I imagine myself alone at Benny's eating the world's biggest slice
Across the room the payphone starts to ring
I'm chewing on ice Benny picks it up on his way to kick the jukebox
He grabs the phone and says it's for you
Now I grab the phone my hands are shaking
Hello you say
It's me now way
No way I wake up covered in makeup
Straight from a dream to nightmare
It seems I find myself alone again in Hoboken
I'm staring at payphones
I'm thinking of questions
I'm pressing the numbers in my head I'm staring att payphones
I'm staring at payphones
I'm thinking of questions
Hypothetical intellectual arguements I'm staring at payphones
Three months later I'm back at Benny's eating my pepperoni pie
Across the room the payphone starts to ring
I'm rubbing my eyes
Leona picks it up on her way to make a phone call
She grabs the phone and says it's for you
Now I'm not afraid of you or the payphone
Hello I say it's me
Go away in three months
I woke up
Got myself cleaned up
Thank you for seeing what I couldn't see
Things could be worse than being alone again in Hoboken

Overall Meaning

The lyrics of Dan Potthast's "Staring at Payphones" tell a story of a person imagining themselves at Benny's, a pizza place, where they see a payphone ringing. When Benny picks up the phone and hands it over to the singer, they hear a voice that surprises them, causing them to shake with nerves. The song then shifts to a dream-like sequence where the singer wakes up to find themselves covered in makeup, transitioning from a dream-state to a nightmare. They find themselves alone in Hoboken staring at payphones, pondering questions and intellectual arguments, suggesting a sense of loneliness and feeling lost.

The lyrics then transition to a scene three months later back at Benny's, where the payphone rings, and the singer is no longer afraid. Leona picks up the phone, and it's once again for the singer, who answers confidently. They tell the person on the other end to go away in three months but then, in the end, become thankful, realizing that things could be worse than being alone.

The song is about feeling lost and alone in the world, but it is also about finding the strength to overcome that fear and realize that being alone is not the worst thing that can happen. It is a reminder that people come and go in our lives, but we must learn to adapt and embrace change.

Line by Line Meaning

I imagine myself alone at Benny's eating the world's biggest slice
I picture myself happily indulging in a huge pizza slice, content with being alone.

Across the room the payphone starts to ring
A phone in the distance begins to ring and catch my attention.

I'm chewing on ice Benny picks it up on his way to kick the jukebox
As I absentmindedly chew on ice, Benny walks to the jukebox while answering the ringing payphone.

He grabs the phone and says it's for you
Benny takes the phone call and tells me that it's for me.

Now I grab the phone my hands are shaking
My hands tremble as I take the phone call.

Hello you say
The person on the other end of the line greets me with a hello.

It's me now way
I am shocked and disbelieving that the caller is who they say they are.

No way I wake up covered in makeup
In disbelief, I imagine myself waking up from a dream in which I am wearing heavy makeup.

Straight from a dream to nightmare
I feel like I am experiencing a bad dream.

It seems I find myself alone again in Hoboken
I come to the realization that I am once again by myself in Hoboken.

I'm staring at payphones
I am looking at the payphones, perhaps contemplating whether to make another call.

I'm thinking of questions
My mind is busy generating questions and ideas.

I'm pressing the numbers in my head I'm staring att payphones
In my mind, I am dialing numbers on the payphone's keypad while continuing to stare at it.

Hypothetical intellectual arguements I'm staring at payphones
I am considering different hypothetical and intellectually stimulating arguments while looking at the payphones.

Three months later I'm back at Benny's eating my pepperoni pie
Some time passes, and I find myself back at Benny's, savoring a slice of pepperoni pizza.

Across the room the payphone starts to ring
Once again, a payphone in the vicinity begins to ring and catch my attention.

I'm rubbing my eyes
I am rubbing my eyes, perhaps still tired or disoriented.

Leona picks it up on her way to make a phone call
Someone named Leona takes the phone call as she is on her way to make one herself.

She grabs the phone and says it's for you
Leona lets me know that the call is for me.

Now I'm not afraid of you or the payphone
I am no longer scared of the caller or the payphone itself.

Hello I say it's me
I greet the caller, informing them that it is me who they are calling.

Go away in three months
I request that the caller leave me alone for the next three months.

I woke up
I have had a realization or an awakening of sorts.

Got myself cleaned up
I have taken steps to clean up or improve my situation.

Thank you for seeing what I couldn't see
I express gratitude to the caller for helping me see something that I couldn't on my own.

Things could be worse than being alone again in Hoboken
I come to the understanding that things could be even worse than being alone in Hoboken, and I take some comfort in that thought.

Contributed by Declan E. Suggest a correction in the comments below.

To comment on or correct specific content, highlight it