Callahan started out as a highly experimental artist, using substandard instruments and recording equipment. His early songs often nearly lacked melodic structure and were clumsily played on poorly tuned guitars (possibly influenced by Jandek, whom Callahan admired), resulting in the dissonant sounds on his self-released cassettes and debut album Sewn to the Sky. Much of his early output was instrumental, a stark contrast to the lyrical focus of his later work. Apparently, he used lo-fi techniques not primarily because of an aesthetic preference but because he didn't have any other possibility to make music. Once he signed a contract with Drag City, he also started to use recording studios and a greater variety of instruments for his records.
From 1993 to 2000, Callahan's recordings grew more and more "professional" sounding, with more instruments, and a higher sound quality. In this period he recorded two albums with the influential producer Jim O'Rourke and Tortoise's John McEntire, and collaborated with Neil Hagerty. After 2000's Dongs of Sevotion, Callahan began moving back to a slightly simpler instrumentation and recording style, while retaining the more consistent songwriting style he had developed over the years. This shift is apparent in albums such as Rain on Lens, Supper, and A River Ain't Too Much to Love.
Smog's songs are often based on simple, repetitive structures, consisting of a simple chord progression repeated for the duration of the entire song. His singing is strikingly characterized by his baritone voice and a style of delivery without being over-emotional. Melodically and lyrically he tends to eschew the verse-chorus approach favoured by many contemporary songwriters, preferring instead a more free-form approach relying less on melodic and lyrical repetition. Themes in Callahan's lyrics include relationships, moving, horses, teenagers, bodies of water, and more recently, politics. His generally dispassionate delivery of lyrics and dark irony often obfuscate complex emotional and lyrical twists and turns. Critics have generally characterized his music as depressing and intensely introverted, with one critic describing it as "a peep-show view into an insular world of alienation." Despite this there is also a broad swathe of joy throughout Callahan's work and more attentive critics have picked up on Callahan's tendency to black humour, a tendency often confused with a depressed mental state or a genuine obsession with the morbid, a confusion no doubt caused by his deadpan vocals.
Cat Power (Chan Marshall) recorded Callahan's song Bathysphere on her 1996 album What Would the Community Think. She covered him again in 2000 on her Covers Record doing the song Red Apples.
Smog's Cold Blooded Old Times appears on the High Fidelity soundtrack. The song Vessel in Vain (from Supper) was also used on the soundtrack of the independent British film Dead Man's Shoes in 2004. In October 2007, Cadillac released a commercial which featured Smog's song Held and Bob Dylan driving a 2008 Escalade through the desert.
As of 2007 he lives in Austin, Texas where he released Woke on a Whaleheart. It was his first record release as Bill Callahan.
Free's
Bill Callahan Lyrics
Jump to: Overall Meaning ↴ Line by Line Meaning ↴
A field of questions
As far as the eye can see
Is this what it means to be free?
Or is this what it means to belong to the free?
To be free in bad times and good
To belong to being derided for things I don't believe
If this is what it means to be free
Then I'm free
And I belong to the free
And the free
They belong to me
The song "Free's" by Bill Callahan is a meditation on the concept of freedom and what it truly means to be free. The lyrics evoke a sense of ambiguity and uncertainty, with the singer standing in a field of questions, asking if this is what it means to be free or if it means to belong to the free. The singer appears to be grappling with the contradictions and complexities of freedom, recognizing that the freedom to do good can also mean the freedom to do harm, and that being part of a group can sometimes be constricting even as it provides a sense of belonging.
The lyric "To be free in bad times and good" suggests that true freedom is not just about being able to do whatever one wants when times are good, but also about the ability to navigate difficult situations and make choices that align with one's values and beliefs. The idea of being "derided for things I don't believe / And lauded for things I did not do" underscores the fact that freedom is not always a straightforward or easy path.
Ultimately, however, the singer comes to the conclusion that if this is what it means to be free, then they are free and belong to the free, and that the free belong to them. This suggests a sense of solidarity and community among those who value freedom, even as they recognize that there will always be tensions and challenges that come with it.
Line by Line Meaning
I'm standing in a field
I find myself in an open space
A field of questions
An abundance of uncertainties surround me
As far as the eye can see
The horizon is covered with my doubts
Is this what it means to be free?
I question if this is the true definition of liberty
Or is this what it means to belong to the free?
Perhaps the shared experience defines freedom
To be free in bad times and good
Freedom endures in all aspects of life
To belong to being derided for things I don't believe
Identifying with ridicule when not in agreement
And lauded for things I did not do
Acknowledged for achievements not of my own making
If this is what it means to be free
When considering the previous statements
Then I'm free
The previous notion was accepted
And I belong to the free
Under the previously established terms
And the free
Individuals who have experienced this kind of freedom
They belong to me
Are a part of my life
Contributed by Camilla W. Suggest a correction in the comments below.