Who By Fire?
Leonard Cohen Lyrics


Jump to: Overall Meaning ↴  Line by Line Meaning ↴

And who by fire, who by water
Who in the sunshine, who in the night time
Who by high ordeal, who by common trial
Who in your merry merry month of may
Who by very slow decay
And who shall I say is calling?

And who in her lonely slip, who by barbiturate
Who in these realms of love, who by something blunt
Who by avalanche, who by powder
Who for his greed, who for his hunger
And who shall I say is calling?

And who by brave assent, who by accident
Who in solitude, who in this mirror
Who by his lady's command, who by his own hand




Who in mortal chains, who in power
And who shall I say is calling?

Overall Meaning

Leonard Cohen's song Who By Fire? poses existential questions about the inevitability of death and the different ways it can happen. The song asks a series of questions, each beginning with the phrase "who by," which creates a sense of unknown and ambiguity. The first question asks "who by fire, who by water" invoking the idea of fire and water as both dangerous and cleansing elements. This is followed by "who in the sunshine, who in the night time" which could be interpreted as a metaphor for life and death. The next line "who by high ordeal, who by common trial" emphasis the notion that death can come through difficult and challenging times or simply through everyday life.


The lyrics continue to delve into different ways one might die, referencing death by slow decay, loneliness, drug overdose, and various natural disasters. The final verses present the idea of death by "brave assent" or "accident," and then ends with the question "who shall I say is calling?" which could be interpreted as the personification of death asking who its next victim will be. Overall, the song is a contemplative meditation on the nature of death and the uncertain fate that awaits us all.


Line by Line Meaning

And who by fire, who by water
Who will suffer through a violent death from fire, who by drowning?


Who in the sunshine, who in the night time
Who will perish by day under bright light, and who will die under the cloak of darkness?


Who by high ordeal, who by common trial
Who will triumph when tested through a daunting trial, and who will succumb with ease during a common test?


Who in your merry merry month of May
Who will be taken during your joyous month of May?


Who by very slow decay
Who will face death through a painfully slow degeneration?


And who shall I say is calling?
Who is calling out to decide the fate of these beings?


And who in her lonely slip, who by barbiturate
Who will die alone in her undergarment, who by overdosing on barbiturates?


Who in these realms of love, who by something blunt
Who will perish in this world of love, who by a blunt, forceful tool used as a weapon?


Who by avalanche, who by powder
Who will be taken by an avalanche of snow, who by gun powder?


Who for his greed, who for his hunger
Who will die due to their unquenchable thirst for wealth or their insatiable hunger?


And who shall I say is calling?
Who is calling out to decide the fate of these beings?


And who by brave assent, who by accident
Who will embrace death with courageous acceptance, who because of chance or misfortune?


Who in solitude, who in this mirror
Who will depart from this world in solitude, or who will perish by looking in the mirror and facing their own death?


Who by his lady's command, who by his own hand
Who will die under the orders of their partner, or who will take their own life?


Who in mortal chains, who in power
Who will die in slavery or captivity, who in the supremacy of power?


And who shall I say is calling?
Who is calling out to decide the fate of these beings?




Lyrics © BMG Rights Management
Written by: Leonard Cohen

Lyrics Licensed & Provided by LyricFind
To comment on or correct specific content, highlight it

Genre not found
Artist not found
Album not found
Song not found
Most interesting comment from YouTube:

@FromHeadToHeart7

@@A.staris Thank you. Yes, i am fully aware that this song was inspired by the ונתנה תוקף prayer/chant. I also grew up with this prayer/chant and know it very well. The fact that this song is a commentary on this chant (and the worldview behind this chant) is very obvious and clear. However, what is usually not noted by those who have emotionally invested their indentity in a humanity-dividing, sectarian belief systems (and take any possible opportunity to distinguish themselves from the rest of humanity by using such non-sensical nationalist oxymoroms like 'the god of israel' or 'jesus calls on you to repent and come back to the christian faith' or 'muhammed is god's messanger, so repent and come back to islam', or being proud that someone mentioned a chant from their sectarian tradition), what is failed to be noted by such sectarian religious-nationalists is that he was actually NOT agreeing with this abusive fear-driven theology of god (that is promoted in the ונתנה תוקף chant) as a judgemental punishing vengeful entity (which is the common view in all sectarian exoteric religions that created god in the image of their traumatised, fearful, violent, possesive, tribalistic and unconscious psyche), and he was NOT agreeing with this reliance on fear and terrorizing as a means to acheive compliance (as is practiced by all psychologically-undeveloped exoteric religions. For example, if you'll study christian evangelism, you'll know that this ונתנה תוקף chant is IDENTICAL to their beliefs and practice of terrorizing/scaring the followers into "repentance" and compliance. It is the exact same judgemental, punishing, vengeful uncompassionate sectarian theology and set of beliefs (which are the POLAR OPPOSITE of what God actually is... even though both of these zealous sectarian mind-invented unconscious ideologies - both christian and jewish evangelism - place themselves as the gatekeeprs to God, pretend to speak for God and to represent God's will..)

