I Should Care
Marty Paich Orchestra Lyrics

The song "I Should Care" by the Marty Paich Orchestra is a love song that reflects on moving on from a past love while admitting that the impact it had on the singer's life remains. The singer acknowledges that they should be upset about the fact that their love has ended, but they're not because they have come to terms with the reality of the situation. The lyrics imply that the singer has gained maturity from previous romantic experiences and that they have learned how to manage their emotions.

The song's opening lines "I know I should pity me, but I don't because, you see, I have loved and I have learned" suggest that the singer has accepted the past and suggests that the singer is not the victim of the situation. In the first verse, the singer admits that they should be upset about the end of their relationship, but the chorus counters this idea. The chorus reveals that the singer should care and that they do care in reality.

The second verse of the song reflects on the singer's ability to sleep well despite having a few dreams that disturb their peace. The verse speaks to the idea that the process of moving on is not necessarily a simple one. The dream represents the singer's sub-conscious reflecting on their past love while the counting of the sheep is their way of moving forward, which they do very well.

Overall, the song "I Should Care" is a reflective and melancholic romantic song that explores themes of love and loss. The singer is mature and self-aware, fully realizing that their past love will always be with them in some capacity. The song explores the idea of being able to move on while still holding on to the things that make someone human, such as the ability to feel.