What Are You?
David Gray Lyrics


Jump to: Overall Meaning ↴  Line by Line Meaning ↴

What are you becoming? What have you become?
Once you sang your own song
Now you're dancing to the same drum
What have you become?

And what is that you're wearing?
Money's ugly confidence
You sacrificed the poem of your imagination
For these pounds and pence

Me, I take the cynic's role
Throw scorn on your empty mind
I've seen this monotonous world
Make dull what used to shine
You lost interest, you lost your spine
Oh, that spine, fine, fine

When there' nothing left
On this plate you're handed
You find yourself running the gauntlet
Of all of these double standards
It's very thin ice over which you're skating
And after this black winter, the thaw

So what are you?




Tell me, tell me what are you
And what have you become

Overall Meaning

The lyrics of What Are You by David Gray reflect a sense of disappointment and disillusionment towards someone who has lost their sense of individuality and artistic expression. The singer questions the person's identity by asking "what are you becoming?" and "what have you become?" It is evident that the person used to be creative and unique, singing their own song, but now they have given into conformity and are "dancing to the same drum". The use of the phrase "Money's ugly confidence" highlights the idea that the person has given up their poetic imagination for the sake of material gain.


The singer's perspective is one of cynicism towards the person's mind which he considers empty. He has seen the monotony of the world make dull what used to shine, and he believes the person he is addressing has lost interest and their spine in being an artist. The line "When there's nothing left on this plate you're handed" conveys the helplessness and void that the person feels in a society that demands conformity.


The song ends with the singer still questioning the person's identity, wondering what they have become. This song shows a critical outlook towards the societal norms that stifle creativity and encourages people to maintain their own unique identity.


Line by Line Meaning

What are you becoming? What have you become?
I am curious about what you are transforming into, and how different you are from who you were before.


Once you sang your own song
You used to have your own unique voice and ideas.


Now you're dancing to the same drum
Nowadays, you follow the same trends as everyone else.


What have you become?
I am wondering how you have changed and developed over time.


And what is that you're wearing?
I am interested in knowing about the clothes you are wearing at the moment.


Money's ugly confidence
The possession of money has given you an unappealing sense of self-assurance.


You sacrificed the poem of your imagination For these pounds and pence
You traded your creative and imaginative side for the sake of making money.


Me, I take the cynic's role
I am usually skeptical and distrustful of people and their motives.


Throw scorn on your empty mind
I criticize and mock your mind for being devoid of original thoughts or ideas.


I've seen this monotonous world Make dull what used to shine
I have observed how our mundane world can dim and lessen the lustre of things that were once brilliant.


You lost interest, you lost your spine Oh, that spine, fine, fine
You have lost passion and the courage to stand up for yourself or what you believe in.


When there' nothing left On this plate you're handed
When you've exhausted all your options.


You find yourself running the gauntlet Of all of these double standards
You encounter double-dealing, discriminatory, and unfair schemes.


It's very thin ice over which you're skating And after this black winter, the thaw
You are skating on a precarious footing, and you should be wary, but there's still hope for recovery after the difficult times pass.


So what are you? Tell me, tell me what are you And what have you become
I am asking you to reveal your current identity and how it has changed or evolved over time.




Lyrics © Kobalt Music Publishing Ltd.
Written by: David Gray

Lyrics Licensed & Provided by LyricFind
To comment on or correct specific content, highlight it

Genre not found
Artist not found
Album not found
Song not found

More Versions