PS. In case you are not familiar with the distinction i made above between exoteric religions (which are the POLAR OPPOSITE of God, and that move humanity away from God and the wholistic qualities of God) and esoteric religions (which do see and understand the non-sectarian nature of God) then I'll just quickly explain that exoteric religions are highly divisive and sectarian (and place a huge amount of value on 'the uniquness of our group and "our god").

Exoteric religions contradict the wholistic universal non-sectarian REALITY of God/Consciousness/Being.

Exoteric religion distort/turn on their head the original teachings of the mystics who were the original spark of all religions (distort them from a wholistic-unifying esoteric seeing of the nature of reality/God, into a sectarian humanity-dividing US-versus-Them right-wing conservative abomination and distortion of the nature of God)

Exoteric religion stays on the superficial level of culturally-specific rituals and conditioning. Its ideals are completely ego-bound and mind-created, and it doesn't go beyond the level of conceptual thoughts and the emotions that such thoughts generate.

Exoteric religion is a reflection of the wounded and unconscious human psyche which seeks safety and solace through beliefs, and therefore is highly reliant on judgement, punishment and the use of fear, shame and guilt to achieve compliance.

Lastly, exoteric religions always dwell in the past (judgement/condemnation/shame/guilt) and future (hope/anxiety), and move their followers' attention away the eternal present moment (which is where God/reality actually is).

Esoteric religions are unifying, non-sectarian and recognize the universal qualities of God/Consciousness/Being (which is non-sectarian and non-judgemental and not punishing and not cruel and not vengeful, which is unconditionally loving and is inseparable from what we are).

Esoteric religions have also realized the reality beyond the concepts and images of the thinking brain and the emotional attachments of the frightened and safety-seeking ego.

Esoteric religions also recognize that the present moment is all there is, the time-less reality in which God looks through our eyes (and all other senses) and percives these words on a screen..

Almost any religion on the planet has an exoteric side (which is extremely popular and which is practiced by the vast majority of the culturally-indoctrinated population) and an original esoteric side (which is the original insight of an heretic mystic or mystics - possibly as a result of an NDE in their life - before it was turned into an organized and ritualised religion with a large following. An esoteric side which is usually of interest only for a small number of mystics and not of interest to the vast majority of the population, who seem to crave security, safety, comfort, certainty, community of similarly-believing people, and soothing solace-giving concepts, more than anything else, and therefore gravitate to the exoteric part of the religion).

For example, the esoteric side of exoteric christianity, islam, judaism, buddhism, hinduism is (respectively) Gnosis, Sufism, Kabbalah, Zen/Daoism, Advaita-Vedanta/Non-Duality, respectively..

And of course there are also many indigenous shamanic wholistic ways of living on the planet which are almost entirely esoteric in their un-mediated connection to (and embodying of) Spirit/Being/God/Consciousnes and its manifestation as everything that exists..



All comments from YouTube:

@Renaldo1269

We miss you Leonard, especially in these times of darkness

@thierryvanbiesen1025

C'est beau. Merci

@brahmani928

sure

@miguelaragones9649

@@brahmani928 00

@Benedict42

So say we all.

@bripan321

Yes we do.

36 More Replies...

@davidgreen8629

Sometimes it takes a lifetime to appreciate how brilliant Leonard was!

@misapachilala3702

Please don't say was

@phoenixblues111

Please don’t say

@winterfawn9762

Well, nice people.. he “ was “ “ is” “ and always will be “ a genius 🙏💕

More Comments

More Versions