Genre not found
Artist not found
Album not found
Song not found

8 Etudes Op. 42: No. 2 in F sharp minor
Alexander Scriabin Lyrics


No lyrics text found for this track.

The lyrics are frequently found in the comments by searching or by filtering for lyric videos
Most interesting comment from YouTube:

Paco Machado

If you can't feel these rhythms and polyrhythms, you can't play it (well). That is the fucker.

The advanced rhythm course in Amsterdam is very good. Also private lessons possible and a book to buy (get) when you start private lessons there. I don't know the teacher (s) there.

Also the drummer Peter Magadini has a pilyrhythm book out there. See links below.

I spent a lot of time finding this information. The good thing is that all these polyrhythms exercises makes the timing better and better.

The sad thing is that music colleges are usually not good with studying polyrhythms and not good with studying different feels behind and ahead of the beat. See video below.

If we play exactly on the click it sounds mechanical. Maybe good sometimes if the composer requires it, but I don't like to hear the phrase "On top of the beat". It is behind or ahead in many variations.

Many usually think good timing is something we are born with, but it is not true. For example to feel a group of five takes time, and playing with different feels takes time - and to learn to feel the different feels.

Also we hear that to play different rhythm feels are an intuitive thing. No. We need to dig deep into it. It's all about emotions too. To play something angry and aggressive behind the beat is not very realistic, is it. Or to play a love song ahead of the beat. We need to be emotionally connected. If we can't feel the rhythms and the rhythm feels, we can't put emotions into it. And music is about expressing emotions.

Maybe the Brahms violin concerto in D is a good example of different rhythms and different rhythms feels blended together in a superb way by the solo violin.

"The lion never attacks behind the beat".

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uyr2pBVyqvU

http://www.advancedrhythm.com
https://www.amazon.com/Polyrhythms-Musicians-Guide-Peter-Magadini/dp/0634032836
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=w0DtCmh0JI0



All comments from YouTube:

MoldySoup

The beauty contained within the fifth Étude drove me past the brink of tears.

Morgan Martinez

The difficulty of that piece is directly proportional to its beauty.

Aldo Rossi

The fifth is a deep homage to melancholy and sadness.

Classical Mountain

I barely can't hold my tears when I play this masterpiece.

Guillermo Badell

they are all wonderful but number 5 is just incredibly beautiful..full of Russian feeling, only meant for real virtuosos

Sean Riedy

The fifth etude, to me, is easily one of the best pieces of Scriabin's, if not of all time; not just for the raw musical value but also what it represents. This piece was written when Scriabin was forming his new harmonic system, and no doubt he was going a bit loony by then, practically psychotic by the end of his life. Listening to his earlier pieces you hear the strong tides and turbulence of his youthful emotions, but by the end of his life he has been consumed wholly by mysticism and eroticism. The fifth etude, as I hear it, is the last rebellion of a man who is going insane and knows it.

6 More Replies...

Daniel Tselyakov

Wow unbelievable, Ohlsson plays these extremely well! Made me feel like I was in flight in op. 42 n.5

Nghia Van

You should also listen to Horowitz’s performance, if you haven’t already

Daniel Tselyakov

@Nghia Van that was the first one I listened to! I love love Horowitz! However, Ohlssohn’s left hand technique is better than Horowitz. You hear every single note.

Where, Where

I think Scriabin reached same or more higher musical level than Chopin's Etude in this etude.
No.5 is of course good, but I especially prefer no.4 and no.8.
The dreamy and poetic mood of no.4 and the simple beauty and innocence of the theme of no.8, the contrasting and meditative mood of the middle part just melted my heart..

More Comments

More Versions