There But For Fortune
Joan Baez Lyrics
Jump to: Overall Meaning ↴ Line by Line Meaning ↴
Show me a prisoner whose face has gone pale
And I'll show you a young man with so many reasons why
And there but for fortune, may go you or I
Show me the alley, show me the train,
Show me a hobo who sleeps out in the rain,
And I'll show you a young man with so many reasons why
There but for fortune, may go you or go I you and I.
Show me the whiskey stains on the floor,
Show me the dunkin' man as he stumbles out the door,
And I'll show you a young man with so many reasons why
There but for fortune, may go you or go I you and I.
Show me the country where bombs had to fall,
Show me the ruins of buildings once so tall,
And I'll show you a young land with so many reasons why
There but for fortune, go you or go I you and I.
You and I,
There but for fortune, go you or go I you and I.
The lyrics of Joan Baez's song There But For Fortune bring attention to the injustices and hardships faced by different people in society. The first verse depicts a young man in jail, whose face has gone pale due to the overwhelming number of reasons he has for being there. The second verse shows a hobo sleeping out in the rain, which serves as a reminder that anyone could find themselves in a similar position due to circumstances beyond their control. The third verse mentions a drunken man stumbling out the door, further highlighting the struggles that some people face on a daily basis.
The final verse brings to light the effects of war on a country and its citizens. Joan Baez sings about the ruins of buildings once so tall, and the profound impact that bombs falling have had on the land and its inhabitants. Through this verse and the others, Baez reminds us that everyone is susceptible to hardships and struggles, even those who may seem distant from our own lives.
Overall, the song encourages empathy and understanding towards those who may not have access to the same privileges and opportunities as others. It teaches us to be grateful for the things we have and to acknowledge that there are always reasons why someone may be in a difficult situation.
Line by Line Meaning
Show me a prison, show me a jail,
If you show me a prison and a jail, display me a prisoner who has suffered and become pale, and I will display a young man who has experienced many injustices and reasons to hurt.
And I'll show you a young man with so many reasons why
If you show me a person who has been through pain, you'll see someone who has been given many reasons as to why they've ended up in that situation.
There but for fortune, may go you or I
Life is unpredictable, and if we're not careful, we may end up in a similar situation; it could have been us instead of them.
Show me the alley, show me the train,
If you point me to the alleyways and trains, or any place where people suffer, or those who live outside in the rain, then I will show you a person who has faced similar issues.
There but for fortune, may go you or go I you and I.
We must be empathetic towards others and accept the fact that life's circumstances could have been different for either of us, given the current situation.
Show me the whiskey stains on the floor,
If you lead me to places with whiskey stains on the ground or show me people who have had unusually destructive habits, then I could show you a person who has faced similar problems that led them to be there.
Show me the dunkin' man as he stumbles out the door,
If you show me a person leaving a place, worried or anxious, then I might show you a person who has been caught up in similar issues.
Show me the country where bombs had to fall,
If you show me any place affected by war, where homes and buildings have been destroyed, then I could show a young person who has experienced similar hardship.
Show me the ruins of buildings once so tall,
If you show me the destruction of tall buildings or structures caused by bombs, then I would show you a young country whose life has been severely altered.
And I'll show you a young land with so many reasons why
If you show me a place with ruins and destruction, then I will show you a young community trying to justify their situation with many reasons as to why they ended up there.
There but for fortune, go you or go I you and I.
No one is immune to fate; life's circumstances have the power to change anyone's destiny, including our own.
Lyrics © O/B/O APRA AMCOS
Written by: PHIL OCHS
Lyrics Licensed & Provided by LyricFind
@avasouth920
I found her when I was 25 or so. I'm 81 now and have never found anyone to compare with dear Joan.
@tedkelley4481
Ava South seventy and I feel the same and I've loved a few
@TheOilkd
I have a similar history. I first saw her at 16 and I'm 72 now. Love her music and her humanity.
@claudiegloro2317
No, I think you were around 15 ! 😀
@claudiegloro2317
Ava South : because I’m the same in France. But I’m 72.. friendly.
@philipnorris6542
Nice one, Ava; I'm now 66.
@folkmusicgirl
Yes, I have to agree 100 % that this is the finest version of this song. This is the very first song I ever heard by Joan Baez many years ago when I was really, really young and I just was stunned that here was this voice singing on the radio and the most beautiful voice I had ever heard. The dj announced afterwards, that it was this folk singer named Joan Baez and I became a fan right there and then and forever more.
@user-ch5qd3uz3l
joan is a national treasure, and her version is tops, but the original phil version is the best imo
considering his history, the "show me the whiskey stains on the floor" hits a lot harder in the original
@UrrmmWut...
My parents had a cassette tape with this song and at 5 or 6 yrs old (born in 79) i fell in love with folk music . Id listen to that tape on repeat lol. I found it the other day still in tact somehow! The other songs on it were: Michael, Green,Green, this land is your land, you were on my mind, Guantanamera, where have all the flowers gone, greenfields, crooked little man, little boxes(which at 6 i thought was not only a great song but also hilarious😂😂) Ill never find another you, &walk right in. Still love these songs today😊
@butfulmuzik
A brilliant, haunting song by a man who was just too beautiful and sensitive to stay in this world. Add to that the voice of my guardian angel, Joan Baez, and you just have to listen to the truth of that song. One of the finest songs and one of the finest interpretations ever.