Well, not entirely. Here's some good relationships.

Whitestorm - Willowpelt
Sorreltail (Whitestorm and Willowpelt's daughter) - Brackenfur
Honeyfern (Sorreltail x Brackenfur's daughter) - Berrynose (he may have been prickly but he did love her)
Poppyfrost (Sorreltail x Brackenfur's daughter) - Berrynose (second verse, same as the first)
Cinderheart (Sorreltail x Brackenfur's daughter) - Lionblaze
Lilyheart (Sorreltail x Brackenfur's daughter) - Snowbush
Fernsong (Cinderheart x Lionblaze's son) - Ivypool
Sorrelstripe (Cinderheart x Lionblaze's daughter) - Dewnose
Spotfur (Cinderheart x Lionblaze's daughter) - Stemleaf

Erika ‘KittyPet’ Jaguire

5y↑174

BlueStar’s Big Mistake(s)

…

Most of her entire life and life choices.

jk

....

But still! Come on! When someone tells you that your ‘most trusted deputy’ is a cold blooded murderous killer, don’t just ‘meh’ those claims away! For the love of StarClan! Look into it a bit! Gosh dang it all. Sheesh.

....

jk

All comments from YouTube:

Bright Guardian Akira

5y↑196

Download Amino and search to join Warriors Amino: https://aminoapps.onelink.me/4eRt/BrightGuardianAkira
Follow me: Bright Guardian Akira

Cubaris sp. "Rubber Ducky"

Guardian bright akira

Bullet Storm

I just hate blue star and imma tell you why 1 she is not a supportive sister when snowfur and thistleclaw became mates even though she dated oakheart who is a river cat and may I remind u it’s against the warrrior code to date
another cat from a another clan and number two she is the reason swiftpaw died cause if she made swift paw and bright heart warriors swift paw would have never attacked the dogs and gets killed and then she was supposed to make brightpaw a warrior and named her a cruel name lostface

ChipChip knockout

Yeah but without the bluefur and oakheart ship we wouldn't have blue star

Juicymango

Warriors amino

got banned yeee

L.Z.

I joined Warrior Amino and your’s too!

12 More Replies...

pinkbunnygirl43

5y↑210

Woah! I just started Oakheart’s week of speedpaints and literally recording audio expressing my exact same thoughts like 3 days ago! Small world! Lol.

Millie Dean

3y↑2

@Pinkbunnygirl43 i love your warrior cats moves sooooooo much!!!!!!!!!!!!

hollowspirit

4y↑6

@path/raze bruh its her, it has the verified mark

Cat lady

4y↑6

path/raze really dude

path/raze

5y↑2

you just want likes fker

KoolKeldeo 105

5y↑467

Another thing; White-eye was nursing kits around the time Bluefur made that choice. So, if she *actually talked with Sunstar and White-eye*, she could've had it arranged to where White-eye would nurse Bluefur's kits while she was busy with deputy duties.
sarcastic slow clapping Great job, Bluefur!

G.D. Graham

2y↑1

Ouch

VioletSkiy

3y↑2

Sunstar didn't seem to want to give any leway but then again, she could of explained it to him

TheeVenison Productions

3y↑7

White-eye’s kits were three moons older. They must have been weaned

DragonQuill

4y↑16

That would have been a good idea. Or maybe talking to Thrushpelt as well. He loved her kits so much I think he would have been more than happy to take care of them after they were weaned and while Bluefur was taking care of her deputy duties. He would have made a great den dad:)

Flame

Flim No, he did not. I’ve read bluestars prophecy.

7 More Replies...

Phantom StarsX

3y↑78

Let's be honest, Goosefeather played a HUGE part in bluefurs conviction and belief. everything was working against bluefur, and we know she later regretted it. Bluestar literally went insane, and the grief of the past played aa big part in that.

Patrick May

5y↑295

bluestar: wow, thistleclaw sure is evil. i better not let him become leader!
also blustar, moons later: huh, lionhearts dead? i guess i'll make my mortal enemy's former apprentice my deputy! nothing bad could come of that!

