Tell Me Why
Mary J. Blige; Will Smith Lyrics


Jump to: Overall Meaning ↴  Line by Line Meaning ↴

[Mary J. Blige]
Whyyyyyy, whyyyyyy
Whyyyyyy, whyyyyyy

[Chorus:]
I really wish I could explain it baby
It's just the world is kinda crazy baby
Ain't no pretty way to paint it baby
Don't cry, dry your eyes

[Will Smith]
September 11th I woke up about 7 AM
West coast time, french toast and my turkey bacon
Takin' my time awakin, turnin' my TV on
To my surprise, saw what everybody in the world saw
Me and my children, images were chillin'
My son said - daddy were there people in that building?
A cold sweat, frozen with a lump in my chest
I heard his question, couldn't bring my lips to say yes to him
That night at my son's side, he cried
And prayed for the ones who died in the World Trade
His palms to God, seeds of qualms with God
He just, kept on pressin' me, wanna know why
Then one week later our bombs were dropped
We seein' them, on CNN, they just won't stop
The infrared, images of brutal attack
He said "Daddy now we killin' 'em back," right right

[Chorus]

[Chorus]

Souls are captured (souls are captured)
Dreams are stolen (dreams are stolen)
Hearts are broken (hearts are broken)
Evil plaguin' he rewardin'
Hate surrender (hate surrender)
Love exalted! (Love exalted!)
Hope elated! (hope elated!)
Negativity destroyed and..

[Will Smith]
Honest to God, why is the bomb always gettin' the last word
and why, did her uncles have to molest her
and why, did all them cops have to be shootin' to kill?
And why, did all them priests have to act so ill?
Tell me why did James Byrd Jr. have to be touched?
Tell my why did Malcolm and Martin depart from us
Tell me why did the sniper make that little boy shoot
And why, is human life always denied for loot?
Tell me WHY did MANDELA have to live in a cage
Why did my brother Sterling have to die at that age
Tell me why did Reginald Denny deserve his fate
And why the fuck can't love, seem to defeat hate?
Tell me why is it so hard for all the children to eat?
Why did 'Pac and Biggie Smalls have to fall in the street?
Tell me why did Jam Master Jay have to go that way?
Please, what am I supposed to say my kids when they say

[Chorus]

[Chorus]

[Will Smith]
Can't explain it baby life is just really crazy
I mean if it's world wars or the life of a little baby
We got more stores than they got rice under buddha lazy
You live four scores and still it be drivin' you crazy
But for me I try to see the button side
Sometimes it be like the goodness be tryin' to hide




or tryin' to flee, but it can't, it's deep inside
Sweetie you be the light for others, make 'em believe in God

Overall Meaning

The song "Tell Me Why" by Will Smith featuring Mary J. Blige is a deeply reflective piece on the tragedies of life and the volatile state of the world. The song opens with Mary J. Blige singing "why" in a pained and questioning tone, setting the somber mood for the rest of the track. Will Smith then recounts his experience of waking up to the news of the 9/11 attacks, the fear and confusion that followed, and the difficulty of explaining the situation to his children. The song delves into other heart-wrenching topics such as child abuse, police brutality, racial violence, and hunger.


Smith wonders out loud about the injustices of the world, why human life is often denied for mere material gain, why hope seems so hard to find, and why love can't seem to overcome hatred. He expresses his despair and frustration with the state of things but also tries to offer a glimmer of hope through his music. Smith encourages people to keep faith and to maintain a positive outlook despite the adversity life throws at them. The song ends on a message of resilience and strength, urging listeners to be a light for others and to always believe in God.


