The Wrong Man Was Convicted
Barenaked Ladies Lyrics


Jump to: Overall Meaning ↴  Line by Line Meaning ↴

Who's lonely now?
Which one of us is suffering?
Who's in his cups?
Which one of us recovering?
Who likes to look at pictures and cries, but way too late?
Who doesn't want to change a thing, accepting it was fate?

The wrong man was convicted
You know I did the deed
I thought that you would wait for me
Your wants I needn't heed
The wrong man lies beside you
And waits for you to wake
And all because I lacked conviction
The judgment's my mistake

Who's breathless now?
Who only hyperventilates?
Who'd die for you?
Who's dying inside anyway?
Which one of us is sunshine and which one's growing dim?
While two men dream of you at night, do you just dream of him?

The wrong man was convicted
You know I did the deed
I thought that you would wait for me
Your wants I needn't heed
The wrong man lies beside you
And waits for you to wake
And all because I lacked conviction
The judgment's my mistake

Who's lonely now?
Who's reaching out to no one?
Who's lonely now?
It takes one to know one
I changed my mind, you said that I could change it back
I wanted space, and now change has fallen through the cracks
If I'm again beside your body, don't tell me where it's been
It's cruel, unusual punishment to kiss fingerprinted skin

The wrong man was convicted
You know I did the deed
I thought that you would wait for me
Your wants I needn't heed
The wrong man lies beside you
And waits for you to wake
And all because I lacked conviction
The judgment's my mistake





It's my mistake

Overall Meaning

"The Wrong Man Was Convicted" by Barenaked Ladies is a poignant and emotional song about a man who regrets his past decisions and the consequences that follow. The first verse of the song sets the scene for a broken relationship where one person is suffering and recovering while the other is looking at pictures and crying, but way too late. The second verse intensifies the situation by asking who's breathless now, who'd die for you, and which one of us is sunshine and which one's growing dim. The chorus reveals the crux of the matter - the wrong man was convicted because of the singer's lack of conviction. He thought the person he loved would wait for him and ignored their wants, leading to the wrong man lying beside her and waiting for her to wake. The final verse is a poignant plea, where the singer admits his mistake and begs for another chance, but is met with only the reality of fingerprinted skin.


The song is a heart-wrenching portrayal of the pain and regret caused by indecision and fear in a relationship. It highlights the importance of clear communication and the dangers of assuming one person will wait for the other. The repeated use of "who's lonely now" emphasizes the loneliness felt by both parties in the aftermath of the mistake.


Line by Line Meaning

Who's lonely now? Which one of us is suffering?
Which one of us is experiencing loneliness and pain?


Who's in his cups? Which one of us recovering?
Which one of us is drunk and which one of us is trying to get better?


Who likes to look at pictures and cries, but way too late?
Which one of us enjoys looking at memories, but is too late to change them?


Who doesn't want to change a thing, accepting it was fate?
Which one of us is content with the way things turned out, believing it was meant to be?


The wrong man was convicted, you know I did the deed.
I am the one who committed the crime, but the wrong person was punished.


I thought that you would wait for me, your wants I needn't heed.
I believed you would wait for me and that I didn't need to consider your desires.


The wrong man lies beside you and waits for you to wake,
The individual who was punished is beside you and waits for you to wake up.


And all because I lacked conviction, the judgment's my mistake.
The blame for this error lies with me because I didn't have the confidence to stand up for the truth.


Who's breathless now? Who only hyperventilates?
Which one of us is out of breath and which one only breathes quickly and deeply?


Who'd die for you? Who's dying inside anyway?
Which one of us is willing to die for you but is also suffering on the inside?


Which one of us is sunshine and which one's growing dim?
Which one of us is bright and positive while the other is fading away?


When two men dream of you at night, do you just dream of him?
If two men are dreaming of you, are you only dreaming of one of them?


Who's lonely now? Who's reaching out to no one?
Who is currently alone and trying to connect with no one?


It takes one to know one
A lonely person can recognize another lonely person.


I changed my mind, you said that I could change it back.
I altered my opinion but you assured me I could switch back.


I wanted space, and now change has fallen through the cracks.
I desired some distance and now progress has halted.


If I'm again beside your body, don't tell me where it's been,
If we are together again, do not reveal any information about your past relationships.


It's cruel, unusual punishment to kiss fingerprinted skin.
It is cruel and unusual to kiss skin that belongs to someone else.


It's my mistake
It was my error.




Lyrics © BMG Rights Management, Warner Chappell Music, Inc.
Written by: Stephen Duffy, Steven Page

Lyrics Licensed & Provided by LyricFind
To comment on or correct specific content, highlight it

Genre not found
Artist not found
Album not found
Song not found