G.D. Graham

2y↑1

Unfortunately yes

3amHellbeast

2y↑6

@Yawning Lion True, but at that point it's not like she could catch on that her next deputy would die either? (And not by Tigerclaw lol, otherwise she never would have picked him). She was in denial about Tigerclaw and saw him as a strong competent deputy... which Honestly if you take out Ravenpaw seeing Tigerclaw kill someone (which Bluestar refused to believe) he would seem like the best choice at the time. After all, in her book she was always more worried about Whitestorm being more like his father because of his genetics then Tigerclaw, to the point in where even Firestar was confused about Bluestar's treatment of Whitestorm. That being said it's been a really long time since I've read the first arc and Bluestar's book, but I always really liked Whitestorm and always thought that Bluestar gave him the short end of the stick.
I also believe that her mental decline didn't help with this either. After losing Oakheart, Redtail, Spottedleaf, and Lionheart so quickly, her old thoughts and trust issues really took hold of her and I wouldn't be surprised if that included her worries on Whitestorm... even though he proved time and time again that he's a good boy with good intentions and was nothing like his father. She was kind of doubting everyone at the time and was falling apart not just as a leader but as a person too.

Yawning Lion

2y↑5

@3amHellbeast Alternatively, maybe Bluestar didn't promote him because he was family and she was worried that he'd die like Redtail and Lionheart did.

3amHellbeast

2y↑5

@Yawning Lion Whitestorm still would have been better then Tigerclaw, he was a great deputy for Firestar! But nah cause Whitestorm is Thistleclaw's son and apparently that makes him sooo much worse then Tigerclaw somehow. I'm kinda glad he wasn't chosen though cause Tigerclaw would have probably taken him out too (then again that could mean getting Longtail as Firestar's possible first deputy though and that would have been cool

Yawning Lion

2y↑6

TBF, who were her options? Whitestorm, Tigerclaw, and... Darkstripe??? Obviously it should've been Whitestorm, but ThunderClan was also dealing with RiverClan and Brokenstar's ShadowClan so they needed some strength in their corner.

2 More Replies...

bridget mcalister

5y↑716

Bluestar's Big Mistake...
Making Tigerstar deputy.

•ChînchxllåQvQ•

The series would've been over by fos

G.D. Graham

True

Julie Dillion

@Rowanheart YES WHITESTAR!!!! WE DESERVE WHITESTAR!!!! HECK YEAH!! Too bad BlueStar didn't make WhiteStorm Deputy 💔

Nick's_paws (alt)

@lodgimoss || ignore old comments its not tiger heart its tiger claw ^^ i read the books

InnerBeast

3y↑3

Is it strange how Bluestar had so much trust in Tigerclaw even though he was trained by Thistleclaw

22 More Replies...

Doc Digit

5y↑105

BlueStars mistake?

NAMING A CAT LOST FACE

Kiki Bukoski

2y↑3

Brightheart was basically a teenager when THAT happened, and I said in another reply that an Amino kid trashed Bluestar for it

Sassy canines

2y↑3

So true

Joe Mama

4y↑39

Does anyone else agree that Bluestar's Prophecy is the SADDEST book? It's just my opinion but I was up at 4am reading about Mosskit's death CRYING. Lmao

Edit: I also cried in Moonflower's death, Sunfall talking to Bluepaw about needing to move on, Snowfur's death, Bluefur telling Whitekit about Snowfur's death, Bluefur telling Oakheart that they can't be together, and of course when it talked about them searching the camp for an entire moon looking for the 'lost' kits.

2SimpleOfAMango

2y↑3

What about Goosefetaher or Sweetpaw? Sweetpaw got poisoned and was in a coma

?krynn?

2y↑1

mhm, and Crookedstar's promise

butterstick rose

2y↑1

Yeah I cried on that book a lot😭😭
Tallstars book was pretty sad too😭

Pupgod

5y↑49

Sunstar could’ve chosen Thrushpelt he had spottedleaf when she was doing warriors training and sunstar wanted someone young Thrushpelt is young he also had a apprentice which is a requirement of being deputy I think the Erin’s just wanted drama so they ignore this factor but Bluestar’s prophecy is still a good book

Hadès

5y↑33

Nice video. I totally agree with you.
It always bugged me when people complain how Bluestar didn't choose Thrushpelt when he was so nice. Well, for one, she didn't love him. And for two, she didn't love him. I mean, honestly, no matter how nice someone's nice to you, you're not gonna force yourself to have feelings for him, and it's not gonna make you a horrible person. The whole point of Thrushpelt is that he perfectly understand it.

