When Your Lover Has Gone
Billie Holiday Lyrics


Jump to: Overall Meaning ↴  Line by Line Meaning ↴

What good is the scheming, the planning and dreaming
That comes with each new love affair
The dreams that we cherish, so often might perish
And leaves you with castles in air

When you're alone, who cares for starlit skies
When you're alone, the magic moonlight dies
At break of dawn, there is no sunrise
When your lover has gone

What lonely hours, the evening shadows bring
What lonely hours, with memories lingering




Like faded flowers, life can't mean anything
When your lover has gone

Overall Meaning

In Billie Holiday's song, "When Your Lover Has Gone," the lyrics discuss the feelings of emptiness and despair that come with a lost love. The opening lines question the validity of all the scheming, planning, and hope that are often associated with a new love affair, highlighting how fragile and fleeting these experiences can be. The dreams that are carried by said moments often prove to be mere wistful illusions, and when reality sets in, all that is left are castles in the air - empty and insubstantial.


The second verse speaks to the loneliness and emptiness that follow the loss of a lover. The beauty of starlit skies and magic moonlight, which might have once been sources of wonder and enchantment, now seem hollow and unimportant. The arrival of a new day, which should be accompanied by the light of the rising sun, holds no such promise, leaving behind only a sense of longing and disappointment. Memories of past happiness haunt the present, casting a shadow over everything and draining life of all meaning.


Overall, the lyrics convey a deep sense of heartbreak and despair that come with the loss of a lover. Holiday's mournful delivery underscores the sense of emptiness and longing expressed in the song, and her performance helped establish her as one of the most influential singers of her time.


Line by Line Meaning

What good is the scheming, the planning and dreaming
Why bother with the elaborate plans and fantasies we make when starting a new relationship


That comes with each new love affair
That we associate with romantic partnerships


The dreams that we cherish, so often might perish
The hopes that we hold dear, are more likely to be dashed than come true


And leaves you with castles in air
Withdraws the support of a fulfilling relationship, leaving us with little more than escapist fantasies


When you're alone, who cares for starlit skies
The beauty of nature itself is meaningless to us when we are lonely and heartbroken


When you're alone, the magic moonlight dies
The romantic ambiance of a night sky loses its charm when we are pining for lost love


At break of dawn, there is no sunrise
Even the sun presents no new hopes or promises without the support of a loving partnership


When your lover has gone
When the one we love has left us behind


What lonely hours, the evening shadows bring
The sad hours of the night when the shadows lengthen and we are forced to face our loneliness


What lonely hours, with memories lingering
The time we spend alone, with only our memories to keep us company


Like faded flowers, life can't mean anything
In the same way that dead flowers no longer bring beauty or joy, so too does life lose its meaning without love


When your lover has gone
The cause of our heartbreak and despair




Lyrics © Warner/Chappell Music, Inc.
Written by: EINAR AARON SWAN

Lyrics Licensed & Provided by LyricFind
To comment on or correct specific content, highlight it

Genre not found
Artist not found
Album not found
Song not found
Comments from YouTube:

@parisjackson453

I came to this song because I wanted to hear what type of songs Jimmy liked. Now I'm glad I came here. I absolutely love this song. It's pretty relaxing and sounds great.

@beril2261

like Jimmy

@bradysmet3159

me too

@gisanneali-clarke850

Me as well, do you know what other songs he liked?

@slick247

Jimmy is the King of cool, as Elvis once said!
What a Great taste in music he has too, Awesome song by Billie
God Bless them all 👍

@waynej2608

Billie Holiday recorded this 8-23-55, so James Dean got to enjoy it for a little over a month. Wonderful tune, shows he had excellent taste.

@Haydentostars0017

Every time I think of James Dean, I think of Billie Holiday music, and New York City. Its just the perfect combination.

@koenhughes9267

Only just found out minutes ago this was his favorite song of Holiday's, been a fan of both for more than a decade and I'm still only 26.

@afonsolucas2219

Incredible song. It brings a tear to my eye. Rest In Peace Jimmy.

@kpopkrazee

its nice to think that this is a song James Dean had listened to and also enjoyed the mellow tunes of, gives u a small but still an insight of how he might have been as a person, instead of just how he was painted by the Hollywood marketing masterminds.

More Comments

More Versions