Give It Back To The Indians
Mark Murphy Lyrics


Jump to: Overall Meaning ↴  Line by Line Meaning ↴

Old Peter Minuet had nothing to lose when he bought the isle of Manhattan
For twenty-six dollars and a bottle of booze and they threw in the Bronx and Staten
Pete thought that he had the best of the bargin but the poor red man just grinned,
And he grunted "ugh!" meaning okay in his jargon for he knew poor Pete was skinned.
We`ve tried to run the city....but the city ran away...
And now Peter Minuet
We can`t continue it...
Broadway`s turning into Coney,
Champagne Charlie`s drinking gin,
Old New York is new and phony
Give it back to the Indians!

Two cents more to smoke a Lucky,
Dodging buses keep you thin,
Now New York is simply ducky,
Give it back to the Indians!

Take all the reds, on the boxes made for soap
Whites on Fifth Avenue
Blues down in Wall Street losing hope..
Big bargain today...Chief take it away!

Come you busted city slickers,
Better take it on the chin
Father Nick has lost his knickers
Give it back to the Indians!

Take all the reds, on the boxes made for soap
Whites on Fifth Avenue
Blues down in Wall Street losing hope..
Big bargain today... Chief take it away!

Come you busted city slickers,
Better take it on the chin




Father Nick has lost his knickers
Give it back to the Indians!

Overall Meaning

The song "Give It Back To The Indians" speaks to the idea that the white settlers in America stole land from the indigenous people who originally inhabited it. The lyrics describe the ironic situation of Peter Minuet, who bought the island of Manhattan from the Lenape Indians for a mere 26 dollars and a bottle of liquor. The singer implies that the Native Americans knew they were getting the better end of the bargain, as they accepted the trade (and said "ugh!" to indicate their agreement), fully aware that Minuet was taking advantage of them. The chorus then adds a call to action, asserting that modern-day Americans should give back the land they stole and return it to its rightful owners.


In later verses, the song describes the ways in which New York City has lost its way, with Broadway becoming just another amusement park and the city losing its authentic character. The chorus repeats the refrain to reinforce the idea that the current state of the city is a result of its wrongful acquisition. The second half of the song introduces an interesting twist, with the singer targeting both wealthy whites on Wall Street and the Catholic Church. The lyrics suggest that even those who didn't directly participate in stealing Native American land are still benefiting from the unjust system that was put in place. The chorus concludes the song with a final plea to return what was taken and give it back to those who rightfully owned it.


Line by Line Meaning

Old Peter Minuet had nothing to lose when he bought the isle of Manhattan
Old Peter Minuet didn't have much to lose when he bought Manhattan


For twenty-six dollars and a bottle of booze and they threw in the Bronx and Staten
He got a pretty good deal, only paying twenty-six dollars and a bottle of booze, plus they threw in the Bronx and Staten


Pete thought that he had the best of the bargin but the poor red man just grinned,
Peter thought he had won in the deal, but the Native Americans knew he was actually the loser


And he grunted "ugh!" meaning okay in his jargon for he knew poor Pete was skinned.
The Native American simply grunted, which meant okay in his language, because he knew Peter had been taken advantage of.


We've tried to run the city....but the city ran away...
We've tried to control the city but it's proven to be too difficult.


And now Peter Minuet
And now, referring back to Peter Minuet and the previous lyrics.


We can't continue it...
We can't keep trying to control the city.


Broadway's turning into Coney,
Broadway is losing its glamour and turning into Coney, a place of lower class entertainment.


Champagne Charlie's drinking gin,
Even the higher class people have resorted to drinking cheaper alcohol, like gin.


Old New York is new and phony
The old New York that was once genuine is now fake and inauthentic.


Give it back to the Indians!
The solution to this problem is to give the land back to its original owners, the Native Americans.


Two cents more to smoke a Lucky,
Even the smallest things, like buying cigarettes, have gotten more expensive.


Dodging buses keep you thin,
Dodging buses while walking is necessary to stay in shape and avoid accidents.


Now New York is simply ducky,
Now New York is simply alright, nothing special anymore.


Take all the reds, on the boxes made for soap
Take all the Native Americans on soap packaging as a representation of how they have been trivialized and exploited.


Whites on Fifth Avenue
Meanwhile, white people continue to enjoy shopping on Fifth Avenue.


Blues down in Wall Street losing hope..
People of color in poorer areas like Wall Street have lost hope for improvement or success in their lives.


Big bargain today...Chief take it away!
This is a reference back to the original bargain that Peter Minuet made with the Native Americans, saying that now in the present day, the Native American Chief should take it away.


Come you busted city slickers,
A call out to the city-dwellers who have been unable to improve the city's situation.


Better take it on the chin
Better just accept the fact that the city is not going to get better, at least not without drastic changes.


Father Nick has lost his knickers
Even Church officials like Father Nick have lost their grip on the city and its situation.


Give it back to the Indians!
The solution remains to give the land back to the Native Americans as a way to right the wrongs of the past and move towards a better future.




Lyrics © Warner/Chappell Music, Inc., CONCORD MUSIC PUBLISHING LLC
Written by: LORENZ HART, RICHARD RODGERS

Lyrics Licensed & Provided by LyricFind
To comment on or correct specific content, highlight it

Genre not found
Artist not found
Album not found
Song not found

More Versions