First Reactions After Falling Through the Ice
La Dispute Lyrics


Jump to: Overall Meaning ↴  Line by Line Meaning ↴

I knew it was far too late to walk out on the lake then
Halfway to the middle thawed I wasn't doing all that great

Had I cut my hair short?
Had I grown my beard out long?
Had I gone to school or?

Why do all my plans fall through?

There's a leak in the basement
Stupid permanent estrangement
Casement windows need glazing
Hinges and arms need be replaced

All the way at the edge I said I think
That we should head back
What if now the ice cracked?
Think I felt it bend

We took opposite steps
Tried to even the stress
Picked a safe direction but
You never know the way the ice thins

Half-asleep in dreams where
Ceilings start collapsing
Free fall through the roof beams
Get startled back awake
Before you hit the pavement
Floor of the foundation
Water in the basement
Bodies in the lake

Don't panic I could hear you saying as I fell through
Blackness complete down waiting till my feet touched ground

At the bottom they finally did
First reaction was this is it
Next thought was just stay calm kick up
And save your phone

Because I wanted to tell you
Because I thought you should know

Because I thought it might scare you
To see me under the ice
Make you remember you cared for me
What would you do if I died?
Would you fly out for my funeral?
Get too drunk at my wake?
Would you make a scene then?
Climb in and try to resuscitate me?

I was on the ice and I was underwater
I was getting pulled out, I was in my wet clothes
Stumble on the walk back, someone stoked the fire at camp
I was by the flames trying to get my body warm
I was standing naked checking to see if my phone still worked

I will cut my hair short
Trust me, I will
I will let my beard go
Trust me, I will
I will never tempt fate
Not once, I swear




I will never trust ice
I will never trust a thing

Overall Meaning

The song First Reactions After Falling Through the Ice by La Dispute is a story of a person who falls through the ice in the middle of a lake. The lyrics contain the thoughts of the person while they are struggling to survive and the aftermath of the experience. The song begins with the singer recounting their thoughts as they walked out on the lake, questioning whether they had made the right choices in their life. As they begin to feel the effects of the cold water and the ice cracking beneath them, they become aware of their near-death experience. They are terrified and with no hope of rescue, they begin to consider what the aftermath of their death would be like for those they care about.


The person's thoughts then shift to their current situation in real-time. They are experiencing a nightmare-like scenario where they are half asleep, and it feels like their ceilings are collapsing, and they are free-falling through the roof beams. Then they wake up before hitting the pavement and find themselves at the bottom of the lake. The first reaction is relief, they are alive, and the next thought is to stay calm and save their phone.


In the final section of the song, the person reflects on their experience and how it has changed them. They vow to change their ways, cut their hair short, grow their beard out long, and never again trust ice or tempt their fate.


Overall, the song is an incredibly powerful portrayal of the experience of death and the profound effect it can have on a person. It is a reminder that life is precious and that we must cherish it while we can.


Line by Line Meaning

I knew it was far too late to walk out on the lake then
I realized that it was already too late to step out of the lake


Halfway to the middle thawed I wasn't doing all that great
I was already in the middle of the lake, thawed and I wasn't doing well


Had I cut my hair short?
I wonder if I had cut my hair short


Had I grown my beard out long?
I wonder if I had grown my beard out long


Had I gone to school or?
I wonder if I had gone to school or not


Why do all my plans fall through?
Why do all my plans fail?


There's a leak in the basement
There is a leak in the basement


Stupid permanent estrangement
A foolish and unchangeable separation


Casement windows need glazing
Casement windows need new glass


Hinges and arms need be replaced
Hinges and arms need to be replaced


All the way at the edge I said I think
At the edge of the lake, I said


That we should head back
We should go back now


What if now the ice cracked?
What if the ice cracks now?


