What If
I Robot Lyrics

The lyrics to I Robot's song, What If, are a heart-wrenching portrayal of the pain and confusion that come with losing someone important. The opening lines, "Eight and a half years of confusion turns into a lifetime of torment," suggest a prolonged period of uncertainty and instability that ultimately leads to enduring suffering. The second line, "Of replacing the unreplaceable," refers to the difficulty of finding a substitute for what has been lost, whether it be a person, a relationship, or something else entirely. The third line, "Of questioning the unquestionable," indicates a sense of desperation and confusion, as the singer struggles to make sense of what has happened and find some kind of resolution.

As the song progresses, the pain and longing of the singer become more pronounced. "My life without you will be exhausted by the burden of this question and this question alone," they sing, highlighting the all-consuming nature of grief and loss. The repetition of this line only underscores its importance, suggesting that the singer is stuck in an endless cycle of questioning and searching for answers. In the second verse, the singer takes on a more vulnerable tone, describing themselves as "tortured by regret" and "naked without your security." They reach out for something to hold onto, but find only the "delusion that maybe, one day, you'll give me the answers that I search for." The final line of the song, "Naked without your touch, smile, voice, and love," captures the profound emptiness and longing that come with losing someone close.

Overall, I Robot's What If is a powerful and poignant examination of what it means to lose someone important and to grapple with the resulting pain and confusion. Through its evocative lyrics and plaintive melodies, the song offers a window into the complex emotions that accompany this kind of experience.