Tell Me a Lie
Kelly Clarkson Lyrics


Jump to: Overall Meaning ↴  Line by Line Meaning ↴

Can't ever get it right
No matter how hard I try
And i've tried
I put up a good fight
But your words cut like knives
And im tired

As you break my heart again this time
Tell me I'm a screwed up mess
That I never listen listen
Tell me you don't want my kiss
That you're needing distance distance

Tell me everything but don't you say she's what you're missing baby
If she's the reason your leaving me here tonight
Spare me what you think and tell me
Tell me a lie.

You're the charming type
That little tweinke in your eye
Gets me every time
And well there must have been a time
I was a reason for that smile

So keep in mind

As you take whats left of you and I
Tell me I'm a screwed up mess
That I never listen listen

Tell me you don't want my kiss
That you're needing distance distance

Tell me everything but don't you say she's what you're missing baby
If she's the reason your leaving me here tonight
Spare me what you think and tell me
Tell me a lie.

Tell me I'm a screwed up mess
That I never listen listen

Tell me you don't want my kiss
That you're needing distance distance

Tell me everything but don't you say she's what you're missing baby
If she's the reason your leaving me here tonight




Spare me what you think and tell me
Tell me a lie.

Overall Meaning

In this song, Kelly Clarkson expresses her frustration and disappointment with a lover who is leaving her for someone else. She admits that despite her efforts to be the perfect partner, she is not able to please him. She asks him to spare her the truth about his reasons for leaving, as she cannot bear to hear that she is being replaced by another woman. Instead, she asks him to tell her a lie, to tell her that she is a mess and that he doesn't want her anymore, but to keep the other woman out of it.


The song is essentially about the pain of rejection and the desire to avoid facing the truth of a failed relationship. By asking for a lie, the singer is trying to protect herself from the harsh reality of being rejected in favor of someone else. She is also demonstrating a lack of self-esteem, as she seems to believe that she is not good enough for her partner and that he is leaving her because of her flaws.


Overall, the lyrics convey a sense of vulnerability and emotional turmoil, as the singer struggles to come to terms with the end of her relationship. Despite her strength and resilience, she cannot escape the pain of rejection and the fear of being replaced by someone else.


Line by Line Meaning

Can't ever get it right
I feel like I can never do anything right in your eyes.


No matter how hard I try
Even when I put in a lot of effort, it doesn't seem to make a difference.


And i've tried
Believe me, I've done everything I can to make things work between us.


I put up a good fight
I've been trying really hard to keep our relationship going.


But your words cut like knives
Your words hurt me deeply.


And im tired
I'm exhausted from trying so hard to make things work between us.


As you break my heart again this time
You're hurting me once again with your actions or words.


Tell me I'm a screwed up mess
It seems like you think I'm a complete disaster.


That I never listen listen
You think I don't pay attention to what you say.


Tell me you don't want my kiss
You don't want anything to do with me anymore, even physically.


That you're needing distance distance
You want to put some space between us.


Tell me everything but don't you say she's what you're missing baby
Don't tell me that you're leaving me for someone else.


If she's the reason your leaving me here tonight
If you're leaving me for someone else, don't let it be because of her.


Spare me what you think and tell me
I don't need you to tell me what you really think of me.


You're the charming type
You have a way of making me like you, even when you treat me poorly.


That little tweinke in your eye
You have a mischievous glint in your eye that makes me want to believe in you.


Gets me every time
Even though you've hurt me before, I keep falling for your charms.


And well there must have been a time
I remember a time when we were happy together.


I was a reason for that smile
I hope that I at least made you happy at some point.




Contributed by Kayla M. Suggest a correction in the comments below.
To comment on or correct specific content, highlight it

Genre not found
Artist not found
Album not found
Song not found
Comments from YouTube:

Jan Probasco

I just wish Kelly would actually record and release this song...I just love it. Others versions of it pale.

Danielle Kramer

Had no idea she wrote this until today. Her version is good too. Wish she would release it.

Slayzee Michaella

I liked her version but I honestly like 1D version better

Brittany Elizabeth

I think both versions are good, but I think I like this one just a bit better.

Brianna Kae

I love Kelly Clarkson and One Direction both but I think 1D's version is better.

Bianca Garcia

Actually, it was hers first, and then she gave it to them, but still live the video!

Shaira Mae Fernandez

i liked it so much <3

Ameh ;-;

<3 This from both 1D and her

Kas H

i think both their versions are good

Rjeplin

Kelly Clarkson wrote this song and was going to put it on her Stronger album, but it got leaked.  She decided to give it to one direction.  They both are good versions, but Kelly wrote it so technically it is her song.

More Comments

More Versions