Two Brothers
Jimmie Rodgers Lyrics


Jump to: Overall Meaning ↴  Line by Line Meaning ↴

Two young brothers on their way
Two young brothers on their way
Two brothers on their way
One wore blue and one wore grey

One wore blue and one wore grey
One wore blue and one wore grey
The fifen drums begin to play
All on a beautiful morning

One was gentle one was kind
One was gentle and one was kind
One was gentle one was kind
But a cannonball don't pay no mind

A cannonball don't pay no mind
Who is gentle and who is kind
One came home one stayed behind
Two girls waiting by the railroad track

Two girls waiting by the railroad track
Two girls waiting by the railroad track
One wore blue and one wore black

One wore blue and one wore black
One wore blue and one wore black




Waiting for their loves to come back
All on a beautiful morning

Overall Meaning

The lyrics to Jimmie Rodgers's song Two Brothers tells the story of two young brothers who go to war for opposite sides, one wearing blue and the other grey. The song is based on the American Civil War, a conflict where the nation was deeply divided along geographic and ideological lines. The melody of the song is bittersweet, evoking feelings of sadness and loss but also of hope and longing.


The song's opening lines emphasize the youth and innocence of the brothers, setting the stage for a tragic story. The repetition of the line "Two brothers on their way" creates a sense of inevitability, as if the brothers were destined to meet their fates on the battlefield. The line "One wore blue and one wore grey" highlights the division that had taken hold of the nation, with brothers fighting against brothers and families torn apart.


The song contrasts the personalities of the two brothers, with one being gentle and kind and the other being undefined. The line "But a cannonball don't pay no mind" underscores the fact that war is a brutal, indiscriminate force that can take away even the gentlest of souls. The final stanza of the song brings the story full circle, with two girls waiting for their loves to return. The imagery of one wearing blue and one wearing black suggests that one of the brothers has died, bringing home the cost of the war in a poignant and heart-wrenching way.


Line by Line Meaning

Two young brothers on their way
Two brothers, young and full of hope, were traveling


Two brothers on their way
These two brothers are journeying towards their respective destinies


One wore blue and one wore grey
One of these brothers was clad in blue, the other in grey military uniform, signifying the opposing sides they were on during a war


The fifen drums begin to play
The sound of a fife and drum instrument heralded the beginning of the conflict


All on a beautiful morning
Ironically, the war began on a bright and pleasant morning, when everything seemed peaceful and perfect


One was gentle one was kind
One of the brothers had a gentle and kind disposition


One was gentle and one was kind
The distinction between the two brothers was made again, emphasizing their character traits


One was gentle one was kind
Even though they had different personalities, they were both just young boys


But a cannonball don't pay no mind
The cannonball didn't discriminate and caused havoc and destruction regardless of who was kind or who was cruel


A cannonball don't pay no mind
The brothers' differences were rendered irrelevant in the face of the deadly weapon


Who is gentle and who is kind
The cannonball had no way of knowing who was the gentle one or who was the kind one; it injured and killed indiscriminately


One came home one stayed behind
One of the brothers managed to survive the war and the other did not


Two girls waiting by the railroad track
Their loved ones had left behind girlfriends or wives who were waiting for them to return at a railway station


Two girls waiting by the railroad track
The waiting girlfriends or wives are symbolic of the many people who suffer when their loved ones go to war


One wore blue and one wore black
One girl was mourning for her blue-clad Union soldier, while the other was wearing black for her grey-clad Confederate lover


One wore blue and one wore black
Just like the brothers, the girlfriends or wives were also on opposing sides of the conflict


Waiting for their loves to come back
The girls were waiting patiently for their beloveds to return home safely from the war


All on a beautiful morning
The same war to which they bid adieu on a bright morning, they awaited its return on another fine day




Lyrics © O/B/O APRA AMCOS
Written by: TRAD

Lyrics Licensed & Provided by LyricFind
To comment on or correct specific content, highlight it

Genre not found
Artist not found
Album not found
Song not found
Most interesting comments from YouTube:

@Sj27m

My dear old Dad was born in 1901 and this was one of his favorite songs in his large repertoire.
I was born in 1966 and Dad turned 66 two months after I was born.
Can you imagine having a new born baby at 66years old?
What a remarkable man.
Up into his 90s
He would step out on the front porch, dance a jig and yodel so loud that the neighbors dog 75 yards away would bark, and he would have a big laugh.
He had a kids heart and a charisma unmatched by anyone I've ever met.
He made the world a much much happier place to live, and I had no idea how much I would miss him.
Everyone loved and respected Dad and he loved and respected everyone.
Remembering those happy times and his laughter and light heartedness has brought me through to many hard times to remember.
He is still my best friend and my rock. LOVE YOU DAD AND MOM AND I KNOW WE'LL BE TOGETHER AGAIN
SOON. ❤❤❤



