The group's initial line-up came together in Toronto in 1977, when David Millar asked his fellow Ontario College of Art student Mark Gane to help him start a band. Millar recruited Martha Johnson to play keyboards; Johnson brought in a friend from high school, Carl Finkle, to play bass; and Gane's brother Tim Gane signed on as the drummer. With Millar and Mark Gane as guitarists, and Johnson as lead vocalist, this is the line up that debuted at an Ontario College of Art Hallowe'en party in October 1977.
They chose the name "Martha and the Muffins" to distance themselves from the aggressive names adopted by many punk bands of the era. According to Mark Gane: "We decided to use it as a temporary name until we could all agree on something better." The name ended up sticking for the next 7 years.
Saxophone player Andy Haas began performing with the band early 1978 (initially as a guest artist). Founding member Millar left the band shortly thereafter, preferring to work as the band's sound engineer for live shows. He was replaced by Martha Ladly, who had attended high school with the Ganes. She became the group's second keyboardist/vocalist named Martha, although Martha Johnson remained the group's primary lead singer.
In 1978, they released their first independent single, "Insect Love". This and a demo tape recorded in June 1978 quickly garnered them a recording deal with the DinDisc offshoot of Virgin Records.
In 1979, the band traveled to England to record their first Virgin album, Metro Music (1980).
This album gave Martha and the Muffins a major international hit single with "Echo Beach". Although the album didn't spawn any further hits, "Paint by Number Heart" did get some airplay on Canadian radio.
Later in 1980, the band released their second album, Trance and Dance, which was less successful and didn't give the band any hit singles. Also in 1980, Ladly left the band to pursue an art scholarship and would briefly join The Associates. Jean Wilson briefly replaced Ladly on tour in 1981, but never recorded with the group.
In 1981, bassist Finkle left the band, and was replaced by Jocelyne Lanois, the sister of then-unknown record producer Daniel Lanois. After Jocelyne introduced the band to her brother, they figured Daniel was an ideal candidate to produce their next LP. However, in order to utilize his services as a co-producer, Martha and the Muffins had to agree to Virgin Records' demand that if they were going to insist on working with an unknown producer, they would also have work with a lower album recording budget.
Martha and the Muffins' 1981 album This is the Ice Age, produced by Daniel Lanois and the band, was recorded in Toronto and Hamilton, Ontario. More experimental than previous efforts, it also gained significant Canadian radio airplay from the singles "Women Around the World at Work" (a #24 hit in Canada) and "Swimming". However, despite critical acclaim, the album didn't spin off any hit singles internationally, and Virgin dropped the band from their roster.
Following This Is the Ice Age, Haas and Tim Gane left the band. The band, now a quartet (Martha Johnson, Mark Gane, Jocelyne Lanois, and new drummer Nick Kent) signed to Canadian indie label Current Records, distributed by RCA.
1983's Danseparc was produced by Daniel Lanois, Gane and Johnson. Gane, eager to finally drop the name "Martha and the Muffins", proposed that the group be now called "M + M". In a compromise, both names were used for a time, and the Danseparc album cover had both "M + M" and "Martha and the Muffins" printed on it.
The album's title track was another top 40 single in Canada, and for the Danseparc tour, the group was augmented by auxiliary players including guitarist Michael Brook. However, at the end of the tour Gane and Johnson (now a couple) announced that while they wanted to continue as a recording act, they also wanted to branch out in new directions by using new collaborators. In essence, Gane and Johnson decided that "M + M" was now Martha + Mark, along with a bevy of studio musicians and hired sidemen.
Their duo's 1984 album Mystery Walk was again co-produced by Daniel Lanois with Gane and Johnson, and featured a a large sticker crediting the band as "M + M o/k/a (once known as) Martha and The Muffins". Guest players included drummer Yogi Horton, bassist Tinker Barfield, and the Brecker Brothers on horns.
Whatever their group name, the Mystery Walk album gave M + M/Martha and the Muffins their biggest hit in years with "Black Stations/White Stations", an anti-racist anthem whose first verse took radio stations to task for refusing to play a song about mixed-race romance, a story which Martha Johnson had heard related on the radio while driving in her car.
"Black Stations/White Stations" was a smash hit in Canada; in the United States it reached #2 on the dance music charts, but was ironically banned by many radio stations. "Cooling the Medium", the second single, was also a significant hit in Canada. In 1985 Johnson and Gane started work on their next album in Montreal, before heading to Bath, England to work with producer David Lord, resulting in the album The World is a Ball (1986). Although the lead single "Song in My Head" garnered them some airplay (and was another top 40 hit in Canada), the album sold poorly, and Gane and Johnson subsequently moved to England for a time.
Johnson and Gane took several years to record a follow-up to The World is a Ball. Recording started in Bath, where the couple had moved to in 1987, and continued in Toronto when they moved back to their home city in 1989.
In 1992, they contributed a cover of Joni Mitchell's "Shades of Scarlett Conquering" for the Mitchell tribute album Back to the Garden, and released the album Modern Lullaby. For this release, the duo revived the name "Martha and the Muffins", although the only other original Muffin to participate was Tim Gane (on "additional percussion"). The single "Rainbow Sign" was only a moderate hit, and Johnson and Gane essentially shut down the band and moved on to other projects for the next several years. Johnson and Gane's daughter Eve was also born in 1992.
In 1998, Johnson and Gane recorded a single new bonus track ("Resurrection") for the 1998 Martha and the Muffins compilation album Then Again: A Retrospective. The following year, another new Martha and the Muffins recording ("Do You Ever Wonder?") appeared on a various artists compilation called The World According to Popguru.