sherlockhoots

5y↑64

I can agree with her biggest mistake but not the part about Oakheart. I as a BlueOak shipper am of course here to defend my ship!!!:

I don't agree with your part on Oakheart being a person she was curious about but didn't want any future commitments with because she and Oak are mates in Starclan. Surely if that was the case you'd think she'd like Oakheart for a bit more then his looks and reputation. I think Oakheart and Bluestar is a perfect pairing. On one side you have Bluestar, a cynical character who constantly is living in the past and never lets go of death. Then you have Oakheart who despite having a brave exterior is a fun-loving character who cares more for the future and recognizes that life just goes on. Two complete opposites who compliment each other a lot. It does a lot more than say Crookedstar and Bluestar because they're too similar to be anything more then friends. They recognize each other as respected leaders but Crookedstar is too loyal and would probably be too serious for Bluestar. Bluestar acted like a whole different person when around Oakheart but in the end she was the more responsible one and Oakheart wasn't too good when it came to decision making. That's when their relationship hit a turn when kits were introduced. Bluestar however being the responsible one took them to Riverclan and was a moment of development for Oakheart to step up and act like a real deputy would and take the kits in. However after Bluestar losing another life at her paws for probably nothing and having no one to comfort her she probably wouldn't find her way back to Oakheart. As well as that Oakheart learning more about responsibility from Bluestar and him having to raise two kits now he left part of his fun-loving self behind with their relationship to instead focus on priorities. Of course this doesn't mark the end of their relationship just for Bluestar's Prophecy. A bit more development in the main series and then they meet in Starclan and get to be themselves.

So in conclusion their opposite personalities happened to make them the perfect pair but of course caused future strain in their relationship at least until they both met in Starclan again.

•ChînchxllåQvQ•

2y↑1

I had no idea there was an essay hidden under the read more button.
Time to read it all

Kl0diana

2y↑2

okay, but bluefur was idiotic taking them to Riverclan, during a harsh leafbare, poor mosskit.

maryan adote

"Oakheart is super hooooooot" xd

Tune Aj

5y↑15

I always noticed a parallel between Bluestar and Snowfur with their love interests.
Snowfur and Bluefur used to think Oakheart was a cocky, arrogant warrior, only Bluefur realized he wasn't later. Though Snowfur still insisted he was.
Bluefur thought that Thistleclaw was also cocky and arrogant, as well as very fierce with others. Snowfur didn't, and was mooning over him since apprenticehood.
They were also wrong in their own way-
Oakheart and Bluefur was illegal.
Thistleclaw was actually a bad, fierce cat according to the books(though I don't really go with Spottedleaf's Heart as being canon, OotS was still a thing).

h.ad3s

5y↑77

Actually, Bluestar’s biggest mistake was renaming Brightpaw to Lostface. Change my mind.

edit: y'all its been 3 years. give me a break pls

h.ad3s

@Zuki that's... entirely incorrect, but thanks

h.ad3s

@Zuki i'd rather not argue further but, go on?

h.ad3s

@Zuki understandable

h.ad3s

@Zuki i'm sorry for the argument with the other user, i didn't mean to start a real fight

📺RadioHost_Vox🎬

1y↑1

@Zuki don’t give me that bullshit. Not all apprentices are perfect at all. Again she probably wanted to have fun considering for several moons before her apprenticeship she wasn’t allowed to go out so she wanted to explore. In warrior standards sure that may be a bit childish but what do you expect!?

9 More Replies...

uhhh

5y↑225

Ye blue star makes many mistakes but she learns from them

리안 이

@TheMythicalNeko lol

G.D. Graham

@TheMythicalNeko Lol

i am tomato

4y↑5

Union Pacific #844
well obviously you can't learn anything if you're dead, but from the trip she learned her clan wasn't traitors

Ambermoon

4y↑4

She didn't learn from her deadly mistake of jumping onto the dog

TheMythicalNeko

5y↑8

@King Namor 777 you are right. Bluestar is a great leader once you look at her from a certain point of view.

