Mystery
Indigo Girls Lyrics


Jump to: Overall Meaning ↴  Line by Line Meaning ↴

Each time you'd pull down the driveway
I wasn't sure when I would see you again
Yours was a twisted blind sided highway
No matter which road you took then
Oh you set up your place in my thoughts
Moved in and made my thinking crowded
Now we're out in the back with the barking dogs
My heart the red sun
Your heart the moon clouded
I could go crazy on a night like tonight
When summer's beginning to give up her fight
And every thought's a possibility
And the voices are heard but nothing is seen
Why do you spend this time with me
Maybe an equal mystery

So what is love then is it dictated or chosen
(Handed down and made by hand)
Does it sing like the hymns of 1000 years
Or is it just pop emotion
(Handed down and made by hand)
And if it ever was there and it left
Does it mean it was never true
And to exist it must elude
Is that why I think these things of you
I could go crazy on a night like tonight
When summer's beginning to give up her fight
And every thought's a possibility
And the voices are heard but nothing is seen
Why do you spend this time with me
May be an equal mystery

But you like the taste of danger
It shines like sugar on your lips
And you like to stand in the line of fire
Just to show you can shoot straight from you hip
There must be a 1000 things you would die for
I can hardly think of two
But not everything is better spoken aloud
Not when I'm talking to you

Oh the pirate gets the ship and the girl tonight
Breaks a bottle to christen her
Basking in the exploits of her thief
She's a very good listener
Maybe that's all that we need
Is to meet in the middle of impossibility
We're standing at opposite poles
Equal partners in a mystery
(Handed down and made by hand)





We're standing at opposite poles
Equal partners in a mystery

Overall Meaning

The song “Mystery” by Indigo Girls is a beautiful and emotional exploration of a complicated relationship. The lyrics describe how the singer felt uncertain and confused whenever her lover would leave, not knowing when they would see each other again. The metaphor of “twisted blind-sided highway” represents the unpredictable nature of the lover’s behavior which left the singer feeling emotionally crowded. Yet, despite the lover’s faults, the singer acknowledges that she is equally drawn to the mystery of the relationship.


The chorus of the song is particularly poignant, with the singer lamenting, “Why do you spend this time with me? Maybe an equal mystery.” She wonders about the nature of love and whether or not it is something that is chosen, or something that is handed down by force. The imagery of “pop emotion” highlights the idea that love can be fickle and fleeting, but that doesn't mean it isn't real.


The final verses of the song incorporate the metaphor of pirates and stolen ships, representing the unpredictability - and danger - of the love affair. Yet even in the face of uncertainty and danger, the two main characters remain “equal partners in a mystery,” standing at opposite poles but still drawn together.


Line by Line Meaning

Each time you'd pull down the driveway
I was uncertain about our future each time you left


I wasn't sure when I would see you again
The unpredictability of our relationship made me feel uncertain


Yours was a twisted blind sided highway
Your journey in life was complex and unpredictable


No matter which road you took then
Your actions were unpredictable and difficult to anticipate


Oh you set up your place in my thoughts
You occupied a significant space in my mind


Moved in and made my thinking crowded
You had a strong influence on my thoughts and feelings


Now we're out in the back with the barking dogs
We are in a difficult situation or environment


My heart the red sun
My heart burns passionately for you


Your heart the moon clouded
Your feelings for me are uncertain and unclear


I could go crazy on a night like tonight
The sense of possibility and the unknown can be overwhelming


When summer's beginning to give up her fight
The changing of seasons can symbolize the changes in our relationship


And every thought's a possibility
I am filled with hope and uncertainty about what we could become


And the voices are heard but nothing is seen
There is a sense of confusion and chaos in my thoughts and feelings


Why do you spend this time with me
I am unsure of your intentions and your feelings for me


Maybe an equal mystery
Perhaps our connection and attraction is equally inexplicable


So what is love then is it dictated or chosen
Is love something that is predetermined or a conscious choice?


(Handed down and made by hand)
Is love something that is inherited or created by individual effort?


Does it sing like the hymns of 1000 years
Is love something timeless and universal?


Or is it just pop emotion
Or is it something that is trendy and fleeting?


And if it ever was there and it left
If love fades away, was it truly genuine?


Does it mean it was never true
Does the loss of love negate its earlier existence?


And to exist it must elude
Perhaps love can only survive by being elusive and mysterious


Is that why I think these things of you
Perhaps the mystery of love is why I am drawn to you


But you like the taste of danger
You are attracted to risky and exciting situations


It shines like sugar on your lips
You find danger irresistible and tempting


And you like to stand in the line of fire
You enjoy taking risks and testing yourself


Just to show you can shoot straight from you hip
You want to prove that you are capable and skilled


There must be a 1000 things you would die for
You have a strong sense of loyalty and dedication


I can hardly think of two
I am not as confident in my own convictions and values


But not everything is better spoken aloud
Some things are best left unsaid or unacknowledged


Not when I'm talking to you
Especially when communicating with you


Oh the pirate gets the ship and the girl tonight
Sometimes the person who takes risks and breaks rules is rewarded


Breaks a bottle to christen her
Celebrating a new beginning or adventure


Basking in the exploits of her thief
Enjoying the thrills and excitement of a daring partner


She's a very good listener
She is attentive and understanding


Maybe that's all that we need
Perhaps we just need someone to listen and understand us


Is to meet in the middle of impossibility
Perhaps we can find common ground despite our differences


We're standing at opposite poles
We are very different from each other


Equal partners in a mystery
Despite our differences, we are both drawn to the mysterious nature of our connection




Lyrics © Universal Music Publishing Group
Written by: EMILY ANN SALIERS

Lyrics Licensed & Provided by LyricFind
To comment on or correct specific content, highlight it

Genre not found
Artist not found
Album not found
Song not found

More Versions