The second self-titled album by Good Old War is at its lush heart, an album of immense growth. A natural evolution from the band's debut Only Way to Be Alone (Sargent House), Good Old War radiates with warmth and vulnerability, both qualities undoubtedly cultivated by the band's hands-on self-production, and the environment of solitude in which the album was created.
Holed up in a remote house in the Pocono Mountains through the white winter month of February 2009, Keith Goodwin (vocalist/guitarist), Dan Schwartz (vocalist/guitarist), and Tim Arnold (vocalist/drummer) coalesced into a dynamic harmonious unit, using their time in complete isolation to explore new approaches to their music-making process: they learned new instruments; they wrote about subjects like love, loss, and addiction; they explored musical conventions far outside indie-rock/folk territory. Good Old War's sophomore album doesn't just maintain the intricate vocal harmonies, infectious sing-along melodies, and pop-song writing foundation of Only Way To Be Alone, it expands them. The results are a collection of songs that could translate from a living room to an arena without losing their heartbeat.
"This record is different because there's more shake, shake, shake," explains vocalist/drummer Tim Arnold. "The songs came from all over the place. They range from loneliness to domestic violence to drug addiction to true love. There are more instruments being struck by artists who know how to strike them. There's more strings being plucked by pluckers who know how to pluck them. There's more vocal chords vocalizing and there's more lungs breathing. There's more sun shining and there's more clouds forming. There's a constant amount of push/pull dynamic yet it reflects everyday, natural life."
"Individually, Keith and I wrote some of the best songs we ever wrote," explains vocalist/guitarist Dan Schwartz. "And, Tim completely murdered his drum tracks - all with only brushes! Collectively, we became a very tight group. We talked about everything: the words, the rhythms, the notes, which microphone to use. We learned from each other and got more confident in our songwriting and on our instruments together." Unlike their debut, which was extensively pre-planned and rehearsed, Good Old War was created from scratch in the studio. Rather than recording live as they did on Only Way To Be Alone, the album was recorded track by track, allowing the musicians to discover intricacies in each other's work.
Goodwin took on the bulk of the engineering, showing impressive talent at the mixing board and embracing the freedom of self-producing. "We wanted to make a record unlike any other. It was exciting to rely on and nurture our own production skills, which was a new experience for all of us. Because the core of our sound is about simple elements: guitar, vocal harmonies, and percussion, the production is simple and organic” he notes. "We discovered we had the ability to be largely self-reliant in the making of a record. I love that we can record whatever we want, whenever we want." With Goodwin steering the direction of the recording process, Good Old War is an album made with great conscientiousness to live performance; all arrangement on the record can be performed live and there are no guests on the album. The Final mix was provided by Jason Cupp
Good Old War's songwriting process has spontaneity, intuition and collectivity at its roots. The band first toured with Anthony Green in December 2007 (in lieu of Days Away which had recently dissolved). All of the songs that made their way onto the bands debut Only Way To Be Alone were written in a van on the way to those shows. Amidst the process of writing and touring, an innate musical kinship developed between Good Old War & Green; by the end of the tour the band was following their own set with a complete performance as Green's backing band. Months later Good Old War appeared on Avalon, Anthony Green's debut.
Only a month after officially choosing a name, Sargent House signed Good Old War and the band recorded the songs they had written on the road with Rick Parker and Jason Cupp. In May 2008, Sargent House announced a national tour during which the band would play a set of their own followed by a second set with Green yet again. The tour ended with a performance on Last Call with Carson Daly and the band released their debut album, Only Way to be Alone, which helped garner a loyal fanbase and overwhelmingly positive response from the press. Upon the album’s release, the single “Coney Island” began gaining attention at Triple A radio, while the video won MTVU’s “The Freshman” award and maintained heavy rotation for over three months.
Throughout 2009, Good Old War found themselves in a whirlwind of touring including dates with The Gaslight Anthem, The Heartless Bastards, Rx Bandits, and The Honorary Title. Towards the end of the year, Good Old War were seemingly everywhere; they sang "God Bless America" at a hometown Phillies game, played a multitude of radio events including WXPN’s XPoNential Fest, headlined their first tour (while also playing as the band for Cast Spells' Dave Davison), released a split EP (with Cast Spells), and jetted over to the west coast for a set of holiday shows with Anthony Green, continuing their long standing double-set tradition.
After two years of existence, Good Old War is gearing up for the release of their self-titled highly anticipated follow-up with lyrical topics ranging from love and loss to living life and everything in between. The album urges listeners to be aware of their own mortality by spending their days doing what they love; after all, it's a product of Good Old War doing just that.
coney island
Good Old War Lyrics
Jump to: Overall Meaning ↴ Line by Line Meaning ↴
And I said, "thank you for your thoughts, but I'm done."