3 More Replies...

Qiqi wants Cocogoat milk and a happy meal

3y↑7

Honestly, I feel that Bluestar was mentally ill

While she was in grief for her relatives, and corrupted by Goosefeather’s prophecies, she thought about thistleclaw becoming deputy ruining the clan, all of that caused her to not think straight, which leads to her sacrificing her kits

When everything went wrong with the deputies she chose, she felt as if it wasn’t worth it. She felt like everything that she did was worthless. So she battled with Starclan thinking they were to blame for everything she went through (the prophecy). She felt like she was destined to suffer

Vigy

5y↑14

Honestly, If Bluefur had just gone up to Sunstar and said, "Trust me, Thistleclaw if not a good choice. He will be the downfall of Thunderclan." Then Sunstar would believe her, he loved her as his own daughter, and trusted her. Sigh, Thrushpelt might have been a good leader, who knows.

Toboe

5y↑333

Bluestar made many mistakes.
I think her worst mistake was bringing Snowfur to thunderpath were she died.
Without her dying, the complete story would be different.

Btw I really don't like Bluestar and her relationship with Oakheart because it was so out of the blue.

☆ Bubbles ☆

It was Snowfur who ran into the street and decided to chase them off, also Leopardfoot told her because she didn't want to hear Snowfur grunting all the time, and Bluefur didn't know there was Thunderpath

Frosted Felony

like a one night stand- I think that was the point (probably?? Idk--)

Suchomimus Tenerensis

3y↑1

Heh, out of the BLUE

abbie

3y↑1

how long has it been since you read her special? Snowfur's death was an accident and the result of trying to chase cats of the territory she wasnt led there and if anything Bluefur wanted them to stay away from the cats and leave to get a patrol

The Reptile

Nice pun

27 More Replies...

Willow Mewo

5y↑82

Bluestar: nah I wont have kits.

A month later

Bluestar: Oakheart you'll be a father
Oakheart: what?

Artisam Gamer

3y↑5

Can we also talk about the pure grief she caused Thrushpelt when she said the kits died? Like how afterwards he was described as grieving like a father would.
Also the trama she gave to Brightheart was unmistakable.

IcyFeathers

3y↑6

Okay, sure, Thrushpelt might’ve been nice, but even if they’re nice then you still don’t have to downright LOVE them! There are plenty of nice people with crushes that aren’t returned in the world, hahaaa.
Basically, not Bluefur’s fault that she didn’t like Thrushpelt all that much.

_beanbag_

4y↑8

It seems that bad choice in a mate runs in Bluestar’s family.
Moonflower: Stormtail
Bluefur: Oakheart
Mistystar: Blackclaw (supposedly)
Snowfur: Thistleclaw (added by Silverflare)

Numberjacks Octonauts

3y↑2

flareyberry

GlitchedWind Snowfur: Thistleclaw

-CHIXIE-

4y↑17

Bluestar: I need to save my clan *sacrifices almost everything she has ya know cuz why not*

Starclan: lololololol only fire will save the clan

Great video akira

Ariana Marie

5y↑3

What about Goosefeather? Sure, he gave her the prophecy, but he was also pressing her to become deputy. All I can say is, that I can relate to Bluestar in some way, because she's the type of character that doesn't work well under pressure and suffering.

pls kill me papi

4y↑3

I simply adore Bluestar! But feel like they could've done more with her character. I think the only real mistake she made was naming Brightheart Lostface but she was still as I would put it "Mad as a hatter" and still grieving over who she lost which was I guess around 6 cats. But it was still a no-no on her part.

pls kill me papi

4y↑1

And OOF I wish Sunstar would've told her sooooner >:(

pls kill me papi

4y↑2

And I agree with Akira she did live a life of loss and just needed someone to lean on, we all do. I think Sunstar was the only one who was guiding her the right way along with Rosetail and Goosefeather.

Hannah Starr

4y↑10

Honestly when I read the book, I was really disappointed that Bluestar didn't end up with Thrushpelt. He was kind, generous, and obviously loved her.

Hyena Edits

5y↑2

I like Bluestar because she's such a complex character. She tries to do the right thing but she messes up big time and has to live with the consequences, which is a very relatable conflict. And I think in the end, for most of her life, she was able to rise above the mistakes she made in the past and become a great leader.

