coney island
Gabriel Kahane Lyrics


Jump to: Overall Meaning ↴  Line by Line Meaning ↴

Here at the freak show where the pinheads lie,
in their cage making faces at the passers-by,
I steal a glance, but they don't catch my eye, oh no.
There's a flutter in my stomach at the Siamese twins,
the loneliest couple with the same six limbs,
always together but they're still not friends, oh no.
There's a secret part of me gets so silent
by communion at Coney Island, oh.
At the end of the boardwalk there's an open door,
and it's headed out to heaven and a bright blue shore.
I take a breath, I'm scared to death, and I look up
And there's a secret part of me gets so silent
By communion at Coney Island, oh.
Please don't let a single person know




My crazy feeling at the circus show.
Truth of the matter is, it's here I feel at home.

Overall Meaning

In Gabriel Kahane's song "Coney Island," he captures the eerie yet comforting feeling of being at a freak show. He begins the song by describing the pinheads in their cage, making faces at the passersby. The use of the word "freak show" may imply that these people are being put on display for entertainment, which could be seen as unethical. However, as he continues to describe the other acts such as the Siamese twins and their struggles with friendship, he expresses empathy for these people and a sense of fascination.


The chorus brings in the theme of communion, which can be interpreted in a few ways. It could be seen as the communion of the singer with the performers, as he feels a connection to them despite their differences. Alternatively, it could be seen as a way for the singer to connect with something larger than himself, whether that's a feeling of acceptance or a higher power. This idea is reinforced in the final verse when Kahane sings about the door at the end of the boardwalk that leads to heaven and a bright blue shore.


Overall, "Coney Island" is an introspective and emotional song about the feeling of being different and finding solace in unexpected places. It speaks to the idea that there is beauty in diversity and that we can all find ways to connect with each other, even if we seem vastly different on the surface.


Line by Line Meaning

Here at the freak show where the pinheads lie,
At this place, where the unusual individuals are, and the heads of pins lie,


in their cage making faces at the passers-by,
Inside a confined space, making facial expressions to the people walking by,


I steal a glance, but they don't catch my eye, oh no.
I quickly look, but they do not grab my attention, oh no.


There's a flutter in my stomach at the Siamese twins,
There is a noticeable feeling of excitement within me because of the Siamese twins,


the loneliest couple with the same six limbs,
The most isolated pair with the same limbs,


always together but they're still not friends, oh no.
Despite always being with each other, they do not have a close relationship, oh no.


There's a secret part of me gets so silent
I have a part of me that becomes quiet and private


by communion at Coney Island, oh.
When I come together with everything Coney Island has to offer, oh.


At the end of the boardwalk there's an open door,
At the conclusion of the raised walkway is a clear entrance,


and it's headed out to heaven and a bright blue shore.
Leading to a paradise-like vision with a vivid sea of blue.


I take a breath, I'm scared to death, and I look up
I inhale deeply and then, frightened yet courageous, I look upwards.


And there's a secret part of me gets so silent
My private side becomes silent yet again.


By communion at Coney Island, oh.
As a result of my involvement with everything Coney Island has to offer, oh.


Please don't let a single person know
I implore you not to let anyone find out


My crazy feeling at the circus show.
My intense emotions while in the circus.


Truth of the matter is, it's here I feel at home.
The reality is, this is where I feel comfortable and accepted.




Writer(s): Gabriel John Kahane

Contributed by Lila P. Suggest a correction in the comments below.
To comment on or correct specific content, highlight it

Genre not found
Artist not found
Album not found
Song not found
Comments from YouTube:

@TW-sy6df

I believe that this song was originally going to be performed with Rachael Price (Lake Street Dive). Sarah Jarosz subbed in after Rachael's ankle injury. Came in from Nashville after I'm With Her picked up the award for Best Duo/Group at the Americana Music Association Awards. Bet it looks good next to the International Folk Artists of the year Award. Both well deserved.

More Versions