In the City
Carrie Newcomer Lyrics


Jump to: Overall Meaning ↴  Line by Line Meaning ↴

Chalk one up for the street
Mark one down for the city
One more grown baby boy is sleepin' on the sidewalk tonight
Wide round eyes, wide round lights
Can be full but without substance
In an instant you can hear an angel
Spread its wings and fly away
You're in the city
Where you lay down your dreams
You can feel it, through the sidewalk
A heartbeat beneath your feet
Where they'll let you smell the water
Then tell you "you can't drink,
You're in the city now"

There's a cry, there's a roar
There's a howl that never ends
There's a silence that runs wide as it runs deep
And unspoken, broken people
Lying in the doorways
The light within them sputters and flickers
Like it almost had never been

You're in the city
Where you lay down your dreams
You can feel it, through the sidewalk
A heartbeat beneath your feet
Where they'll let you smell the water
Then tell you "you can't drink,
You're in the city now"

There's a light and it is you
There's a light and it is me
There's a hope that's round and hollow
As a paper moon on a string
We can be perfect, we can be stronger
Saints are sinners who just tried longer
I am certainly no saint
But I surely heard the call

You're in the city
Where you lay down your dreams
You can feel it, through the sidewalk
A heartbeat beneath your feet
Where they'll let you smell the water




Then tell you "you can't drink,
You're in the city now"

Overall Meaning

Carrie Newcomer's song "In The City" is a poignant reflection on the realities of living in an urban environment. The opening lines of the song, "Chalk one up for the street, Mark one down for the city," suggest that while there may be some "wins" for city life, there are also significant losses. The lyrics go on to describe a scene of poverty and homelessness, with a "baby boy...sleepin' on the sidewalk tonight." The image of "wide round eyes, wide round lights" evokes both innocence and vulnerability, while the line "Can be full but without substance" suggests a hollowness in the city's promises of abundance and opportunity.


Newcomer contrasts the gritty realities of life in the city with a sense of hope and resilience. The chorus repeats the phrase "You're in the city, where you lay down your dreams," acknowledging that the city can be a place of both possibility and disappointment. The metaphor of the city as a living thing, with a "heartbeat beneath your feet," creates a sense of connection and mutual dependency between the urban environment and its inhabitants. The line "Where they'll let you smell the water/Then tell you 'you can't drink'" captures the structural inequalities of urban life, in which access to basic resources like clean water is often limited by socioeconomic status.


Line by Line Meaning

Chalk one up for the street
Acknowledging a win for the underprivileged and struggling people who populate the streets


Mark one down for the city
Highlighting the city's failure to care for its vulnerable population


One more grown baby boy is sleepin' on the sidewalk tonight
Highlighting the tragic reality of homelessness among young adults


Wide round eyes, wide round lights
Describing the intensity and allure of city life


Can be full but without substance
Acknowledging that the city can provide many pleasures but leave you feeling empty


In an instant you can hear an angel
Highlighting the fleeting moments of beauty and hope in city life


Spread its wings and fly away
Emphasizing the brief nature of those moments and how they vanish too soon


You're in the city
Addressing the listener and noting their presence in the urban landscape


Where you lay down your dreams
Describing the city as a place where people come to pursue their goals and aspirations


You can feel it, through the sidewalk
Suggesting that the city's energy, both good and bad, can be felt through the very ground


A heartbeat beneath your feet
Metaphorically comparing the pulse of the city to a human heartbeat


Where they'll let you smell the water
Describing the tantalizing quality of the city's offerings that may be just out of reach


Then tell you "you can't drink,
Acknowledging the barriers to accessing those offerings, particularly for marginalized communities


You're in the city now"
Emphasizing the idea that city life comes with its own set of rules and limitations


There's a cry, there's a roar
Describing the range of emotions and sounds that exist in the city


There's a howl that never ends
Highlighting the constant noise and activity that characterizes the city


There's a silence that runs wide as it runs deep
Contrasting the noise with the profound sense of loneliness and isolation that can also be found in the city


And unspoken, broken people
Noting the suffering and hardship that often goes unseen in the city


Lying in the doorways
Describing the physical location of those who have been pushed to the margins of society


The light within them sputters and flickers
Metaphorically describing the fragile and precarious state of these individuals


Like it almost had never been
Emphasizing their vulnerability and the sense that they could disappear at any moment


There's a light and it is you
Offering a message of hope and resilience in the face of adversity


There's a light and it is me
Encouraging everyone to recognize their own potential for good and positive change


There's a hope that's round and hollow
Acknowledging the fragile nature of hope, which can be easily shattered


As a paper moon on a string
Comparing hope to a cheap and flimsy toy that can be easily broken


We can be perfect, we can be stronger
Encouraging people to strive for self-improvement and to work together to build a better world


Saints are sinners who just tried longer
Suggesting that even those who are considered holy or righteous have struggled in their lives


I am certainly no saint
Acknowledging one's own imperfections and limitations


But I surely heard the call
Emphasizing the importance of recognizing one's own purpose and calling, whatever that may be




Contributed by Abigail H. Suggest a correction in the comments below.
To comment on or correct specific content, highlight it

Genre not found
Artist not found
Album not found
Song not found

More Versions