King Namor 777

5y↑2

In my opinion Bluestar is calm and wise soul. Who made a lot of hard and difficult choices in her past. Then in the present she lose three Thunderclan deputy and good Thunderclan cats die. Everything she done to save the clans did nothing, even giving up her own family didn't change the darkest events to unfold.

So she put all her faith and hope in a flames colored ginger tom from Two-leg place. Who was once rised as a kittypet named rusty with a compassionate and selfless heart. Bluestar taught her new apprentice/adopted son as true member of her family and teach him ways of the warrior code in order to rewrite the mistakes of the past and add light in the darkness, confusion during those chaos times of Brokenstar and Tigerstar.

crocuspetals

5y↑113

I have like these super mixed feelings about Bluestar. 😂

Jayden Robinson

5y↑3

Is it just me or does Akira have such a fun voice I love it

festive eggnog

5y↑2

I love love love love LOVE how you designed ThrushPelt!!! 😍

Manisha.Walletje

5y↑63

Bluestar is actually one of my favorite warrior cats characters

Meowth

5y↑3

I watched the minute this was posted!
But Bluestar learned from some of her mistakes. Most of these weren't her fault. Like, being angry after her sis and her mom passed. I am still heartbroken that my Grandpa died, and it has been months!

Holly Gonzales

5y↑5

Who else heard Akira slowly dying at the beginning talking about "making kits" 😆😆

josie758

2y↑1

I feel like a lot of Bluestar’s decisions were influenced by the fact she grew up around loss. It’s the only thing she knew. It’s like how kids in abusive households grow up to find partners who abuse them. They gravitate toward trauma because it’s what they know. The same could be said for Bluestar. Desperate and searching for a quick fix to her problems, she gravitated to the only thing she knew— loss. She would lose her kits to save her clan, because she knew how to navigate loss and knew how that particular grief felt.

cathacker

5y↑189

....Mosskit? Moss... SHE EXISTED FOR A SKIT..?

Leafpaw1

@•ChînchxllåQvQ• death was plot relevant n nothing else

•ChînchxllåQvQ•

Mo's skit
Who is mo and why did this kit have to die for his skit

cabinboycott

5y↑6

Mosskit isn't mentioned in the Forest of Secrets?
And besides, that's ONE book, plus there has been many mistakes in the series, one book doesn't change a thing!

tea z

5y↑3

@malpharynx Mosskit is called a tom in Forest of Secrets.

malpharynx

5y↑7

@• CloudyWeather • Nope its a she. But the cats of the clans said she was. That was because that book is always wrong

3 More Replies...

tiger löwe

5y↑1

Reading all these comments leaves me with only one question.

Am I the only one here who actually likes Bluestar ?

She is still one of my favourite characters and leaders. She made a lot of bad decisions, but she was a good leader imo, had a hard life and not everything was her fault nor in her control. And still she always tried to be there for her clan despite everything she went through. Idk about you, but I'd feel the same way, if I was in her situation.

Change my mind !

CloverMoon Studios

5y↑55

I got a cute idea for an animation, basically a group of kits following an Egyptian Mau to the song "walk like an Egyptian" :3

CobaltChono

But they are in Jojo part 3 cosplay

Bluepaw WARRIORS

5y↑8

"Dont judge anyone by there choices when you don't know what choices they had"

Erika ‘KittyPet’ Jaguire

5y↑174

Louise Bryant

@Novima Movies Sigh

Novima Movies

I will never forgive her for Lostface

Dino Girl

5y↑3

Yeah but she did listen once but firestar was suspecting redtail of breaking the warrior code

Ruby The Ruby

2y↑1

To be honest I didn't have any trouble with her giving the kits at the end of the book, that desicion made sense but I feel like they should've explored bluefur and Oakheart more. I think the way akira thinks of bluefur's mindset makes sense but there really is no hints in the book to make that conclusion while reading it. And since we only see them spend true quality time together once at fourtrees, it feels very weird. Love your explanation tho akira!

