A Man I'd Rather Be
Bert Jansch Lyrics


Jump to: Overall Meaning ↴  Line by Line Meaning ↴

Now I wish I was a dog
Lazin' about all day
With the barks so loud and fierce
To keep the cats away
But a man's a man
And a dog's a slave
So man i would rather be
Now I wish I was a book
Upon a dusted shelf
With a millions of words to read
Lord but I can't even read myself
But a man's a man
And a book can't think
So man I would rather be

Now I wish I was a brick
In a middle of a wall
With a plastic coat and hat
I would have no cares at all
But a man's a man
And a brick won't talk
So man I would rather be

Now I wish I was a fly
A buzzin' around and around
Racin' through the air
With no spiders to be found
But a man's a man




And a fly get squashed
So a man I would rather be

Overall Meaning

The song "A Man I'd Rather Be" by Bert Jansch is an interesting ode to the complexities of human existence. Through four different verses, Jansch sings about his wishes to be a dog, a book, a brick, and a fly. Though all four things may seem vastly different, Jansch uses them to represent different aspects of freedom and captivity.


In the first verse, Jansch sings about wishing to be a dog, lazily lounging around all day and barking fiercely to keep the cats away. He admires the unencumbered nature of a dog's life, but ultimately realizes that a "man's a man and a dog's a slave," recognizing the limitations that come with being a human.


The second verse explores a desire to be a book, with countless words to be read and explored. However, Jansch laments that he cannot even read himself and acknowledges that "a man's a man and a book can't think."


In the third verse, Jansch wishes to be a brick, a small piece of a larger structure that has no cares or responsibilities. However, again, he acknowledges that "a man's a man and a brick won't talk."


Finally, in the fourth verse, Jansch expresses a wish to be a fly, buzzing around through the air with no real limitations. He recognizes that a fly may be free of certain concerns, such as spiders to kill, but ultimately acknowledges that a "man's a man and a fly gets squashed."


Throughout the song, Jansch is grappling with the limitations and responsibilities that come with being a human being, ultimately accepting the complexity of the human experience.


Line by Line Meaning

Now I wish I was a dog
I desire simplicity and ease of living, like that of a dog


Lazin' about all day
Spending most of the day relaxing and doing nothing


With the barks so loud and fierce
Using loud and fierce barking to keep away unwanted visitors


To keep the cats away
To protect myself from danger and competition


But a man's a man
I recognize and accept my human identity and responsibilities


And a dog's a slave
Dogs do not have the freedom and autonomy that humans possess


So man i would rather be
Being a human is my preferred state of existence


Now I wish I was a book
I long for the knowledge and wisdom contained within books


Upon a dusted shelf
On a forgotten and neglected shelf, where books are left to collect dust


With a millions of words to read
Containing a vast amount of literature and ideas to explore


Lord but I can't even read myself
Despite the wealth of knowledge out there, I am still struggling to understand myself


And a book can't think
Books cannot have consciousness or the ability to think and reason


Now I wish I was a brick
I wish to be something inanimate and unfeeling


In a middle of a wall
A small, insignificant part of a larger structure


With a plastic coat and hat
Covered in an artificial, protective layer of plastic


I would have no cares at all
Not having to bear any responsibility or pressure


And a brick won't talk
As an object, a brick is mute and cannot communicate or express emotions


Now I wish I was a fly
I desire the freedom and mobility of a fly


A buzzin' around and around
Flying in a carefree and unrestricted manner


Racin' through the air
Moving quickly and seamlessly through the environment


With no spiders to be found
Without the presence of danger or predators


And a fly get squashed
As a small and fragile creature, a fly can be easily killed or destroyed


So a man I would rather be
Ultimately, I would choose to remain human and embrace the challenges and feelings that come with it




Contributed by Amelia C. Suggest a correction in the comments below.
To comment on or correct specific content, highlight it

Genre not found
Artist not found
Album not found
Song not found

More Versions