Song Without Words
Felix Mendelssohn Lyrics


Instrumental

To comment on or correct specific content, highlight it

Genre not found
Artist not found
Album not found
Song not found
Most interesting comments from YouTube:

klaus ehrhardt

Desataram-se as amarras que me prendiam ao mundo
Com o qual tanto de meu tempo pus a perder.
E por tanto tempo de mim nada mais percebendo,
Bem pode acreditar que morto esteja eu.

Que importância tem isto pra mim,
Que em julgando o mundo, por morto me der.
Contra isso nada há que possa dizer,
Já que para ele, realmente morri eu.

Morto sim – para o seu tumulto,
Repousando agora em pago tranquilo.
Sozinho em meu céu vivo,
De amor meu, música minha!

Tradução livre a partir do alemão.



Baila Hie

@Steven Gregory This is like saying that all "Chinese look a like"... They don't... (As a matter of fact, my Chinese colleague said that all Europeans look alike, she couldn't tell them apart...:-) )


It is often due to the lack of the capability to differentiate in the listener. These Mendelssohn songs have a uniquely distinctive sound and energy... I would recognise them among a million "similar" songs... The same holds for any other well-known composer of piano music, and I know a lot... Often I only have to hear the first few notes to know what piece it is and by what composer, and often I can also identify by which composer it is even if did not yet know the piece... The instrument is the same, yet the energy "unique".


With respect to originality - the remarks below about recycling older material, is a more nuanced one. This is for the connaisseur, and I do agree up to a certain point. The twist they give to the music is still often highly distinctive. E.g. Liszt - for me also highly distinctive in sound and energy. You feel the man behind the notes, his character, his energy. There is (so much) more to a piece of music than the given chord progressions in which a composer leaves his distinctive mark.


And indeed, in that respect - pop music is the genre that produces, in my opinion, the highest degree of songs that sound the same. Same progressions, same rhythms, similar melodies - yet even here most pieces are unique, the colour of the voices, the choice of synthesizer tunes etc.



Retner

Сборник пьес "Песни без слов"
Тетрадь 1, Op. 19b (1829-1830)
[01] 00:00:00 No. 1 E-dur
[02] 00:04:38 No. 2 a-moll
[03] 00:06:50 No. 3 A-dur
[04] 00:09:16 No. 4 A-dur
[05] 00:11:32 No. 5 fis-moll
[06] 00:14:14 No. 6 g-moll

Тетрадь 2, Op. 30 (1833-1834)
[07] 00:16:49 No. 1 Es-dur
[08] 00:21:32 No. 2 b-moll
[09] 00:23:48 No. 3 E-dur🔥
[10] 00:26:01 No. 4 h-moll
[11] 00:28:56 No. 5 D-dur
[12] 00:31:20 No. 6 fis-moll

Тетрадь 3, Op. 38 (1836-1837)
[13] 00:35:05 No. 1 Es-dur
[14] 00:37:06 No. 2 c-moll
[15] 00:38:51 No. 3 E-dur
[16] 00:41:05 No. 4 A-dur
[17] 00:43:27 No. 5 a-moll
[18] 00:45:54 No. 6 As-dur

Тетрадь 4, Op. 53 (1839-1841)
[19] 00:50:07 No. 1 As-dur
[20] 00:53:46 No. 2 Es-dur
[21] 00:55:53 No. 3 g-moll
[22] 00:58:40 No. 4 F-dur
[23] 01:01:40 No. 5 a-moll
[24] 01:04:40 No. 6 A-dur

Тетрадь 5, Op. 62 (1842-1844)
[25] 01:07:21 No. 1 G-dur
[26] 01:10:24 No. 2 B-dur
[27] 01:12:21 No. 3 e-moll🔥
[28] 01:16:11 No. 4 G-dur
[29] 01:17:37 No. 5 a-moll
[30] 01:20:56 No. 6 A-dur🔥

Тетрадь 6, Op. 67 (1843-1845)
[31] 01:23:14 No. 1 Es-dur
[32] 01:26:17 No. 2 fis-moll🔥
[33] 01:28:36 No. 3 B-dur
[34] 01:31:10 No. 4 C-dur
[35] 01:33:05 No. 5 h-moll
[36] 01:35:06 No. 6 E-dur

Тетрадь 7, Op. 85 (1834-1845)
[37] 01:37:19 No. 1 F-dur
[38] 01:40:10 No. 2 a-moll
[39] 01:41:07 No. 3 Es-dur
[40] 01:43:31 No. 4 D-dur
[41] 01:47:14 No. 5 A-dur
[42] 01:49:15 No. 6 B-dur

Тетрадь 8, Op. 102 (1842-1845)
[43] 01:51:35 No. 1 e-moll
[44] 01:54:32 No. 2 D-dur
[45] 01:56:46 No. 3 C-dur
[46] 01:58:17 No. 4 g-moll
[47] 02:00:30 No. 5 A-dur
[48] 02:01:38 No. 6 C-dur



All comments from YouTube:

John Alexiou

Rena was my great aunt and I remember her playing when I was very young. This brings back so many memories for me, thanks.

Enzo

wow

dmswan

That is so wonderful to hear! 🎹🌹🎹. Her interpretations of the Mendelssohn’s Song Without Words are brilliant!

Brenda Drew

John, I researched your aunt on the internet and found a brief write up on Wikipedia! Wondering why people today haven't heard of her and she's been forgotten for the most part at least here in the states when she could be a household name since her playing was brilliant! As a pianist/composer myself I would love to hear her compositions! I joined an international organization of women composers years ago and we never get to hear their music. My music a light folk opera was performed locally and I want to get it out again,since it's been almost 30 years since it was performed! Very hard to get one's music out and heard esp women composers. There has been such a systemic bias against that ever since the 19th century and before! Old bad habits die hard, really sad...pathetic! We don't even have enough woman conductors and it's too bad we genderize everything! Dvorak even said a real sexist comment about women not being able to compose and they said in the 19th century that there was "masculine music" and "Feminine music"! Ridiculous...music is music! They accept women "Songwriters" not composers of serious music like classical! Their loss! As well as for the rest of us! smdh

Francesco Consolino

my grandma use to play piano every sunday after lunch try'n to calm down me and my cousin... she was a great musician. but to much shi to get on a stage... lot of memories for me too...

Harold Brown

Wonderful memories.

4 More Replies...

Gerry R

This is such marvelous music and to have it all together and so well annotated makes it even more special.  The effort that you put into that task is greatly appreciated, at least by me.

Priscilla Wilson

@Matteo Longarini Let's not be judgmental. Everybody makes mistakes. lol

TiticatFollies

Thank you for this treasure.
1 yr later: Having now listened to a number of versions, I believe this is the most beautiful and heartwarming.

Frankie DeRousse

Very correct excellent relaxing enjoyable , and I am going to get it on my phone

More Comments

More Versions