Homosexual Spaghetti

Bluestar’s prophecy was so sad tho, now that I reread it it’s so full of emotional moments it gives me goosebumps

King Namor 777

I love Bluestar as wise and calm leader of Thunderclan during the first couple of books before she got crazy. I only hate the bad choices she made in the past and present. Which is no different than a human in history or today making similar mistakes like Bluestar.

CallmeTrigg

5y↑2

In any picture of Oakheart he ALWAYS looks charming and nice I’ve never seen a picture of him that’s not charming and nice.It gives him a better reputation.

Honestly Sleeping

Could you possibly due a video on Yellowfang when she basically lied to Squirrelflight about kits and pressured her into claiming the kits as her own. I think it would be very interesting to hear your thoughts about it. Leafpools wish is still my least favorite book to this day.

RaiGuy

5y↑2

I don't believe what Sunstar said meant he wasn't going to choose Thistleclaw just that he was glad he didn't have to for those reasons but if Bluefur had kept her kits he definitely was going to choose him so her sacrifice wasn't wasteful.

Frostwing

5y↑5

Pleaaaasseee do more vids more often they are so entertaining and I ABSOLUTELY love them!

cathacker

5y↑35

Nooo! Her biggest mistake was having unreal fur schemes. WHAT TYPE OF CAT HAS PURPLE-GREY-BLUE fur? DARNIT BLUESTAR. (I know it’s not her fault it’s the writing team-her parents) Sorry Bluestar but it had to be said.

woofcat

Patches Roll Lilac cats are a light creamish brown

Koharu Yuki V3

5y↑2

@• CloudyWeather • Russian blues are gray or extremely light blue. My friend has a Russian blue cat, and it is not a purple blue.

Koharu Yuki V3

I always think about how if Bluestar had kits with Tigerclaw they would all be purple or black.....

sherlockhoots

5y↑3

While genetically she's not a Russian Blue the Erin's don't care about genetics. They base pelt colours of actual cats including purebred ones. So while she may not be a Russian Blue by realism, her pelt colour is definitely based off one.

Salami

My oc has the same fur color

4 More Replies...

Kitty The Cat

5y↑2

Bluestar could have said “I found these kits out in the snow and I would like a Queen/cat to take care of them so they can be a member of ThunderClan.” Or something like that

butterstick rose

Yeah but by then the cats had noticed how pregnant Bluestar was

Rutt Kongas

4y↑5

Well, I ship BluestarxOakheart. Maybe yes, it wasn't the best decicion for her to make, but still, I feel so glad that they finally got back together.

Blep

Some of Bluestars mistakes:
Taking Oakheart as her mate
Lying to her clan mates
Taking Snowfur to the Thunderpath
Taking her kits to Riverclan instead of letting the clan raise them while she was deptuty
Picking Tigerclaw as her deputy
Naming Brightheart as Lostface,
And there’s probably MANY MANY more...

Helena's inky hour

So, I have strong views on love and I believe a person should follow their heart and find someone who they love and they love them back. But Thrushpelt is an example of the man you wanna strive for, one that cares about the relationship more than having children, because kids is decided later out of love not bargaining

Crimsonilla

5y↑1

I’m so close to finishing Bluestar’s Prophecy!

twigbranch45

1y↑1

thrushpelt is the sweetest little angel ever and honestly he deserves someone better than bluestar

frostdragon64

Funny Bluestar followed the 'prophecies' concerning herself, but ignored the others. She spent so much worrying about Thistleclaw it costed the life of one of her kits. 'But Goosefeather said-' Goosefeather also pointed out Tigerkit, and Bluefur witnessed Tigerpaw being overly aggressive but completely ignored it. But became surprised when Tigerclaw aIf anything from starclan doesn't involve her, who cares? She had all this proof about him being a bad cat, but ignored it. All she had to do was talk to Sunstar. Or even help guide his choice. But oh well, 'the prophecy is about me, I need to do this'.

Fight4Kyla

4y↑5

Bluestar in Into the wild: Welcome firepaw
Bluestar in Fire and Ice: find windclan
Bluestar in Forest of secrets: Yes mistyfoot and stonefur were my kits
Bluestar in Rising Storm: RUN THERES A FIRE!!!!
Bluestar in A Dangerous Path: YOURE ALL TRAITORS

Daydream

2y↑1

Very true

Amanda Sproul

I mean, technically, Blue-Fur saw Thistle-Claw in blood one time, but what if she saw Thistle-Claw kill a cat in the Dark Forest before Spotted-Leaf, especially if she was still Blue-paw then? That'd make even more sense for her to hate him.

