Could Never Be Heaven
Brand New Lyrics


Jump to: Overall Meaning ↴  Line by Line Meaning ↴

Do you know the words that make the hidden door open?
Can you speak my secret name and fix me?
I have no heart, I have no brain
Lord I have no courage
Can you get me home again?

Could never be heaven without you
Could never be heaven without you
Never be heaven without you

I was drowning in the lake, damned
Over a dead mining town
The cars and the homes lay still in the water
The deeper I sank, the less I died
The trees swayed, slow in the tide
There were people I love below me singing

And all of the songs were about you
And all of the songs were about you
And all of the songs were about you

The whale is well-rehearsed
Swimming circles in the church
A Cardinalfish says, "God is dead"
The whale says, "Get out of my head
Get out of my head
Get out of my head"

You are not alone
We are not separate
My daughter's shoulders are my shoulders
My son's hands my hands
My wife's heart my own heart
I've heard the outer darkness is really nice this time of year

Could never be heaven without you
Never be heaven without you
Never be heaven without
Could never be heaven without you
Never be heaven without you
Never be heaven without you

You've got so many things that you do believe
You've been conditioned to believe in

Mmhmm

And then if you try and break away from your conditioning
And try and be sort of individual and, in least in our day and age right now
You start to think, "Well, am I really doing this because I really want to be different?
Am I doing it because there's such an emphasis placed to"





I don't know how to break through this contradictory mess
And really find your own authentic individuality

Overall Meaning

The song "Could Never Be Heaven" by Brand New may seem cryptic at first, but upon closer inspection, the lyrics reveal a deep yearning for connection and purpose. The first verse asks for a guide who can help the singer navigate through life. He feels lost and disconnected, and needs someone who can "speak [his] secret name and fix [him]." The reference to "no heart, no brain, and no courage" is reminiscent of the Tin Man from The Wizard of Oz, emphasizing the need for a companion on this journey.


The chorus emphasizes the importance of this connection, declaring that "could never be heaven without you." The repetition of this phrase underscores the intense desire for companionship and belonging, without which life feels empty and incomplete. This sentiment is echoed in the second verse, which describes the singer drowning in a lake amidst abandoned buildings. Despite the bleak surroundings, the singer finds solace in the love of those around him, who are "singing all of the songs" about the person he longs to be with.


The final verse takes a surreal turn, portraying a whale swimming in a church and a Cardinalfish declaring that "God is dead." These images highlight the disorientation and confusion that comes with feeling adrift and alone. The repetition of the plea to "get out of [his] head" conveys the singer's desperation for a way out of this state of mind. However, the song also offers a glimmer of hope, as the singer realizes that "we are not separate" and the love of others can help overcome feelings of isolation.


Line by Line Meaning

Do you know the words that make the hidden door open?
Do you understand me well enough to know what I truly desire or need from you?


Can you speak my secret name and fix me?
Are you able to see me for who I truly am and help me become a better version of myself?


I have no heart, I have no brain
I feel empty and lost, like I have no emotional capacity or intellectual capability.


Lord I have no courage
I lack the bravery and strength to overcome my fears and face the challenges ahead.


Can you get me home again?
Can you guide me back to a place of safety, comfort, and familiarity?


Could never be heaven without you
My life is incomplete and unfulfilling without your presence and love.


I was drowning in the lake, damned
I was overwhelmed with feelings of hopelessness, unworthiness, and guilt.


Over a dead mining town
My despair and suffering was exacerbated by the desolate and forgotten surroundings around me.


The cars and the homes lay still in the water
The material possessions and possessions of others are now stagnant and forgotten.


The deeper I sank, the less I died
The more I delved into my own despair and misery, the more I discovered my resilience and fortitude.


The trees swayed, slow in the tide
Nature kept moving and persevering, even in the midst of my own turmoil and suffering.


There were people I love below me singing
Even in my darkest moments, the thoughts of my loved ones provided me with a sense of hope and comfort.


And all of the songs were about you
In every moment of my life, you are ever-present and always on my mind.


The whale is well-rehearsed
The religion or belief system you follow has been practiced and perfected over time.


Swimming circles in the church
Religious institutions and structures can seem stagnant and cyclical.


A Cardinalfish says, 'God is dead'
Someone within the religious community has questioned the existence or relevance of a higher power.


The whale says, 'Get out of my head'
Sometimes, it can be difficult to reconcile personal beliefs and the doctrines of organized religion.


You are not alone
There are others in this world who share your fears, anxieties, and struggles.


We are not separate
Despite our internal struggles and external differences, we are all connected through our shared humanity.


My daughter's shoulders are my shoulders
We bear the weight of those we love and those who love us, carrying their burdens as our own.


My son's hands my hands
Our actions and choices matter, both for ourselves and for those we leave behind.


My wife's heart my own heart
The love and emotional bonds we share with others become a part of our own identity and being.


I've heard the outer darkness is really nice this time of year
Sometimes, it's tempting to escape from our own problems and difficulties, but ultimately, we must face them head-on.


You've got so many things that you do believe
You hold a multitude of opinions and ideas that have been instilled in you over time.


And then if you try and break away from your conditioning
If you attempt to question or challenge your established beliefs, you may feel uncertain and uncomfortable.


And try and be sort of individual and, in least in our day and age right now
In today's society, there is a constant emphasis on individuality and standing out from the crowd.


You start to think, 'Well, am I really doing this because I really want to be different?
You may wonder if your attempts to be unique or original are influenced by societal pressure or a need for validation.


Am I doing it because there's such an emphasis placed to'
You may feel conflicted about whether your actions are truly authentic or simply conforming to cultural norms.


I don't know how to break through this contradictory mess
You may feel overwhelmed by conflicting emotions, thoughts, and beliefs, unsure of how to reconcile them.


And really find your own authentic individuality
Ultimately, only you can determine what your true beliefs and values are, and how to live accordingly.




Lyrics © BMG Rights Management
Written by: Jesse Lacey

Lyrics Licensed & Provided by LyricFind
To comment on or correct specific content, highlight it

Genre not found
Artist not found
Album not found
Song not found

More Versions