Deadeye Dick were an American alternative rock trio that was formed in New … Read Full Bio ↴Deadeye Dick were an American alternative rock trio that was formed in New Orleans, Louisiana. The band, which consisted of vocalist/guitarist Caleb Guillotte, bassist Mark Adam Miller, and drummer Billy Landry, was formed in 1991 and took their name from the Kurt Vonnegut novel of the same name. The group built up a loyal following touring the Southeast. They self-produced their first album even though they still had not landed a record deal. A song titled "New Age Girl" from this self-published record became popular regionally and earned airplay in New Orleans and Atlanta. After receiving this airplay, the band landed a record deal with the independent label Ichiban Records. Ichiban released the group's debut album A Different Story in 1994. After its release, the song "New Age Girl" was selected for inclusion on the Dumb and Dumber feature film soundtrack. The publicity from the film caused the song to become a national hit, peaking at #27 on the Billboard Hot 100 in March 1995. The band released their second album, Whirl, in 1995 but were unable to reproduce the success produced by "New Age Girl". Deadeye Dick later disbanded. Caleb Guillotte and Mark Miller continue to remain active in the local New Orleans music scene as producers.

Different Story
Deadeye Dick Lyrics

Jump to: Overall Meaning ↴ Line by Line Meaning ↴

As if you turned around, or disconcerting sound, replaces silence
And if you wonder why I wouldn't try to rhyme, my past with yours
But then you turn your eyes away

And when it's sleepy-time, the list is so sublime, I have to choose
The story's long enough and with the proper touch
How can I lose? But then you turn your ears away

And then you inch right in, but nothing you have is for me
â??Cause when we are skin to skin
A piece of your heart for mine, well, that's a different story

And when you want to try, I wouldn't tell you why, or whatever for
You needn't even ask why I'm not quite up to task for your revival
So then I turn my heart away

And then you inch right in, but nothing you have is for me
â??Cause when we are skin to skin
A piece of your heart for mine, well, that's a different story

And when I say goodbye, I won't shed a tear
I'm mad about you, but try? Well, that's a different story
I'm mad about you, but try? Well, that's a different story
I'm mad about you, but try? Well, that's a different story

Well, that's a different story, well, that's a different story
Yeah, yeah, yeah

Overall Meaning

The lyrics of Deadeye Dick's song Different Story describe a relationship between two individuals that is complicated and full of mixed emotions. The songwriter sings about the moments when he feels a connection to his partner, only to have them turn away, leaving him feeling unsure and confused. The first verse talks about the disconcerting sound that replaces silence when his partner turns away, highlighting the sense of rejection he feels. In the second verse, he talks about the difficulty of choosing which story to tell his partner before they turn their ears away again. Lastly, the chorus highlights the idea that although he is in love with his partner, he struggles with the idea of giving up a piece of his heart. The phrase "I'm mad about you, but try? Well, that's a different story" repeats at the end of the song, emphasizing the complexity of their relationship.

Overall, the song appears to be about the challenges of opening up emotionally to another person. The songwriter seems to desire a deeper connection with his partner, yet struggles with the fear of vulnerability and abandonment. By the end of the song, he seems resigned to the fact that their relationship will never be what he truly wants it to be, leading to his lack of tears when they part ways.

Line by Line Meaning

As if you turned around, or disconcerting sound, replaces silence
I feel unsettled when you abruptly change your attention, or there is sudden noise in the otherwise quiet environment.

And if you wonder why I wouldn't try to rhyme, my past with yours
You might question why I don't make an attempt to connect our histories through poetry or common experiences.

But then you turn your eyes away
Sadly, you look away, so I feel discouraged and keep my thoughts to myself.

And when it's sleepy-time, the list is so sublime, I have to choose
When it's late at night, there are so many stories to tell that I have to pick one and hope it's the right choice.

The story's long enough and with the proper touch
I have a long enough tale, and I'll deliver it with the right tone and strategy to make it interesting.

How can I lose? But then you turn your ears away
With such a good story, how can I fail to make an impression? But once again, you look away, and I feel ignored.

And then you inch right in, but nothing you have is for me
You try to get close to me, but your motives aren't genuine or sincere.

'Cause when we are skin to skin, a piece of your heart for mine, well, that's a different story
However, when we are intimately close and our hearts are exposed, that's a unique scenario.

And when you want to try, I wouldn't tell you why, or whatever for
If you attempt to discover why I behave a particular way, it's best not to inquire or waste your energy.

You needn't even ask why I'm not quite up to task for your revival
You don't need to inquire why I'm not capable of helping you during challenging times.

So then I turn my heart away
That's when I decide to shut down my emotions and detach myself from the situation.

And when I say goodbye, I won't shed a tear
If we must part ways, I won't show any signs of sadness or regret.

I'm mad about you, but try? Well, that's a different story
I have feelings of love towards you, but attempting to make things work between us is a completely different matter.

Well, that's a different story, well, that's a different story
Indeed, that's a unique situation that can't be compared to anything else.

Yeah, yeah, yeah
An expression of agreement or acceptance with what was just said.

Lyrics © Universal Music Publishing Group
Written by: CALEB GUILLOTTE

Lyrics Licensed & Provided by LyricFind

To comment on or correct specific content, highlight it

TRACKS