Snowblur Studios

5y↑54

Now I wanna make an au where bluefur and thrushpelt became mates and had kits. Idk TwT

moonberry

Do it! I would definitely read that.

KarunaMaya

I'd watch that.

Ambermoon

4y↑5

JUST DO IT DONT LET YOU DREAMS BE DREAMS

LaureleiWolf

I agree a hundred percent with you! BlueStar could of been a little more smarter

CuriousConflict

Bluestar has made ALOT more than just one mistake, she had been mates with oakheart, a RIVERCLAN warrior and then, she gave up the kits she had to become deputy even though giving up the kits had destroyed her completly, and after that, when bluestar became leader, she had actually rejected her clan, causing fireheart to need to act as leader, then bluestar even began to dislike star clan so, so much for "clan over kin!"

Miss Ryuza

I always saw the naming of "Lostface" as her greatest mistake. She let her spite and paranoia lead her to make decisions that badly affect those around her, directly hurting Brightpaw and her self-esteem in the process.

FuntimeXXWarrior

Here's one problem I have with Bluestar's Prophecy...

Why can't Sunstar pick someone else as deputy? Now I know that Bluefur obviously become Bluestar, but couldn't there be a time skip between the chosen cat dying or have it a little earlier than we expect?

ChirriMaple

5y↑536

Well it is true that oakheart is super hot

Sue Bauwens

Littlefluffydino13: Oh, God... Facepalm

☆ Bubbles ☆

Nope, Oakheart is a cat, and cats are cute not hot LOL

♧•woollytail•♧

@Manymomath so😽am😎i💜

Shraddha Anikhindi

I agree, at least the cartoon version of him. And he even acted cool. And I am fully in favor of “forbidden love” which shouldn’t at all be forbidden.

♧•woollytail•♧

Indeed 🤭

23 More Replies...

JvstJaci

5y↑2

is there a problem with not loving someone back? bluestar just didn't like thrushpelt, it's called attraction

Nightshade

5y↑23

Bluestar is me glaring at my teacher in math

A.KitCat.B

Bluestar made a lot of decisions wisely but some were in desperation or misjudging others actions. I relate too much to that.

TJ The Entertainer

Poor Bluestar. She thought that if she didn’t develop relationships and only focusing on her goal to become leader, it wouldn’t hurt anybody. But it turned out, it hurt herself and her clan mates more

Starflame

5y↑4

OakBlue wasn’t so match a forbidden romance as it was a forbidden hookup

Catra is Adora-ble

2y↑1

Ok but here's the thing. Just because there's a "perfect" other cat for her to be mates with, it's not who she loves. You wouldn't date someone you didn't like just because they lived near you and you couldn't afford to move to live near your true love.

(This was before I watched the whole video.)

Theresa Green

5y↑14

Please reply Akira: how do you get the ideas for your names and Characters?

Theresa Green

What about hawknose

•[🌺Pｉnk-shibe🌺]•

3y↑1

Bluestar is a grumpy cat mixed with a kind cat mixed with a fierce cat and mixed with a stressed cat.
Bluestar didn't deserve a bad life.
She had to suffer from PTSD after tigerclaw/star attacked him.
Atleast she sacrificed herself to save her clan and join starclan.

Lemony Cricket

5y↑66

#ThrushpeltDeservedBetter
I’ve seen it here in the comments already, but I nEED TO DO MY PART

• Amaris Rosalette •

3y↑1

Yeah bruhhh

Two dogs and a cat

Bluestar’s prophecy may be canon but I feel like it didn’t quite deliver on the perspective and motivations of Bluestar who I feel were justified

noir

5y↑6

Just realized

Oak heart and Blue stars’ eye colors match there fur

FlaminDorito

What's wrong with not wanting kits? I don't see how people criticize her for this

Nightshade

5y↑54

Bluestar mad a BIGGGG OOPSIEEE

sleepymorus

5y↑2

No hate, but I think I have a solution to the kits. Why couldn't one of the other queens take care of Bluestar's kits? I mean, It's way better and easier than selling them off to another clan. That way, Bluestar's kits could have loved her like their mother their whole life. #LikeIfyouagree

💚Commander ShatteredBlue💚

Normally I would agree with the whole Thrushpelt or Oakheart lose situation, but I’m in the same situation

Lawrence Townsend

3y↑1

Bluestar had a tragic life can't blame her for wanting to fall in love with oakheart so she can be happy.

