Why?
Andrew Bird Lyrics


Jump to: Overall Meaning ↴  Line by Line Meaning ↴

Why? Why'd you do that?
You shouldn't have done that
If I told you once, I told you three times
You'll get your punishment when you
Show me your crimes

It's not a spell or a curse you put on me
Or the way you smile so tenderly
But how I wish it was your temper you were throwing
Damn you for being so easygoing

I thought that time would tell
My sins would provoke you to raise some hell

Not a chance
Whatever happened to fiery romance
Oh how I wish it was those dishes you were throwing
Damn you for being so easygoing

No, don't give me that line
Don't try to tell me inaction is not a crime




Can't you see what kind of seeds you're sowing?
Damn you for being so easygoing

Overall Meaning

The lyrics of Andrew Bird's song "Why?" present a character who is resentful of someone close to them, addressed as "you", for being too easy-going and failing to react to their actions. The opening lines immediately establish a confrontational tone as the singer accuses the addressee of wrongdoing while expressing exasperation with their behavior: "Why'd you do that? You shouldn't have done that". The verses that follow reveal the source of the singer's frustration: they have been hoping to provoke a reaction from the addressee, to "show me your crimes", but have been disappointed so far. The sentiment is summed up in the refrain: "Damn you for being so easygoing".


The singer expresses a desire for a more tempestuous, passionate relationship, wishing that it was the addressee's "temper you were throwing" or that they were engaging in "fiery romance" instead of being maddeningly calm. However, they acknowledge that they are not blameless, saying "my sins would provoke you to raise some hell", but are ultimately dissatisfied with the status quo. The final lines of the song address the addressee directly, accusing them of "sowing" bad seeds by being too passive, and condemning their "inaction" as a "crime".


Line by Line Meaning

Why? Why'd you do that?
Expressing confusion and disbelief towards the actions or decisions made by the addressed person


You shouldn't have done that
Stating disapproval of the said actions by the addressed person


If I told you once, I told you three times
Implying that the addressed person was warned about the consequences of their actions beforehand


You'll get your punishment when you Show me your crimes
Implying that punishment will be served to the addressed person once their wrongdoings are exposed


It's not a spell or a curse you put on me Or the way you smile so tenderly
Rejecting the notion that the addressed person's charm or any external factor caused the singer's feelings


But how I wish it was your temper you were throwing Damn you for being so easygoing
Bemoaning the fact that the addressed person's calmness does not match the singer's passion or intensity


I thought that time would tell My sins would provoke you to raise some hell
Initially believing that the addressed person would eventually react negatively to the singer's mistakes


Not a chance Whatever happened to fiery romance
Realizing that the addressed person's personality does not match the singer's expectations for passion and drama


Oh how I wish it was those dishes you were throwing Damn you for being so easygoing
Once again lamenting the addressed person's lack of fiery emotion or reaction


No, don't give me that line Don't try to tell me inaction is not a crime
Rejecting any excuses or explanations for the addressed person's lack of action


Can't you see what kind of seeds you're sowing? Damn you for being so easygoing
Arguing that the addressed person's actions or lack thereof will have negative consequences in the long run




Lyrics © O/B/O APRA AMCOS

Lyrics Licensed & Provided by LyricFind
To comment on or correct specific content, highlight it

Genre not found
Artist not found
Album not found
Song not found
Most interesting comment from YouTube:

Han&Pret Zel

Why? Why'd you do that?
You shouldn't have done that
If I told you once, I told you three times
You'll get your punishment when you
Show me your crimes

It's not a spell or a curse you put on me
Or the way you smile so tenderly
But how I wish it was your temper you were throwing
Damn you for being so easygoing

I thought that time would tell
My sins would provoke you to raise some hell

Not a chance
Whatever happened to fiery romance
Oh how I wish it was those dishes you were throwing
Damn you for being so easygoing

No, don't give me that line
Don't try to tell me inaction is not a crime
Can't you see what kind of seeds you're sowing?
Damn you for being so easygoing



All comments from YouTube:

Jace Isham

As I watch him do impossible things with his fingers and command loops like a personal army, hear his lyrics, and hear his composition, it's harder and harder to get my around his talent. It's one thing to acquire multiple abilities out of necessity (as he did with guitar), but this man is a poet and a violinist in out of this world frequency. Oh humans.

kortana

seeing him do it live is even more baffling!

gabelogan56

You had me at "impossible things"

Eric Crapton

I've probably watched this thousands of times. What a master of music.

Ethan A

True artistry and mastery of his talent. 5:05 - 5:19 It's like watching a musical. It's like true theatrics of an amazing artist.

Bnjenkins26

And on top of his mindblowing performance, he's got the socks to match :D

Shaquille Oatmeal

I understand everything, literally everything, about this performance. It is staggering.

mamacans26

I cannot even begin to describe what happens to me, the feeling that takes over, when this man performs, when I hear his music... I just don't have the words...but I'll bet he does <3

Zeynep İrem Baş

It's so free and messy but it's still such an amazing song and the way he acts as he plays is really amazing

A. O.

Andrew Bird's music (recorded copies) are sooo good that imagining what he sounds like live is unimaginable.

More Comments

More Versions