Mystery
Gordon Downie Lyrics


Jump to: Overall Meaning ↴  Line by Line Meaning ↴

Somewhere there's a soccer game
I can hear the wild crowd moan
It's not that life here's distasteful to me
It's just that I'm all alone

I wanted what took a lifetime to learn
And to turn and to start again
And after that to turn and sigh
With no more pause than I hada then

It's not that it's such a mystery
I saw it from miles away

In time I'll only think of you
When I'm buttering my toast
Or in some other reflexive moment
When I expect the least or the most

It's not that it's such a mystery
It was practically on display

We've got "world enough and time"
And "wither youth" comes or goes
I hope you'll always think of me as "mine"
And not one of those

It's not that it's such a mystery
This new-found malaise




It's just that this mystery
Has taken your place

Overall Meaning

The song "Mystery" by Gordon Downie is a melancholic reflection on the singer's sense of alienation and disconnection from the world around him. The opening lines allude to a soccer game, suggesting an ordinary scenario that is taking place somewhere nearby, but he is unable to connect with it. The crowd's wild moaning highlights the contrast between the singer's internal state and the excitement of the crowd, emphasizing his sense of isolation.


The second verse begins with a realization that the singer desired a life journey that would require much learning, starting anew, and resignation over time. However, he appreciates he can't do it alone, and the long, drawn-out pause suggests that it's a personal realization. The chorus repeats the idea that the events unfolding around him aren't mysterious, just distant.


The third verse shows the progression of time, with a suggestion that the singer is trying to move on from the past. However, the musicality of buttering toast is so mundane that it brings back thoughts of memories. The final line of the verse expresses the fear that the essential things in his life be forgotten. The final chorus and closing lines reflect on the heartache that this great mystery, which is the cause of his feeling of disconnect, has taken over his happy memories.


Line by Line Meaning

Somewhere there's a soccer game
There's a soccer game happening somewhere, but the singer is not a part of it.


I can hear the wild crowd moan
The singer can hear the roar and unrest of the excited audience at the soccer game.


It's not that life here's distasteful to me
Although things are not that bad, the singer is not fully satisfied with their current state of life.


It's just that I'm all alone
The artist is feeling lonely and disconnected from the world around them.


I wanted what took a lifetime to learn
The artist craves knowledge and wants to learn things that require a long time to master.


And to turn and to start again
The singer desires to start over and begin fresh after learning something new.


And after that to turn and sigh
The singer would like to take a moment and breathe deeply after completing something significant.


With no more pause than I hada then
The artist wants to keep moving forward after achieving their goals without taking too long of a break.


It's not that it's such a mystery
The artist is trying to say that the situation is not that difficult or hard to figure out.


I saw it from miles away
The artist could see the situation coming from a long way off.


In time I'll only think of you
As time passes, the singer will think about the person they are addressing in this song more and more.


When I'm buttering my toast
The artist will think of the addressed person even during mundane activities like making breakfast.


Or in some other reflexive moment
There is a possibility that the singer will get lost in thought about the addressed person in unexpected moments.


When I expect the least or the most
The moments when the singer's thoughts will turn to the addressed person will be unpredictable and could happen at the least or the most expected times.


We've got "world enough and time"
There is no hurry to do anything, as there is more than enough time available.


And "wither youth" comes or goes
The youthfulness of the artist and the addressed person will pass with time.


I hope you'll always think of me as "mine"
The artist would like the addressed person to continue identifying them as someone they belong to.


And not one of those
The singer would prefer not to be grouped with others who the addressed person does not feel the same way about.


This new-found malaise
The singer is referring to a general feeling of dissatisfaction or depression.


It's just that this mystery
The source of the artist's emotional problems is not easily explained or understood.


Has taken your place
The issues in the artist's life have become more significant than their relationship with the addressed person.




Contributed by Carter E. Suggest a correction in the comments below.
To comment on or correct specific content, highlight it

Genre not found
Artist not found
Album not found
Song not found

More Versions