Why I Had To Go
Bishop Allen Lyrics


Jump to: Overall Meaning ↴  Line by Line Meaning ↴

BISHOP ALLEN

It is a narrowing,
It is a shrinking.
And there's a danger of overthinking.
It was everybody getting tired of drinking
Every night.
There was a little left to believe in,
Which is how I really knew I should be leaving...

I should be leaving
Now.
I should be leaving.

We were clever then,
We talked forever then.
And the night of our invention it would never end.
There was a parting
And there was sorrow.
It was impossible to picture it tomorrow.

It was necessity
And it was instinct.
And the pattern underneath
It kept repeating.
Kept repeating,
Kept repeating.
It's just how I really knew I should be leaving...

I should be leaving
Now.
I should be leaving.

Oh and it was everything,
Oh and it was just a way to keep from waking up.
Hello.
Which is why I had to go.
Which is why I should be leaving.
Which is why I had to go.

Am I delibering?
Am I delivering?
Am I offering the blanket
And you're shivering?
Is it a play without the passion?
Is it the endless repetition of inaction?

Is this a christening?
Or there's a crisis.
We can get together then
And say how nice it is.
Is it torment?
That depends.
Which is how a really knew I should be leaving...

I should be leaving
Now.
I should be leaving.

Oh and it was everything,
Oh and it was just a way to keep from waking up.
Hello.
Which is why I had to go.
Which is why I should be leaving.
Which is why I had to go.





What do you know?

Overall Meaning

The song "Why I Had To Go" by Bishop Allen is a reflection on the singer's decision to leave a relationship, and the various factors that contributed to that choice. The lyrics suggest that the relationship had become stagnant and repetitive, with the singer feeling a sense of "narrowing" and "shrinking." The singer cites a lack of belief and a growing tiredness with the routine of drinking as reasons for leaving. Additionally, the singers suggest that there was a sense of inevitability to the departure, driven by both necessity and instinct.


Throughout the song, there are references to the past, including the night of the relationship's "invention" and the clever conversations that were once had. However, these memories are imbued with a sense of sorrow and impossibility, hinting that the relationship had been heading towards its end for some time. The final lines of the song suggest that leaving was a necessary step towards a clearer understanding of oneself and one's priorities, as well as a way to avoid the pain of waking up to the reality of the relationship.


Line by Line Meaning

It is a narrowing,
The situation is becoming increasingly limited in scope and options.


It is a shrinking.
The available opportunities and possibilities are decreasing in number.


And there's a danger of overthinking.
There is a risk of thinking too much, which can lead to indecisiveness and inaction.


It was everybody getting tired of drinking
The constant drinking and partying has become stale and unfulfilling for everyone involved.


Every night.
This behavior has become habitual and occurs on a frequent basis.


There was a little left to believe in,
The sense of hope and purpose has diminished over time.


Which is how I really knew I should be leaving...
This lack of belief is the main reason why leaving is the best course of action.


I should be leaving Now.
The artist needs to leave immediately.


We were clever then,
The artist and others once displayed intelligence and creativity.


We talked forever then.
There was a time when the artist and others could have conversations for hours without getting bored or tired.


And the night of our invention it would never end.
There was a night when the group's creativity and cleverness seemed endless.


There was a parting,
At some point, members of the group separated.


And there was sorrow.
This separation caused pain and sadness.


It was impossible to picture it tomorrow.
It was difficult to imagine a future without everyone being together.


It was necessity And it was instinct.
The singer's departure was both necessary and a natural response to the situation.


And the pattern underneath It kept repeating. Kept repeating, Kept repeating.
The same cycle of behavior and experiences continued to occur over and over again.


It's just how I really knew I should be leaving...
The repetition of negative patterns was another indication that leaving was necessary.


Oh and it was everything, Oh and it was just a way to keep from waking up. Hello.
The drinking, partying, and creative endeavors were all distractions and ways to avoid facing reality.


Which is why I had to go. Which is why I should be leaving. Which is why I had to go.
Again, leaving was the necessary and logical step to take in order to face reality and move forward.


Am I delibering? Am I delivering?
The artist questions whether their words are truly meaningful and effective.


Am I offering the blanket And you're shivering?
The artist wonders if their attempts to comfort others are actually helping or causing more harm.


Is it a play without the passion? Is it the endless repetition of inaction?
The artist questions whether their current situation lacks passion and action, leading to a sense of stagnation.


Is this a christening? Or there's a crisis.
The singer is unsure whether their current situation is a new beginning or a time of great difficulty and upheaval.


We can get together then And say how nice it is.
If the group were to reunite, they could reminisce and recall the positive aspects of their past experiences.


Is it torment? That depends.
The singer is unsure whether their current situation is truly torment or not.


Which is how a really knew I should be leaving...
Through questioning and self-reflection, the singer realized leaving was still the most logical choice.




Contributed by Connor F. Suggest a correction in the comments below.
To comment on or correct specific content, highlight it

Genre not found
Artist not found
Album not found
Song not found
Comments from YouTube:

Iron. pan

this song is so good. i'll buy the album, maybe they can keep growing and give us more good songs. You guys should do the same!

miguel ingles serrano

i am physically disabled by a car accident 18 years ago since then, music is my support, thanks :-))

Kara Eletto

I love this song so much!!! Can't wait for breadcrumbs! You guys are the best!<3

eyedoughnut

love the song/video,peace&wisdom&good health to your families

Crm Cbk

Chilling, peaceful.. as always🤟

weigh Mcdoogle

Fantastic, can't wait for the new album. 

Heaven

perfect !

DotsV

I haven't listened to bishop allen since I was in high school. These last few weeks have been almost dreamlike for me, and I randomly decided to see if they put out any new songs (it's been like 6-8 years). I can swear this song feels like it is speaking directly to me....

Joey Hanghal

I remembered the first time I saw this band,a scene from the movie 'Nick and Norah's Infinite Playlist'

Caique Silva

best movie ever

More Comments

More Versions