Think I felt it bend
I think I felt it bending


We took opposite steps
We walked in opposite directions


Tried to even the stress
Trying to balance the pressure


Picked a safe direction but
Chose a safe direction but


You never know the way the ice thins
You can never know how thin the ice is


Half-asleep in dreams where
Half-awake in dreams where


Ceilings start collapsing
The ceilings begin to fall down


Free fall through the roof beams
Falling freely through the roof beams


Get startled back awake
Suddenly waking up


Before you hit the pavement
Before hitting the ground


Floor of the foundation
The floor of the foundation of the building


Water in the basement
Water in the basement


Bodies in the lake
Dead bodies in the lake


Don't panic I could hear you saying as I fell through
I could hear you saying 'Don't panic' as I fell through


Blackness complete down waiting till my feet touched ground
It was complete darkness as I waited for my feet to touch the ground


At the bottom they finally did
My feet finally touched the bottom


First reaction was this is it
My first reaction was this was the moment of my death


Next thought was just stay calm kick up
My next thought was to relax and resurface


And save your phone
And save the phone from being lost


Because I wanted to tell you
Because I wanted to tell you


Because I thought you should know
Because I thought you should know


Because I thought it might scare you
Because I thought it might scare you


To see me under the ice
To see me trapped under the ice


Make you remember you cared for me
To remind you of your affection towards me


What would you do if I died?
What would you do if I died?


Would you fly out for my funeral?
Would you travel to attend my funeral?


Get too drunk at my wake?
Would you get too drunk at my wake?


Would you make a scene then?
Would you create a scene at my death?


Climb in and try to resuscitate me?
Would you climb in to try and save me?


I was on the ice and I was underwater
I was under the ice and underwater


I was getting pulled out, I was in my wet clothes
I was being pulled out while wearing my wet clothes


Stumble on the walk back, someone stoked the fire at camp
While walking back, I stumbled and someone started a fire


I was by the flames trying to get my body warm
I warmed my cold body by the flames


I was standing naked checking to see if my phone still worked
I was standing naked, checking if my phone still works and is not damaged.


I will cut my hair short
I will cut my hair short


Trust me, I will
Believe me, I will


I will let my beard go
I will let my beard grow


Not once, I swear
I swear, not even once


I will never trust ice
I will never trust the ice


I will never trust a thing
I will never trust anything




Lyrics © BMG Rights Management
Written by: ADAM DAVID VASS, BRADLEY RYEN VANDER LUGT, CHAD WILLIAM STERENBERG, JORDAN LEE DREYER, KEVIN SCOTT WHITTEMORE

Lyrics Licensed & Provided by LyricFind
To comment on or correct specific content, highlight it

Genre not found
Artist not found
Album not found
Song not found
Comments from YouTube:

@MathCoreMC

This is the most important album I've heard in years.

@ghcstie

This is probably my favourite song from the album, to be honest.

@chuncineykinard6233

same

@beverlydoesstuff642

Omg you like La Dispute and Brand New let's be best friends.

But to be honest as great as it is, this is not my favorite on the album. My favorites are probably Stay Happy There, Hudsonville, MI 1956, or Woman (Reading). I can't pick just one.

@ghcstie

BeverlyDoesStuff haha, welcome to the world of late 2000s punk-alt. I rly enjoy stay happy there too, I think I just feel a stronger connection to this one

@FNZOTV

Let's start a petition for a la dispute and brand new tour

@azschrreff

I FREAKING LOVE BRAND NEW ND LA DISPUTE, THEY RE THE ELLIOTT SMITH 4 ME

3 More Replies...

@lolno6768

It's taken like four years for me to finally understand that this is all metaphorical. Evert song loosely follows a narrative about a failed relationship, relating it back to objects and rooms in a house (hence the name) I had a vague sense it was, but I could never connect the dots on my own.

The first song, the storm, is the onset of trouble in a relationship. This song is literally "their relationship is on thin ice". I mean, for fuck sake, they're even moving opposite directions on THIN ICE. Just listen to this album with this theme in mind. 35, while not my favorite is the point where this fictional relationship literally collapses and falls apart. Notice the lyrical content in every song afterwards - usually about understanding, regret, pain, and then eventually catharsis and healing.

Fucking brilliant.

@papakielbasa7077

I think your take on it is spot on, but I also think that the name of the album "Rooms of the House" and the several comparisons of a house and its rooms represent the narrator's relationship and the memories he feels when he looks into these rooms. In this song, it talks in the verses about his relationship and how he views the small things he sees as flaws ( his long hair, hairless face, lack of education/career choice) the same as the small fixer-up problems the house has. It could also represent how small problems (small house damages/small cracks on ice) can eventually pile on to the point where, like his relationship, everything collapses (ceiling collapsing/ falling through ice).


But I could be totally wrong lol

@BabvBlues

i think we all had a vague sense of it, but u explained it very well, would love to hear more of your thoughts

More Comments

More Versions