Line by Line Meaning

Whyyyyyy, whyyyyyy
Expressing confusion and lamentation about the state of the world


I really wish I could explain it baby
Desiring to provide an answer to the confusion


It's just the world is kinda crazy baby
The state of the world is chaotic and unpredictable


Ain't no pretty way to paint it baby
There are no easy or attractive solutions to the world's problems


Don't cry, dry your eyes
Encouraging the listener to be strong in the face of adversity


September 11th I woke up about 7 AM
The song's narrator recalls the morning of September 11th


West coast time, french toast and my turkey bacon
Describing a typical morning routine


Takin' my time awakin, turnin' my TV on
Slowly starting the day and turning on the TV


To my surprise, saw what everybody in the world saw
Witnessing the news of the 9/11 attacks for the first time


Me and my children, images were chillin'
Watching the coverage of the attacks with his children


My son said - daddy were there people in that building?
A child's innocent question in the face of the horror


That night at my son's side, he cried
The artist remembers comforting his child in the aftermath of 9/11


And prayed for the ones who died in the World Trade
The family offers prayers for those who lost their lives


His palms to God, seeds of qualms with God
The son expresses doubts and confusion about God's role in the tragedy


Then one week later our bombs were dropped
Describing the start of the US response to the attacks


We seein' them, on CNN, they just won't stop
Continued news coverage of the military action


The infrared, images of brutal attack
Graphic footage of the bombing campaign


He said 'Daddy now we killin' 'em back'
The son expresses a simplified understanding of the US military response


Souls are captured (souls are captured)
Evil is taking over humanity


Dreams are stolen (dreams are stolen)
People are losing hope for a better future


Hearts are broken (hearts are broken)
People are traumatized by tragedy and suffering


Evil plaguin' he rewardin'
Injustice is being rewarded while good deeds go unpunished


Hate surrender (hate surrender)
Encouraging people to give up hate and anger


Love exalted! (Love exalted!)
Celebrating the power of love to overcome evil


Hope elated! (hope elated!)
Uplifting people through hope and optimism


Negativity destroyed and..
Dispelling negativity and despair


Honest to God, why is the bomb always gettin' the last word
Questioning why violence and destruction seem to win out in the world


and why, did her uncles have to molest her
Expressing outrage and questioning why innocent people suffer


and why, did all them cops have to be shootin' to kill?
Questioning police brutality and unnecessary use of force


And why, did all them priests have to act so ill?
Questioning the hypocrisy of religious leaders who commit crimes


Tell me why did James Byrd Jr. have to be touched?
Questioning why people are targeted for hate crimes based on their race


Tell me why did Malcolm and Martin depart from us
Questioning why inspirational leaders like Malcolm X and Martin Luther King Jr. were assassinated


Tell me why did the sniper make that little boy shoot
Questioning the motive behind senseless acts of violence


And why, is human life always denied for loot?
Questioning why people are willing to harm others for financial gain


Tell me WHY did MANDELA have to live in a cage
Referring to Nelson Mandela's imprisonment and questioning systemic inequality and injustice


Why did my brother Sterling have to die at that age
Referring to the killing of Alton Sterling and questioning why innocent people are targeted by the police


Tell me why did Reginald Denny deserve his fate
Referring to the beating of Reginald Denny during the 1992 LA riots and questioning the randomness of violence


And why the fuck can't love, seem to defeat hate?
Questioning why love and compassion can't prevail over hatred and prejudice


Tell me why is it so hard for all the children to eat?
Referring to the issue of child hunger and questioning why basic needs can't be met for everyone


Why did 'Pac and Biggie Smalls have to fall in the street?
Referring to the killings of Tupac Shakur and The Notorious B.I.G. and questioning why talented artists are taken so soon


Tell me why did Jam Master Jay have to go that way?
Referring to the killing of Jam Master Jay and questioning why violence affects even those who seem untouchable


Please, what am I supposed to say my kids when they say
Asking for guidance on how to respond to children's difficult questions


Can't explain it baby life is just really crazy
Acknowledging that the world is full of chaos and unpredictability


I mean if it's world wars or the life of a little baby
The tragedy of war and suffering affects everyone, from global conflicts to individual experiences


We got more stores than they got rice under buddha lazy
Commenting on the excess and materialism of Western society


You live four scores and still it be drivin' you crazy
Even with a long life, people are still affected by the world's problems


But for me I try to see the button side
The singer tries to find the good in the world


Sometimes it be like the goodness be tryin' to hide
Goodness and kindness can seem rare and hard to find


or tryin' to flee, but it can't, it's deep inside
Goodness is a fundamental part of humanity that can't be destroyed or suppressed