@Sj27m

@@zackyhgyi8772
I have him on tape taking about when he was young.
When he was a kid the guy that ran the movie projector in the theater would give him candy and drinks to turn the hand crank movie projector so he could rest his arm.
No sound but someone would play the piano while the movie played.
He lived in Chicago and Detroit when Dillinger , Pretty boy Floyd, Baby face Nelson, MA Barker, AL Capone , Bonnie and Clide were running around the country.
He went to cash his check at the bank and it was closed and they were replacing the glass window in front because Dillinger had robed it earlier that day and the glass had been shot out.
He worked at Fisher Body in the 20s and later at Hudson, and at Packard in the 40s turning the crank shafts that were going in the Rolls Royce motors that were going in the fighter planes in WW2.
I have all his paperwork showing his job titles and all his drivers licenses from 1936 up to the last one he had in the 90s in his last bill fold.
He saw Halley's comet twice, lived through the Spanish flue, great depression, the dust bowl years.
Frank James, Jeronimo, Wyatt Earp, Annie Oakley, were all still alive when he was young.
I miss hearing him tell about those times.



All comments from YouTube:

@greggwiltfang2915

Born in 1952, I learned this one and many other old tunes (e.g., "Heartaches by the Number") by going to country music shows with my dad's sister and husband, Illinois, German farmers. Traveled by bus where we all sang hymns and popular songs, accompanied by accordions. Though too young to remember it, mom and I went with the same aunt and uncle to the original Ryman Theater. I'm still a lover of old country music.

@kevinwaters5872

Jimmie Rodgers was modern then , and he is still modern now. Real music never ages.

@steveanthrop192

I'm 62 years old and remember my parents having Jimmy's albums.

@noahthebeast3617

Hey man I’m 12 and love this music always have been a fan of the old country classics love Jimmie rodgers

@byeond_the_sea_1959

same

@donaldleroy6502

That's awesome, good taste knows no age, with a few exceptions like myself that didn't learn to appreciate this until I was in my 40s

@drama.crush3

My grandpa, he was born in 1937, and whenever I’m on a road trip with him driving somewhere, he’s always singing and whistling this tune. I just had to look it up and play it for him 💖 (10/27/23)

@Sj27m

My dear old Dad was born in 1901 and this was one of his favorite songs in his large repertoire.
I was born in 1966 and Dad turned 66 two months after I was born.
Can you imagine having a new born baby at 66years old?
What a remarkable man.
Up into his 90s
He would step out on the front porch, dance a jig and yodel so loud that the neighbors dog 75 yards away would bark, and he would have a big laugh.
He had a kids heart and a charisma unmatched by anyone I've ever met.
He made the world a much much happier place to live, and I had no idea how much I would miss him.
Everyone loved and respected Dad and he loved and respected everyone.
Remembering those happy times and his laughter and light heartedness has brought me through to many hard times to remember.
He is still my best friend and my rock. LOVE YOU DAD AND MOM AND I KNOW WE'LL BE TOGETHER AGAIN
SOON. ❤❤❤

@zackyhgyi8772

Your dad lived through america in a time barely any modern american could imagine! What a hell of a year for him to be born.. sadly a lost generation!

@Sj27m

@@zackyhgyi8772
I have him on tape taking about when he was young.
When he was a kid the guy that ran the movie projector in the theater would give him candy and drinks to turn the hand crank movie projector so he could rest his arm.
No sound but someone would play the piano while the movie played.
He lived in Chicago and Detroit when Dillinger , Pretty boy Floyd, Baby face Nelson, MA Barker, AL Capone , Bonnie and Clide were running around the country.
He went to cash his check at the bank and it was closed and they were replacing the glass window in front because Dillinger had robed it earlier that day and the glass had been shot out.
He worked at Fisher Body in the 20s and later at Hudson, and at Packard in the 40s turning the crank shafts that were going in the Rolls Royce motors that were going in the fighter planes in WW2.
I have all his paperwork showing his job titles and all his drivers licenses from 1936 up to the last one he had in the 90s in his last bill fold.
He saw Halley's comet twice, lived through the Spanish flue, great depression, the dust bowl years.
Frank James, Jeronimo, Wyatt Earp, Annie Oakley, were all still alive when he was young.
I miss hearing him tell about those times.

More Comments

More Versions