Tell Me Why
G.A. Mary J. Blige Tye Tribbett & Will Smith Lyrics


Jump to: Overall Meaning ↴  Line by Line Meaning ↴

[Mary J. Blige]
Whyyyyyy, whyyyyyy
Whyyyyyy, whyyyyyy

[Chorus:]
I really wish I could explain it baby
It's just the world is kinda crazy baby
Ain't no pretty way to paint it baby
Don't cry, dry your eyes

[Will Smith]
September 11th I woke up about 7 AM
West coast time, french toast and my turkey bacon
Takin' my time awakin, turnin' my TV on
To my surprise, saw what everybody in the world saw
Me and my children, images were chillin'
My son said - daddy were there people in that building?
A cold sweat, frozen with a lump in my chest
I heard his question, couldn't bring my lips to say yes to him
That night at my son's side, he cried
And prayed for the ones who died in the World Trade
His palms to God, seeds of qualms with God
He just, kept on pressin' me, wanna know why
Then one week later our bombs were dropped
We seein' them, on CNN, they just won't stop
The infrared, images of brutal attack
He said "Daddy now we killin' 'em back," right right

[Chorus]

[Chorus]

Souls are captured (souls are captured)
Dreams are stolen (dreams are stolen)
Hearts are broken (hearts are broken)
Evil plaguin' he rewardin'
Hate surrender (hate surrender)
Love exalted! (Love exalted!)
Hope elated! (hope elated!)
Negativity destroyed and..

[Will Smith]
Honest to God, why is the bomb always gettin' the last word
and why, did her uncles have to molest her
and why, did all them cops have to be shootin' to kill?
And why, did all them priests have to act so ill?
Tell me why did James Byrd Jr. have to be touched?
Tell my why did Malcolm and Martin depart from us
Tell me why did the sniper make that little boy shoot
And why, is human life always denied for loot?
Tell me WHY did MANDELA have to live in a cage
Why did my brother Sterling have to die at that age
Tell me why did Reginald Denny deserve his fate
And why the fuck can't love, seem to defeat hate?
Tell me why is it so hard for all the children to eat?
Why did 'Pac and Biggie Smalls have to fall in the street?
Tell me why did Jam Master Jay have to go that way?
Please, what am I supposed to say my kids when they say

[Chorus]

[Chorus]

[Will Smith]
Can't explain it baby life is just really crazy
I mean if it's world wars or the life of a little baby
We got more stores than they got rice under buddha lazy
You live four scores and still it be drivin' you crazy
But for me I try to see the button side
Sometimes it be like the goodness be tryin' to hide




or tryin' to flee, but it can't, it's deep inside
Sweetie you be the light for others, make 'em believe in God

Overall Meaning

The song Tell Me Why by Mary J. Blige, Tye Tribbett & Will Smith explores the complexity and darkness of the world we currently live in. The chorus, "I really wish I could explain it baby, It's just the world is kinda crazy baby, Ain't no pretty way to paint it baby, Don't cry, dry your eyes," highlights the difficulty in explaining why bad things happen to good people. Will Smith's verse talks about the September 11th attacks and how it impacted him and his family. He also touches on other tragic events throughout history and asks the question, "Tell me why can't love seem to defeat hate?" The song recognizes that while there is hate, sadness, and tragedy in this world, it is important to remember the good and be a light for others.


In summary Tell Me Why is a powerful song about the difficulties we face in life when bad things happen to good people. It is about the cruel side of humanity and the pain, tragedy and loss that can occur in life.


Line by Line Meaning

Whyyyyyy, whyyyyyy
Expressing a sense of confusion and questioning


I really wish I could explain it baby
Expressing a desire to provide an explanation, but feeling unable to


It's just the world is kinda crazy baby
Acknowledge the chaotic and unpredictable nature of the world


Ain't no pretty way to paint it baby
Acknowledge that there are no easy or flattering ways to present the reality of the world


Don't cry, dry your eyes
Encouraging emotional resilience and strength


September 11th I woke up about 7 AM
Describing the experience of witnessing the 9/11 attacks first hand


West coast time, french toast and my turkey bacon
Gives a small insight into the singer's morning routine


Takin' my time awakin, turnin' my TV on
Illustrating a casual and relaxed state-of-mind before the events of 9/11


To my surprise, saw what everybody in the world saw
Realizing the global impact and significance of the attacks


Me and my children, images were chillin'
Sharing an intense and emotional moment with his children after viewing the news


My son said - daddy were there people in that building?
Expressing the innocent curiosity of a child amidst a horrifying event