Millie

4y↑3

Bluefur and Crookedjaw is the superior ship. How are you gonna write them interacting with each other and make her go with Oakheart??

📺RadioHost_Vox🎬

Bluestar is at the very least MID but it’s like the lowest rank of mid you could get

Storm Draws

5y↑4

That moment when you realize warriors actually contains a one night stand 😮

AFUniversCat

seeing mosskit climbing to starclan was way too sad...

Lyndsie Peet

5y↑9

You should make another video about what true fans would never say

Newtleaf

Trushpelt is so nice!! When bluestar gave up her kits he griefed like a true father! He even pretended to be like a true father! Oh God why does it have to be oak heart

bluebird

3y↑3

This is my take; Bluefur's relationship with Oakheart teaches the consequences of lust. Looking at it from an adult perspective, the two of them basically had a one night stand. And because of that, Bluefur got pregnant.

I've come to appreciate these little details in the Warriors series. They don't have to touch explicitly on sexual interactions. The way they handle it is very subtle. It is enough for a child to understand, but as we grow up, we come to find deeper meanings.

Lj Studios

Bluestar is my FAVORITE Warrior cat. How dare you criticize her.

afoodeater

5y↑8

I actually don’t ship Bluestar with Oakheart or Thrushpelt... I ship her with Crookedstar. Mainly because of their interactions at the gatherings in their super editions.

Floofs

4y↑1

Rip blue star she suffered losing her mother as a kit
Losing mosskit
Givingaway mistykit and stonekit
Oakheart her love died
Tigerclaw_star attacking her
Then she tries to tell her kits that she's there real mother but does not succed
And then she almost loses fireheart_star to dog attack
And then she died

•ChînchxllåQvQ•

Me: What horrible life-changing event could Bluestar have done?
sees oakheart on the cover
Me: here we go..

Sweetie Candy

5y↑9

Great vid can’t wait for the next

Spider Bugg

yet i still remember that bluestar stated that she wishes that she was mates with thrushpelt than oakheart, slightly regretting her decision to be with oakheart

kewlaid

Bluestar's big mistake, like you said. She slept with oakheart at fourtrees, and oakheart did something with her. And, she didn't know 'till someone pointed it out.

Kamryn Cottontail

Let’s be real, it’s not Bluestar’s fault she had to give up her kits! Would ThunderClan and us the readers want ThunderClan to go down under ThistleClaw’s evil rule? Let’s use our brains and be real people!

wow

At least you know how loyal she is

Mrs. JD D

The weirdest thing is that Oak'Heart is Silver'Stream's uncle and that Blue'Star is breaking the warrior code for forbidden romance and Gray'Stripe did that too,so,that's kind of weird! "0"

Spearmint Snakes

5y↑3

Bluestar? More like.... BOOstar
hAh
Edit: Thrushpelt is my little cinnamon roll. Honestly, he’s a good guy and also sweet. He’s definitely on my “Top 10 Warrior Cats” list.
Edit edit: Wanted to make it clear that the “BOOstar” thing was a joke. I like bluestar, but she made some bad decisions in life.

MischiefHowlVA

Bluestar's biggest mistake? Most of her life choices.

David Gannon

5y↑4

DO the Jayfeather fanfic already!

flareyberry

bluestar is lucky asf because thrush pelt was nice enough to protect her and her kits.

Cactus_Cat

5y↑75

First comment, LOVE YOU AKIRA. Btw, you said Tigerstar had dovewings kits with her. Ever heard the joke that when two cats sleep next to each other they have kits?

u w u

@King Namor 777 Wait what? Please elaborate O o O

King Namor 777

5y↑3

Warriors cat series is a youth/young adult novel. But the Erin know the book would reach the hands of children so they censor it. Just like a "Dangerous Path". No joke the new version of the book was missing pages when I was reading it.