Sweetie you be the light for others, make 'em believe in God
Encouraging the listener to be a source of positivity and faith for others




Lyrics © Peermusic Publishing
Written by: ROBERT JOHNSON, PETER KNIGHT

Lyrics Licensed & Provided by LyricFind
To comment on or correct specific content, highlight it

Genre not found
Artist not found
Album not found
Song not found
Most interesting comment from YouTube:

@renerodasnospes7178

I really wish I could explain it baby (why),
It's just the world is kinda crazy baby (why),
Ain't no pretty way to paint it baby (why),
Don't cry, dry your eyes
September 11th, I woke up about 7am, west coast time, French toast and my
Turkey bacon, taking my time, awakin', turning my TV on
To my surprise, saw what everybody in the world saw
Me & my children, images were chillin'
My son said, "Daddy were there people in that building?"
A cold sweat, frozen with a lump in my chest
I heard his question, couldn't bring my lips to say "Yes" to him
That night at my son's side, he cried & prayed
For the one's who died in the World Trade
His palms to God, seeds and qualms with God
He just kept on pressin' me, wanna know why
Then one week later our bombs were dropped
We seein' them on CNN, they just won't stop
The infrared images of brutal attack
He said, "Daddy now we killin' em back"; (right, right)

[CHORUS - (2x)]

[BRIDGE - Mary J. Blige:]
Mmmmm, souls are captured
Dreams are stolen, hearts are broken
Evil blatantly rewarded
Hate surrenders, Love exalted
Hope elated, negativity is shorted
Why is the bomb always getting the last word
& why did her uncle have to molest her
& why did all them cops have to be shootin' to kill
& why did all them priests have to act so ill
Tell me why did James Byrd Jr. have to be touched
Tell me why did Malcolm & Martin depart from us
Tell me why did that sniper make the little boy shoot
& why does human life always denied for loot
Tell me why did Mandela have to live in a cage
Why did my brother Sterling have to die at that age
Tell me why did Reginald Denny deserve his fate
& why the f*@k can't love seem to defeat hate
Tell me why is it so hard for all the children to eat
Why did Pac & Biggie Smalls have to fall in the street
Tell me why did Jam Master Jay have to go that way
Please what am I supposed to say to my kids when they say 'Why?'

[CHORUS - (2x)]

[VERSE 3]
Can't explain it baby, life is just really crazy
I mean if it's world wars or the life of a little baby
We got more stores than they got rice under Buddha lazy
You live four scores & still it be driving you crazy
But for me I try to see the bright side
Sometimes it'd be like the goodness be tryin' to hide
Then try to flee, but it can't it's deep inside
Sweetie, you be the light for the others, make 'em believe in God



All comments from YouTube:

@Sakuraqueen

This song always brings me to tears! They both sing with so much passion!!

@chrispleasantable

Anne Etuk My brother plays this song every year on September 11

@KZBluCaesar3

I’m here right now listening; remembering when I first had this cd and heard this track. I was balling then and I’m still crying now hearing it again!!! They slept on this man for 30 years!!!

@suicidesquad5938

Mary killed this song 2019

@REALandRAWW

Mary fucking SANG her ass off! Full vibrato. Love her!

@BronchoKyle

Christ that 2nd verse. Even more relevant today.

@riccardo9383

This is what's missing from today's songs. Sincere and genuine concerns of society and a decent character of the singer, instead of meaningless, cheap "songs". If any singer would sing this or other songs with similar value my respect for him/her would significantly increase.

@aaronjoce702

I most definitely agree with you and you can tell by the way he delivers this song that he has genuinity about issues in the world. However, if someone else were to do a meaningful song like this I feel that they have to be genuine about it and not just do it for sales and ratings

@icynishia1723

True

@atolmasoff

People are listening to the wrong Hip-hop. Hands down, the most I've ever cried, thought, got upset, you name it came from good Hip-hop. Can't even begin to describe the things that flew through my mind the first time listening to some people like Immoral Technique... Good hip hop will take you to some incredible places and some very dark if you can find some artists you can really relate with or even let them take you three.

More Comments

More Versions