In May 1999, Martha and the Muffins performed a live version of "Echo Beach" on the show Open Mike with Mike Bullard. In addition to Mark Gane and Martha Johnson, the band included Jocelyne Lanois, and another Gane brother, Nick.
In 2003, the Johnson/Gane duo (augmented by session players) performed at the CFNY Reunion as Martha and the Muffins. Then in 2005, they performed a number of reunion shows in Toronto, including a double bill with the also-reunited Parachute Club on 14 May. A later concert that year also included Jocelyne Lanois on guitar. However, no other former Martha and the Muffins members participated in these 2005 'reunion' shows, which were the first full-length Martha and the Muffins concerts since 1987.
In press coverage of these shows, Johnson stated that the band may record new material, but nothing definitive has currently been planned. However, one of their later songs, "Paradise", became popularized when the Canadian TV show Paradise Falls used the song as their closing credits theme.
In 2008, Cherry Red Records UK released the 25th Anniversary Edition of the Muffins' 1983 album 'Danseparc (Every Day It's Tomorrow)'. The album was digitally remastered by Peter J. Moore (producer of the Cowboy Junkies' 'Trinity Sessions' album), and produced by Daniel Lanois (U2, Peter Gabriel).
In October 2008, the band released their first new studio album in 16 years. It's entitled 'Delicate' and is mixed by David Botrill (Tool, King Crimson, Peter Gabriel). It's the Muffins' first album since 1992's 'Mordern Lullaby'.
www.marthaandthemuffins.com
Indecisión
Martha and the Muffins Lyrics
Jump to: Overall Meaning ↴ Line by Line Meaning ↴
Though my problem's clear-cut
I find I have two faces
And my hand is in two places
I know I must make a decision
If only they'd invent human fission
A dual personality, my mind permits
My body is caught
By this freedom of thought
My brain is in confusion
'Cos I'm faced with all this choosin'
Here we go...
I wish that I could be decisive,
Then I'd understand where life is going, for me
REPEAT
The lyrics of Martha and the Muffins's song Indecision speak of the confusion and conflict that arises in the mind of an individual when faced with choices. The singer reflects on the fact that while their problem is clear-cut, they seem to have two faces and their hand is in two places. This illustrates the individual's split personality or indecisiveness, as they are torn between two choices. The singer wishes for "human fission," a concept that does not exist, to divide their body into two so that both parts of them can make their own choices.
The song goes on to describe the confusion that the singer is facing in their mind due to the different choices that they have to make. They are caught between the freedom of thought and the limitations of their physical body. They wish they could be more decisive, that they could understand where their life is going. The lyrics of Indecision offer a candid and vulnerable perspective on the struggle of making choices.
Overall, Martha and the Muffins's song Indecision is a poignant representation of the human condition. It highlights the difficulties of making choices and the internal conflicts that arise from having to choose between two things. The song offers a relatable perspective on indecision, and the lyrics are insightful and thoughtful.
Line by Line Meaning
My life is in a rut
I feel stuck or unfulfilled in the current state of my life.
Though my problem's clear-cut
Even though I know what my issue is, I still struggle to solve it.
I find I have two faces
I am conflicted and have different sides or personas depending on the situation.
And my hand is in two places
I am torn between two options or choices and cannot commit to one or the other.
I know I must make a decision
I am aware that I need to choose a path or direction for my life and take action.
If only they'd invent human fission
I wish it were possible to divide myself into two separate beings to better handle conflicting desires or responsibilities.
A dual personality, my mind permits
I have the capacity to think and feel in opposing ways or hold varying opinions.
I only have one body, it just can't do the splits
Though I may want to do or experience multiple things, I can only physically be in one place or do one thing at a time.
My body is caught
I am physically and emotionally trapped or stuck due to my indecision.
By this freedom of thought
While I value my ability to consider multiple options, it has left me feeling overwhelmed and unable to decide.
My brain is in confusion
I am mentally and emotionally disoriented due to the many choices and options before me.
'Cos I'm faced with all this choosin'
I am struggling to make decisions because of the abundance of options or lack of clarity on what path to take.
I wish that I could be decisive
I desire to be more confident in my choices and better able to make decisions.
Then I'd understand where life is going, for me
If I could be more decisive, I would trust in the direction I have chosen for my life.
Contributed by Nathaniel T. Suggest a correction in the comments below.
Conrad Poos
Wow, great audio and great song. And the legendary Tim Pope shot it. Love you Martha and Mark!
Steve Briggs
Beautiful set. Love this music. Thank you.
Graham Simons
Great band - great performance!
Craig McTaggart
Love Martha ,both of you brilliant women . Bring back so many brilliant memories x x
Jaime AIL
Love it and great sax playing
misterbruno
Great sound!
elduuude
Amazing.
Yuke Weiß
This song was all I listened to in 2015 when I was trying to decide my future direction. I was so indecisive.
Joachim Peiper
Great band really. Very talented.... Like the “Muffins and the Passions in Britain, such bands will never be formed any more...... Music today is going to pot...... New wave-Post Punk, one of the greatest music genres ever existed at the best of our lives
Bruno Pinkhof
Didn't know this song untill now, was a big fan of Echo Beach. From Belgium. We had a New Wave band in the eighties and named it Blanco Beach. We stopped and I restarted after many many years and my songs are on the radio in the Benelux now. I like this song,