Why must I cry
These tears from mine eyes
Why must I cry
These tears from mine eyes

Making believe you love me only
(Just to love) was my great sin, whoa
(Just to love) was my great sin, whoa
(Just to love) was my great sin, whoa
(Just to love) was my great sin, whoa

But I will never fall in love again
'Cause only my heart feels the pain
Feels the pain

Why must I trod
This lonely, this lonely road
Why must I carry
This heavy, this heavy load

Making believe you love me only
(Just to love) was my great sin, whoa
(Just to love) was my great sin, whoa
(Just to love) was my great sin, whoa
(Just to love) hmm, my great sin

I'll never fall in love again
'Cause only my heart feels the pain
Feels the pain
Sad pain

I will never fall in love again
'Cause only my heart feels the pain
Feels the pain
Why must I cry
These tears from mine eyes
Why must I cry
These tears from mine eyes
Why must I trod
This lonely, lonely, lonely road
Why must I carry
This heavy, heavy, heavy load
Why must I cry
These tears from mine eyes
Why must I cry
These tears from mine eyes
Why must I trod

Overall Meaning

Peter Tosh's song "Why Must I Cry" talks about the pain of unrequited love. The lyrics talk about the hurt and tears that come from loving someone who does not love you back, and the heaviness that comes with carrying that pain alone. The song is an emotional plea for an end to the suffering caused by unrequited love.

The line "Making believe you love me only" suggests that the subject of the song is pretending to love the singer, leading to the singer's belief that there is a mutual feeling. However, the next line "Just to love was my great sin" suggests that the singer sees loving this person as a mistake. The repetitive phrase "Just to love" emphasizes the irony of the situation - the thing that caused the singer to feel so much pain was their own love.

The singer declares that they will "never fall in love again", because they cannot bear the pain of loving someone who does not reciprocate their feelings. The repeated phrase "only my heart feels the pain" emphasizes the loneliness that accompanies unrequited love. The final lines of the song repeat the questions "why must I cry" and "why must I trod this lonely road", indicating the singer's ongoing struggle to understand why they are experiencing such heartbreak.

Overall, "Why Must I Cry" is a powerful exploration of the pain of unrequited love. Through somber lyrics and a haunting melody, Peter Tosh captures the universal experience of heartbreak and the struggle to move on.

Line by Line Meaning

Why must I cry
Why do I have to suffer and cry?

These tears from mine eyes
These tears are a result of somebody else's actions, causing me deep pain.

Making believe you love me only
I was foolish to believe your deceptive claims of loving only me.

(Just to love) was my great sin, whoa
Loving you was a mistake and one of my greatest sins. It caused suffering and pain.

But I will never fall in love again
I have decided not to fall in love again due to the pain it brings.

'Cause only my heart feels the pain
Only my heart knows the depth of the pain that comes with loving someone who doesn't love back.

Why must I trod
Why do I have to walk alone and suffer through life?

This lonely, this lonely road
The pain and isolation of walking alone on this life's journey is too much to bear.

Why must I carry
Why do I have to bear the weight and pain of somebody else's actions?

This heavy, this heavy load
The emotional burden is too much to bear and is causing a lot of pain.

Sad pain
The pain caused by love and betrayal is particularly difficult to bear and leaves a deep hurt in the heart.