Why There's a Tear in My Eye
Jimmie Rodgers Lyrics


Jump to: Overall Meaning ↴  Line by Line Meaning ↴

I once loved a beautiful maiden
As fair as the blue skies above
And each night as we wondered together
The moon seemed to smile on our love
We vowed to be true to each other
And nothing could cause us to part
But we never once dreamed that the future
Held only a broken heart
Then there came the night when we parted
We quarrelled as all sweethearts do
And I learned what it was to be jealous
When she told me our love was untrue
She told me she had always been faithful
She swore that her love could not die
And then when I did not believe her
She kissed me and told me goodbye

Oh-de lay-ee oh, de lay-ee yo-de lay-ee

I found I had falsely accused her
And went back to make her my bride
And there in the door stood her mother
She told me my sweetheart had died
I went in and knelt down beside her
And there in the hush of that room
I prayed that my maker would take me
And send my soul down to it's doom
So now I have told you the reason
There's always a tear in my eye
For long weary years I've repented
But I'm longing to lay down and die
And I wonder if I'll be forgiven
When I face the master someday
And I wonder if I'll see my sweetheart
On that beautiful shore far away





Oh-de lay-ee oh, de lay-ee yo-de lay-ee

Overall Meaning

In "Why There's a Tear in My Eye" by Jimmie Rodgers, the singer reflects upon a past love affair that ended in heartbreak and regret. The lyrics express the singer's deep love and devotion to a beautiful maiden, emphasizing the happiness they once shared under the gaze of the moon. They made promises to always remain faithful to each other, ignorant of the future's cruel twist of fate.


However, one fateful night, they quarreled like any other couple, and the singer's jealousy caused him to doubt the sincerity of their love. The maiden desperately tried to convince him of her fidelity, but unable to trust her, he pushed her away. When he realized his mistake and went to find her, he was met by her mother at the door, delivering the devastating news of the maiden's death. In that moment, the singer's world shattered, prompting him to question his own worth and plead for punishment for his actions.


Throughout the song, the singer reveals that the tear in his eye is a constant reminder of the remorse he carries. He has spent years repenting for the loss of his true love, feeling a deep longing to be reunited with her in death. He expresses doubt about his own chances of forgiveness when facing the higher powers, wondering if he will ever see his sweetheart again on the shores of the afterlife.


Overall, "Why There's a Tear in My Eye" is a sorrowful reflection on lost love, regret, and the longing for redemption. It explores themes of trust, the consequences of actions, and the profound impact of losing someone dear.


Line by Line Meaning

I once loved a beautiful maiden
There was a time when I had deep affection for a captivating young woman


As fair as the blue skies above
Her beauty could rival the expanse of serene blue skies


And each night as we wondered together
Every evening we strolled aimlessly, hand in hand


The moon seemed to smile on our love
The moon appeared to reflect the happiness of our love


We vowed to be true to each other
We made a solemn pledge to remain loyal and faithful


And nothing could cause us to part
No circumstance could separate us from each other


But we never once dreamed that the future
Yet, we failed to anticipate what lay ahead


Held only a broken heart
It contained nothing but a shattered and wounded heart


Then there came the night when we parted
That fateful night arrived when we bid farewell


We quarrelled as all sweethearts do
We engaged in an argument like any other couple in love


And I learned what it was to be jealous
I discovered the torment of feeling jealous


When she told me our love was untrue
She confessed that our love had been false


She told me she had always been faithful
She professed unwavering loyalty throughout


She swore that her love could not die
She vehemently declared that her love would never perish


And then when I did not believe her
However, my skepticism caused disbelief


She kissed me and told me goodbye
With a final kiss, she bid me farewell


I found I had falsely accused her
Upon reflection, I realized that my accusations were untrue


And went back to make her my bride
Filled with remorse, I returned to claim her as my wife


And there in the door stood her mother
To my astonishment, her mother was blocking the entrance


She told me my sweetheart had died
She delivered the devastating news of my beloved's demise


I went in and knelt down beside her
I entered and humbly knelt next to her lifeless form


And there in the hush of that room
In the silence of that room, devoid of life's noise


I prayed that my maker would take me
I pleaded for my Creator to swiftly end my existence


And send my soul down to its doom
To send my soul to a wretched and despairing fate


So now I have told you the reason
Hence, I have elucidated the cause behind my sorrow


There's always a tear in my eye
That's why a teardrop forever lingers in my eye


For long weary years I've repented
Throughout countless years of exhaustion, I have sought forgiveness


But I'm longing to lay down and die
Yet, I yearn for the release of death and cessation of suffering


And I wonder if I'll be forgiven
I ponder whether absolution awaits my remorseful soul


When I face the master someday
When I confront the divine ruler in due time


And I wonder if I'll see my sweetheart
I also question if I will reunite with my beloved


On that beautiful shore far away
In that distant and exquisite realm


Oh-de lay-ee oh, de lay-ee yo-de lay-ee
An expression of sorrow and lamentation




Lyrics © O/B/O APRA AMCOS

Lyrics Licensed & Provided by LyricFind
To comment on or correct specific content, highlight it

Genre not found
Artist not found
Album not found
Song not found
Comments from YouTube:

T4TEXASTOM JOHNNYCAT

The Father of Country Music harmonizing with Sara Carter, and her cousin & sister-in-law Maybelle strumming & picking the guitar. Legends all.

The Carter Family Channel

The king and queen of country music :)

Joshua Eden

This sad story reminds one of the “Winter’s Tale.”

Filtered Songs No Copyright

Lyrics please

More Versions