One of Us Cannot Be Wrong
Gregory Alan Isakov Lyrics


Jump to: Overall Meaning ↴  Line by Line Meaning ↴

I lit a thin green candle to make you jealous of me
The room filled up with mosquitoes
They heard that my body was free

And I took the dust of a long sleepless night
And I put it in your little shoe
And I must confess that I tortured the dress
That you wore for the world to look through

And I showed my heart to the doctor
He said, 'you just have to quit'
Then he wrote himself a prescription
And your name was mentioned in it

Then he locked himself in a library shelf
With the details of our honeymoon
And I hear from the nurse that he's gotten much worse
And his practice is all in a ruin

I once knew a saint who had loved you
I studied all night in his school
He taught that the duty of lovers
Was to tarnish the golden rule

And just when I was sure that his teachings were pure
He drowned himself in the pool
His body is gone, but out here on the lawn
His spirit continues to drool

An Eskimo showed me a movie
He'd recently taken of you
The poor man could hardly stop shivering
His lips and his fingers were blue

I suppose that he froze when the wind took your clothes
And I guess he just never got warm




But you stand there so nice, in your blizzard of ice
Please let me come into your storm

Overall Meaning

The lyrics to Gregory Alan Isakov's song One of Us Cannot Be Wrong contain a sense of particular confusion and longing, stemming from the singer's complexity towards their romantic interest. The song mentions the use of a green candle to create a feeling of jealousy in their lover, yet the mention of mosquitoes and the reference to the body being free, could be a metaphor to suggest a self-imposed isolation from someone they deeply desire. The singer also admits to putting the dust of a sleepless night in their lover's shoe, and the way they blatantly "tortured" their lover's dress could be interpreted as a representation of the kind of free-spiritedness that their lover may have found attractive, but has now become a source of frustration.
The singer goes on to describe how they showed their heart to the doctor, possibly as an act of desperation in their search for help, but the prescription reflects a kind of heartbreak remedy where their lover's name is mentioned. The mention of the doctor locking himself in a library shelf with details of the honeymoon shows that this loveless situation is causing everyone close to them to suffer. The lyrics about the Eskimo showing the singer a movie he had recently taken of the lover, and how the poor man could hardly stop shivering, speaks to the idea that the singer has a deep desire to see and share their lover's life but is unable to do so. When the singer asks to come into their storm, it could be a plea to be allowed to share this tumultuous time, with the hope of perhaps finding solace together.


Line by Line Meaning

I lit a thin green candle to make you jealous of me
I hoped that by making myself appear more desirable, it would provoke feelings of jealousy in you


The room filled up with mosquitoes
The candle attracted a swarm of mosquitoes into the room


They heard that my body was free
The mosquitoes were attracted to my uncovered and exposed body


And I took the dust of a long sleepless night And I put it in your little shoe
I collected the grime and dust from a night of insomnia and deliberately placed it inside your small shoe


And I must confess that I tortured the dress That you wore for the world to look through
I admit to mistreating the dress that you wore, which was meant to be seen and admired by others


And I showed my heart to the doctor He said, 'you just have to quit' Then he wrote himself a prescription And your name was mentioned in it
I shared my feelings with the doctor, who suggested that I needed to let go of you. He then prescribed himself a remedy, which included your name as a reference to our relationship


Then he locked himself in a library shelf With the details of our honeymoon And I hear from the nurse that he's gotten much worse And his practice is all in a ruin
The doctor, after collecting information about our honeymoon, locked himself away in a library shelf and began to spiral out of control. The nurse has informed me that his mental state has worsened and his profession is now in shambles


I once knew a saint who had loved you I studied all night in his school He taught that the duty of lovers Was to tarnish the golden rule
I knew a holy person who was in love with you, and I spent an entire night studying his teachings. According to him, lovers have a duty to break moral and ethical boundaries in their pursuit of love


And just when I was sure that his teachings were pure He drowned himself in the pool His body is gone, but out here on the lawn His spirit continues to drool
When I thought that his teachings were infallible, the holy man committed suicide. Though his physical body is gone, his corrupted spirit lives on and continues to be fascinated by you


An Eskimo showed me a movie He'd recently taken of you The poor man could hardly stop shivering His lips and his fingers were blue
An Inuit person showed me a film that he had recently taken of you. The man was visibly cold and seemed to be physically affected by the sight of you


I suppose that he froze when the wind took your clothes And I guess he just never got warm But you stand there so nice, in your blizzard of ice Please let me come into your storm
I assume that the man was so stunned and entranced by the sight of you losing your clothing to the wind that he was unable to warm himself afterward. Nevertheless, I find you attractive even in your icy exterior and wish to be close to your wild and tempestuous nature




Lyrics © BMG Rights Management
Written by: Leonard Cohen

Lyrics Licensed & Provided by LyricFind
To comment on or correct specific content, highlight it

Genre not found
Artist not found
Album not found
Song not found

Mike Modelle


on Time Will Tell

A Kansas wheat farmer wonders and worries about the price he will get for his bushels as they pour into some commercial silo.

More Versions