I said that I would never build this up right here
And he said, "that's why I can't work with you son."
But I can't let this go I'm on my way
You can only hold my diamond ring
But I'll go crawling back to the city I love
I'm going to Coney Island have myself a dog
And reminisce why I still hate it here
It's all these people with their cotton candy eyes
It's so sweet, now put the train in gear
But I can't let this go I'm on my way
You can only hold my diamond ring
But I'll go crawling back to the city I love
Cause it's already taken everything
The ground is swallowing my options full release
And if it rains they might just disappear
I counted 27 birds up there today
I'm thinking that's why I still love it here
I'm thinking that's why I still love it here
But I can't let this go I'm on my way
You can only hold my diamond ring
But I'll go crawling back to the city I love
Cause it's already taken everything
Cause it's already taken everything
The song is a reflection on the conflicting feelings one has towards a place or situation that has both positive and negative memories attached to it. The singer has received a letter in the mail and is determined to move on from the situation, saying "thank you for your thoughts, but I'm done." However, the pull of the place, represented by the line "But I can't let this go, I'm on my way," is too strong to resist. He feels trapped, saying that the city has already taken everything, but still feels drawn to it. The contradiction in his feelings is evident throughout the song as he reminisces about visiting Coney Island and enjoying himself while also acknowledging that he hates it there. The singer's struggle to let go of this place he loves and hates at the same time is the underlying theme of the song.
The reference to Coney Island is significant in the song. While it's a fun, nostalgic destination for many, Coney Island has a darker side associated with it. The place has been neglected and often deserted, filled with crime and poverty. The carnival-like atmosphere of Coney Island can be a metaphor for the singer's desire for escape, as the place is known for its distractions and attractions.
Line by Line Meaning
I found a letter in the mailbox today
I received a letter in the mailbox today.
And I said, "thank you for your thoughts, but I'm done."
I expressed gratitude for the letter but declined to act on its contents.
I said that I would never build this up right here
I stated that I would not construct something in a particular location.
And he said, "that's why I can't work with you son."
Someone refused to collaborate with me due to my decision.
But I can't let this go I'm on my way
I cannot abandon this matter and have begun to act on it.
You can only hold my diamond ring
You can only obtain a valuable item from me, but not my commitment to this cause.
But I'll go crawling back to the city I love
I will return to the place that holds my affections despite any efforts to escape it.
Cause it's already taken everything
The city in question has already extracted all of my belongings or resources.
I'm going to Coney Island have myself a dog
I will travel to Coney Island to enjoy a hot dog.
And reminisce why I still hate it here
I will reflect on why I have negative feelings towards this place.
It's all these people with their cotton candy eyes
My dislike of the area is due to the behavior of the individuals who reside there.
It's so sweet, now put the train in gear
Despite the negative aspects, I still find something charming about the place and will return there on a train.
The ground is swallowing my options full release
I feel burdened and hindered by my lack of alternatives or freedom of choice.
And if it rains they might just disappear
The limited choices or opportunities available to me may vanish as quickly as they came, especially if conditions worsen.
I counted 27 birds up there today
I observed twenty-seven birds in the sky today.
I'm thinking that's why I still love it here
My appreciation for the place may be due to the presence or beauty of certain natural elements like the birds in the sky.
Cause it's already taken everything
My possessions and resources have already been depleted by this city.
Contributed by Makayla W. Suggest a correction in the comments below.
Lisa Bailey
I'm in love with this song. I first heard it in a restaurant bathroom in a trip to Boston. It was the day my divorce was final, and I remembered it until I got back to my lonely house in Kansas City. Then I got some Good Old War albums and felt complete again
SeanWatches
i saw them in concert last night, and they are even BETTER. keith has such a damn good voice.
MrMrNdw
You can't sing this song without smiling and having a good time.
l Redeemer
I had never heard of these people before but I recently went to a Xavier Rudd concert in Atlanta and these guys were the opening act and I was blown away!!! They are like a mellow Vampire Weekend BALLIN!
s SMASH
Wow. 12+ years later and this is still such a banger. I remember when this song was first put out. Listened non stop to these boys!
Pedro Villegas
i saw these guys live with Anthony and they are amazing. its amazing how 3 guys can come up with great acoustical music
DaKlogg
I saw these guys play with Circa Survive in Little Rock around 2009/2010. First time I heard them and I fell in love. One of the best shows I have ever been to.
Ross Cairns
I only just discovered this band...perfect for these lovely warm summers days right now!
tazer93
I just saw them live and THEY WERE AMAZING!!! Funny, cute, dancing, just perfect.
Cade Hammers
went to that same show. they did awesome. voices were spot on and theyre real chill. they're also the band anthony green uses for his solo albums.