A cold sweat, frozen with a lump in my chest
Describing the artist's physical and emotional response to 9/11


I heard his question, couldn't bring my lips to say yes to him
Acknowledging the difficulty of finding the right words to say to a child in such a situation


That night at my son's side, he cried
Illustrating a tender and emotional moment between a father and son


And prayed for the ones who died in the World Trade
Showing compassion and empathy for the victims of the attacks


His palms to God, seeds of qualms with God
Expressing the artist's internal struggle about questioning God in the face of tragedy


He just, kept on pressin' me, wanna know why
Highlighting the persistent and innocent nature of a child's curiosity


Then one week later our bombs were dropped
Referring to the start of the War on Terror and the invasion of Afghanistan


We seein' them, on CNN, they just won't stop
Describing the constant media coverage of the war and its impact on daily life


The infrared, images of brutal attack
Describing the horrific and graphic nature of war


He said "Daddy now we killin' 'em back," right right
Expressing the child's simplistic and black-and-white understanding of war


Souls are captured (souls are captured)
Implying a sense of loss and tragedy in the world


Dreams are stolen (dreams are stolen)
Suggesting a lack of hope and optimism


Hearts are broken (hearts are broken)
Acknowledging the emotional pain and suffering of individuals


Evil plaguin' he rewardin'
Commenting on the injustice and absurdity of the world's rewards and punishments


Hate surrender (hate surrender)
Encouraging a rejection of hate and negativity


Love exalted! (Love exalted!)
Emphasizing the importance and power of love


Hope elated! (hope elated!)
Expressing the positive feelings associated with hope and optimism


Negativity destroyed and..
Suggesting that the negativity and suffering in the world can be overcome


Honest to God, why is the bomb always gettin' the last word
Questioning the prevalence and power of violence in the world


and why, did her uncles have to molest her
Questioning the prevalence and power of abuse and trauma in the world


and why, did all them cops have to be shootin' to kill?
Questioning the excessive and deadly force used by police and authority figures


And why, did all them priests have to act so ill?
Commenting on the disturbing and abusive behavior of some religious leaders


Tell me why did James Byrd Jr. have to be touched?
Questioning the motivation and justification for hate crimes and violence against minorities


Tell my why did Malcolm and Martin depart from us
Reflecting on the loss of influential and inspiring leaders like Malcolm X and Martin Luther King Jr.


Tell me why did the sniper make that little boy shoot
Expressing anger and confusion over senseless and tragic events


And why, is human life always denied for loot?
Questioning the priority placed on material possessions over human life


Tell me WHY did MANDELA have to live in a cage
Questioning the injustice and cruelty of apartheid and political imprisonment


Why did my brother Sterling have to die at that age
Expressing the pain and grief of losing a loved one to violence and injustice


Tell me why did Reginald Denny deserve his fate
Questioning the justification for acts of violence and retribution


And why the fuck can't love, seem to defeat hate?
Expressing frustration over the persistent and powerful nature of hate and negativity


Tell me why is it so hard for all the children to eat?
Questioning the prevalence and persistence of poverty and hunger in the world


Why did 'Pac and Biggie Smalls have to fall in the street?
Reflecting on the tragic and avoidable deaths of talented artists


Tell me why did Jam Master Jay have to go that way?
Expressing sadness and loss over the death of a beloved musician and figurehead


Please, what am I supposed to say my kids when they say
Reiterating the struggle of trying to provide answers and explanations to children in a confusing and unpredictable world


Can't explain it baby life is just really crazy
Acknowledging the complexity and unpredictability of life


I mean if it's world wars or the life of a little baby
Illustrating a wide range of extreme situations that can happen in life


We got more stores than they got rice under buddha lazy
Commenting on the abundance and wealth in some parts of the world compared to the poverty and deprivation in others


You live four scores and still it be drivin' you crazy
Suggesting that even a long and full life can be filled with struggles and challenges


But for me I try to see the button side
Seeking out the positive and optimistic aspects of life


Sometimes it be like the goodness be tryin' to hide
Acknowledging the difficulty of staying positive and finding hope in difficult situations


or tryin' to flee, but it can't, it's deep inside
Implying that goodness and hope are innate and cannot be entirely lost or destroyed


Sweetie you be the light for others, make 'em believe in God
Encouraging the listener to be a source of positivity and hope for those around them, and to have faith in a higher power




Lyrics © Peermusic Publishing
Written by: ROBERT JOHNSON, PETER KNIGHT

Lyrics Licensed & Provided by LyricFind
To comment on or correct specific content, highlight it

Genre not found
Artist not found
Album not found
Song not found

More Versions