Broken Man's Lament
Emmylou Harris Lyrics


Jump to: Overall Meaning ↴  Line by Line Meaning ↴

I was once a broken man
I was once a broken fool
Lost my wife and children
To one basic broken rule
Now I live my life in silence
Tho' I'm not quite in a shell
Drink and listen to that song
A whiter shade of pale
A whiter shade of pale

I was good shad tree mechanic
So I send myself to school
They smoothed off my rough edges
In my hands they put new tools
The instructor once he told me
I could work on any line
I could tend and make any diesel sing
Just like Patsy Cline
Just like Patsy Cline

Well I met my wife to be
Through my mother's best friend's son
She had been a bar room singer
She was as good as anyone
But I ask her to stop singing
And the girl she did not flinch
Next day she went and bought that man
A brand new crescent wrench, ohh
A brand new crescent wrench

We had three fine children
As eight years went on by
And earned a silver visor
The knuckles stayed bone dry
But after supper I kept hearin' her
By the kitchen radio
Singing sweet but desperate harmony
A little bit to low, ohhh
A little bit to low

She left three months later
I'd just come home for lunch
Note said "easy come, hard go"
I still love you so much
She said I don't know if I'll be there
Or if you'll want me when I come
But if and when that Abbott steer
You better
Let my sweet dream run, ohhh
Let my sweet dream run

Ohhhh...ohhh...ohhh...ohhh

I was good shad tree mechanic
So I send myself to school
They smoothed off my rough edges
In my hands they put new tools
The instructor once he told me
I could work on any line
But now the diesels aren't the only thing that sing
Just like Patsy Cline
Just like Patsy Cline

I was once a broken man
I was once a broken fool
Lost my wife and children
To one basic broken rule
Now I live my life in silence
Tho' I'm not quite in a shell
Drink and listen to that song
A whiter shade of pale
A whiter shade of pale




A whiter shade of pale
A whiter shade of pale

Overall Meaning

Broken Man's Lament by Emmylou Harris tells the story of a man who has been shattered by the consequences of his actions. The song starts with the man acknowledging that he was once broken and lost everything, including his wife and children, because of a single broken rule. He is now trying to live life quietly and uses alcohol to cope. However, the song suggests that he is not completely in a shell, as he still listens to music, specifically "A Whiter Shade of Pale" by Procol Harum. This song could symbolize his desire for redemption and the hope of rebuilding his life again.


The second verse reveals that the man was once a good shad tree mechanic and sent himself to school to learn more about his craft. He was trained to work on any engine and was even compared to the legendary Patsy Cline. However, the man's failure to confront his wife's passion for singing led to the destruction of their family. The man's wife was once a bar room singer and was just as good as anyone. The man asked her to stop singing, and when she didn't, he retaliated by buying another man a crescent wrench. Eventually, she leaves him, and he is left alone to contemplate his actions. The line "a little bit too low" could suggest that the man didn't fully appreciate his wife's talent until she was gone.


The song emphasizes the theme of regret, the power of love, and the consequences of our actions. It highlights that the man's wife had a passion for something and that he didn't support it. Because of this, their love was never truly fulfilled, leading to the disintegration of their family. The line "let my sweet dream run" suggests that the man's wife had a vision for her future, but her husband didn't allow it to manifest. These lyrics could be interpreted as a warning to all of us: to support our significant other's passions and dreams to achieve true happiness.


Line by Line Meaning

I was once a broken man
The singer was weak and hopeless in the past


I was once a broken fool
The singer was foolish and helpless in the past


Lost my wife and children
The family of the singer was gone


To one basic broken rule
The reason for the artist's loss was a simple but fatal mistake


Now I live my life in silence
The artist is now living a quiet and lonely life


Tho' I'm not quite in a shell
The singer is not completely isolated from society


Drink and listen to that song
The singer tries to soothe himself with alcohol and music


A whiter shade of pale
The song he listens to is 'A Whiter Shade of Pale'


I was good shad tree mechanic
The artist had a talent for fixing cars


So I send myself to school
The artist educates himself to improve his skills


They smoothed off my rough edges
The school helped him to become a better person


In my hands they put new tools
The school provided the artist with better equipment


The instructor once he told me
The singer recalls what he learned from his teacher


I could work on any line
The singer became skilled at repairing any type of car


I could tend and make any diesel sing
The singer was able to fix and make diesel engines run smoothly


Just like Patsy Cline
The artist was as skilled at car repairing as Patsy Cline was at singing


Well I met my wife to be
The artist met his future wife


Through my mother's best friend's son
The singer's girlfriend was introduced by his mother's friend's son


She had been a bar room singer
The singer's girlfriend used to sing at bars


She was as good as anyone
The artist thought his girlfriend was very talented


But I ask her to stop singing
The artist asked his girlfriend to give up her singing career


And the girl she did not flinch
His girlfriend didn't hesitate to stop singing


Next day she went and bought that man
The next day, the girlfriend bought a new tool for the singer


A brand new crescent wrench, ohh
She bought a crescent wrench for him


We had three fine children
The couple had three children together


As eight years went on by
The family had a good life for eight years


And earned a silver visor
The singer probably got promoted at his job


The knuckles stayed bone dry
He didn't have to work very hard physically anymore


But after supper I kept hearin' her
The artist's wife secretly sang after dinner


By the kitchen radio
She sang while listening to the radio in the kitchen


Singing sweet but desperate harmony
Her singing was beautiful but also a little sad


A little bit to low, ohhh
She sang quietly because she didn't want anyone to hear her


She left three months later
The wife left the artist and their children


I'd just come home for lunch
The artist came home for lunch and found a note from his wife


Note said 'easy come, hard go'
The note was a phrase meaning that good things come and go quickly


I still love you so much
The artist still loved his wife very much


She said I don't know if I'll be there
The wife was unsure whether she would return


Or if you'll want me when I come
She was also unsure if the singer would take her back


But if and when that Abbott steer
The wife gave a 'what if' scenario about an animal


You better let my sweet dream run, ohhh
She implies that he should let her pursue her dreams if she ever came back


Ohhhh...ohhh...ohhh...ohhh
Lines of the song being played in the background


The diesels aren't the only thing that sing
The singer realizes that he can now appreciate music, not just engine sounds


I was once a broken man
The singer repeats the opening line, highlighting that he still feels broken


I was once a broken fool
The artist also repeats this line, emphasizing his own foolishness in the past


A whiter shade of pale
The song the artist is listening to is repeated again for emphasis




Lyrics © Sony/ATV Music Publishing LLC
Written by: MARK GERMINO

Lyrics Licensed & Provided by LyricFind
To comment on or correct specific content, highlight it

Genre not found
Artist not found
Album not found
Song not found