously-titled third LP. Included in that release was a companion album, 'Terrible Thrills: Vol. I', consisting of covers and re-imaginings of each 'Steel Train' track by female artists, including Scarlett Johansson, Tegan and Sara, Holly Miranda, Alia Shawkat, Amanda Palmer, and Jack's sister Rachel Antonoff.
The band often polarizes opinions, mainly based around the fact that the style of rock they play is more 'classic' (Jack often jokes the band was "30 years too late"), yet people see them as very much a part of the emo/pop-punk scene (mainly due to their Drive Thru Records connections). They are well noted for their impressive live shows and 'jamming' ability.
The lead singer, Jack, also used to date Scarlett Johansson and the song Better Love off of Twilight Tales from the Prairies of the Sun is about/makes reference to her [1] [2]. Though Better Love is a song strictly about her, he also references her in "2 O'clock'" and "Dig". "Josie smiles and laughs, while me and Scarlett will smoke our hash." [3]and "oh, my scarlet you had a real friend in me."Lyrics
[edit] Current Members
* Jack Antonoff - Vocals, Guitar, Piano
* Evan Winiker - Bass, Backing Vocals
* Daniel Silbert - Guitar, Backing Vocals
* Jon Shiffman - Drums, Percussion
* Justin Huey - Keys
[edit] Past Members
* Matthias Gruber - Drums, Percussion
* Matthew Goldman - Guitar, Backing Vocals
* Scott Irby-Ranniar - Vocals, Percussion
[edit]
Better Love
Steel Train Lyrics
Jump to: Overall Meaning ↴ Line by Line Meaning ↴
And dreamed that she had never died
Wipe that tear, but you don't know why
Boy, you're pretty, but
You're just not for me
And better love I do not see
This girl, she had it kinda sweet
'Till fame swept her off her feet
She see's nothing she did before
Let's her colors hit the floor
Scars are in her name
And she scars me with blame
Hey Scarlet, you're not the same
So, be careful what you choose
I felt love for me and you
I'm not ashamed
As I walk another mile
I help you find out, child
I don't know what to do, I feel lost without you
Better love will come to you
And so, I flew west to see her pride
Two weeks since the music died
I watch the camera shoot this girl
Seems to me a hollow pearl
Mother sat me down
Oh, what's it like, oh my boy,
To be so destroyed?
So, be careful what you choose
I felt love for me and you
I'm not ashamed
So I walk another mile
To help you find out, child
I don't know what to do, I feel lost without you
Better love will take you
So, here I sit, some years have passed
I say I don't, but I miss her bad
I smell her in my sheets, you see
Like she's sleeping next to me
She'll say,
"Jack, I'm leaving now,
And don't you wait up for me,
Cause better love I'm yet to see."
The song "Better Love" by Steel Train is an emotional ballad that explores the complexities of relationships and the pain of lost love. The lyrics are filled with powerful imagery and metaphors that capture the raw, vulnerable emotions of the singer. The opening lines, "Well, you wake the love that sleeps inside, And dreamed that she had never died, Wipe that tear, but you don't know why" set the tone for the song, which is about the power of love to awaken deep emotions within us that we may not even be aware of. The singer urges the listener to be careful in their choices because love can be both beautiful and painful.
The song goes on to tell the story of a girl who gets swept off her feet by fame and loses herself in the process. The singer references her scars and her blame, suggesting that she may have been hurt or traumatized by her experiences. The chorus repeats throughout the song, with the singer insisting that there is "better love" out there, and encouraging the listener to keep searching for it. The song's final verse is particularly poignant, with the singer admitting that even years later, he still misses the girl who left him behind in search of something better.
Line by Line Meaning
Well, you wake the love that sleeps inside
You inspire and ignite the love that has always been within me, but was lying dormant.
And dreamed that she had never died
I had a dream where the love of my life had never left me, and it felt so real.
Wipe that tear, but you don't know why
Even though I'm trying to hide it, I'm crying and I don't even know why.
Boy, you're pretty, but
You're quite attractive, but
You're just not for me
I don't think we're meant to be together.
And better love I do not see
I haven't found a love that's better than the one that got away.
This girl, she had it kinda sweet
The girl I loved used to have a good life.
'Till fame swept her off her feet
But then fame happened, and it completely changed everything for her.
She see's nothing she did before
She's lost touch with her past self and doesn't recognize who she used to be.
Let's her colors hit the floor
She's revealing her true self and shedding any false pretenses.
Scars are in her name
Her name carries the memories of her mistakes and struggles.
And she scars me with blame
She's projecting her issues onto me, and it's taking an emotional toll on me.
Hey Scarlet, you're not the same
You've changed a lot, Scarlet, and I'm having a hard time adjusting to it.
So, be careful what you choose
You should be cautious and thoughtful about the decisions you make.
I felt love for me and you
I loved you, and I thought you loved me too.
I'm not ashamed
I have no shame or regret about the love I felt and gave to you.
As I walk another mile
As I continue on with my life.
I help you find out, child
I hope you discover what you're looking for in life, my dear.
I don't know what to do, I feel lost without you
I'm still unsure of how to move forward, and I miss you deeply.
Better love will come to you
I believe that you'll find a love that's even better suited for you eventually.
And so, I flew west to see her pride
I traveled out west to see her and the life she's built for herself.
Two weeks since the music died
It's been two weeks since we've seen each other and since our relationship ended.
I watch the camera shoot this girl
I see her in the spotlight and on camera, living a different life than before.
Seems to me a hollow pearl
It appears to me that underneath it all, she feels empty and unsatisfied.
Mother sat me down
My mother took the time to talk to me.
Oh, what's it like, oh my boy,
She asked me, 'What's it like, my dear son,'
To be so destroyed?
'To feel so broken and hurt?'
So I walk another mile
So I keep on going and moving forward.
To help you find out, child
To help you discover what you need to in order to be happy.
Better love will take you
I believe that a love even better suited for you will come your way.
So, here I sit, some years have passed
Time has gone by, and I'm sitting here thinking about everything that's happened.
I say I don't, but I miss her bad
I try to convince myself otherwise, but I miss her deeply.
I smell her in my sheets, you see
I can still smell her scent in my bed.
Like she's sleeping next to me
It's as if she's still sleeping next to me, and I can almost feel her presence.
She'll say,
In my mind, I hear her saying,
'Jack, I'm leaving now,
'Jack, I'm leaving now,
And don't you wait up for me,
'And don't you bother staying up for me,
Cause better love I'm yet to see.'
'Because I have yet to find a love that's even better suited for me.'
Lyrics © HIPGNOSIS SONGS GROUP, Peermusic Publishing, WORDS & MUSIC A DIV OF BIG DEAL MUSIC LLC, Warner Chappell Music, Inc.
Written by: JACK ANTONOFF
Lyrics Licensed & Provided by LyricFind