What Does It Matter
Mary Black Lyrics


Jump to: Overall Meaning ↴  Line by Line Meaning ↴

What does it matter if the sun don't rise
It's midnight forever in my Jimmy's eyes
What should it matter if it comes on to spring
When I'm finding winter in everything

Lived in this cold wind city all of my life
Walking around still looks the same
Same people coming and going
It doesn't feel right - See it all now - From so far away

All of the wisdom that I held so high
Shining and useless as this April sky
The hedgerows are singing and it comes on spring
But I'm finding winter in everything

Lived in this cold wind city all of my life
Walking around still looks the same
Same people coming and going
It doesn't feel right - See it all now - From so far away

So what should it matter if the earth may slide
Sky break in pieces or the stars collide
The little of sense left in this world or ours
My Jimmy took with him in the wee small hours

Lived in this cold wind city all of my life
Walking around still looks the same
Same people coming and going
It doesn't feel right - See it all now - It's so far away





I'm finding winter in everything
I'm finding winter in everything

Overall Meaning

The song "What Does It Matter" by Mary Black presents a melancholic view of life, where the singer sees everything as bleak and hopeless. The lyrics suggest that the singer is deeply affected by personal loss and grief, symbolized by the absence of the sun and the onset of winter even in the midst of spring. The lines, "It's midnight forever in my Jimmy's eyes" and "My Jimmy took with him in the wee small hours" imply that the singer has lost someone dear, which has left a permanent mark on her world. The sense of loss is further underscored by the repetition of the line "I'm finding winter in everything", which suggests that the singer's sadness is all-encompassing and inescapable.


The lyrics also suggest a sense of alienation and disconnect from the world around her. The singer mentions living in the same place all her life, but feeling like an outsider, as though seeing everything from a distance. The repetition of the line "same people coming and going, it doesn't feel right" suggests a feeling of being stuck in a rut, where everything seems pointless and routine. The reference to the hedgerows singing and spring coming suggests the potential for renewal and rejuvenation, but the singer seems unable to access it, instead feeling trapped in her own sadness and despair.


Overall, "What Does It Matter" presents a poignant and melancholic view of life, where personal loss, grief, and a sense of detachment from the world combine to create a deep sense of sadness and despair.


Line by Line Meaning

What does it matter if the sun don't rise
The singer's world is so dark and desolate that it doesn't matter if the sun rises or not.


It's midnight forever in my Jimmy's eyes
The singer's loved one, Jimmy, is emotionally distant and cold, representing the darkness and despair that permeates their life.


What should it matter if it comes on to spring
Even the hopefulness of spring does not bring any joy or light to the singer's life.


When I'm finding winter in everything
The artist's life feels like a never-ending, bleak winter, even when others may see a glimmer of hope.


Lived in this cold wind city all of my life
The artist has spent their entire life in a place that feels cold and harsh, adding to the sense of despair.


Walking around still looks the same
Despite the passage of time, nothing seems to change in the singer's life or surroundings.


Same people coming and going
The people in the singer's life are transient and do not bring any lasting connection or joy.


It doesn't feel right - See it all now - From so far away
The artist has gained perspective and can now see how wrong everything feels in their life, even though they are physically close to it.


All of the wisdom that I held so high
The artist used to place great importance on wisdom, but it now seems useless in their bleak existence.


Shining and useless as this April sky
The artist compares the uselessness of their past admiration for wisdom to the deceptive brightness of the April sky.


The hedgerows are singing and it comes on spring
Nature is celebrating spring and new life, but the singer cannot find any joy or hope in it.


But I'm finding winter in everything
The artist's despair and sense of loss taint even the hopefulness of spring.


So what should it matter if the earth may slide
The singer has become so disassociated from the world that they cannot find any concern or fear in the possibility of natural disasters.


Sky break in pieces or the stars collide
Even cosmic events that would typically cause fear or wonder mean nothing to the singer anymore.


The little of sense left in this world or ours
The singer sees very little meaning or sense in the world around them.


My Jimmy took with him in the wee small hours
The artist's loved one, Jimmy, left in the midst of the night, taking any remaining sense of meaning or purpose with him.


I'm finding winter in everything
The refrain reinforces the artist's entrenched sense of despair and emotional coldness.




Lyrics © BMG Rights Management
Written by: DAVID GRAY

Lyrics Licensed & Provided by LyricFind
To comment on or correct specific content, highlight it

Genre not found
Artist not found
Album not found
Song not found

Maureen Smith


on Bruach na Carraige Baine

So beautiful!

More Versions