Latte Cat Even if it's theater, if he's too young he's technically too young, but I don't know the age of Dr. Scott. Plus in the movie, things tend to look better when they are more realistic.

@Mira_Dunia

7y↑1

Latte Cat It might depend on the audience member. To me it does. It might be easier to disguise a younger person as an older person onstage though.

4 More Replies...

@zs5946

6y↑12

This is the best version of this song I ever heard!

@aliisantetik880

8y↑32

I Love This Version More Then The One From The Movie

@Mira_Dunia

7y↑6

Aliisan Tetik I liked Columbia's solo and Janet's emotion at the end in the movie. This version has Meatloaf as Dr. Scott, but I also likes hearing him sing all of Eddie's note in the movie.

@JavertRA

7y↑2

Erin F Agreed, she sounds much better in the film. I thought she sounded like Louise Belcher from Bob's Burgers here!

@WoodsToLiveBy

2y↑2

All the singers, and most of the arrangements, are much stronger in the Roxy Cast than in the film. (Of course, some of the singers are the same ;) but even they give it something extra here. )

@mattd1142

2y↑2

Eddie singing about Eddie

@porpison

11y↑7

Best version of this song!

@thedogemaster5548

5y↑4

They should have added the VROOM VROOM bit in the movie. Its my favourite thing in this song

@desdar100

11y↑16

Meatloaf is the best Dr.Scott\Eddie.

@noahcaldwell3881

7y↑4

VROOM VROOM

@maddiemorris9719

6y↑1

wow just wow

@dancingcheeseproductions4127

10y↑25

I like this version, but, in my opinion, the movie one is better.

@PetProjects2011

9y↑16

Wikia Frog I like the way Little Nell (Columbia) sang her verse in the movie better than the performer in this version. In the movie, Nell sang as though she was crying (what with being sad over Eddie's death), while here, the singer sounds more like she's just pouting like a child.

@ciscokid3430

5y↑3

I like the movie version better too ngl.

@FLonYT326

Cuz of Eddsworld

@Joke300017

12y↑1

love it

@kutzbill

9y↑1

Did Jim Steinman play piano for some of the shows? It seems like I heard Meat got him a job because they were trying to put something together, (Bat out of Hell) back them. I might be mistaken. Some of you Rocky know it alls set me straight won't you. Loved playing Eddie .... my god! 34 years ago! Fuck, I got old!

@barnacleguy

11y↑12

Jonathan Adams, Dr Scott in the movie version, had nowhere near the vocal skills as Meatloaf

@vic9839

7y↑9

Goddamn it, Columbia sucks in this version. She's not even trying.

@MatisFerhati88

sounded suspicious to the mexican 1976 version

@davidscott1348

6y↑5

I do like this version but the movie version of this is better

@emhalz

David Scott try to listen to the one of 2015

@barnacleguy

11y↑8

Absolutely. Movie version of this song sucked compared to this one. This Dr Scott had some great pipes.

@ClovisPictures

8y↑7

They hold vocals to long.

@lindseypacios6295

7y↑2

The Matrix Bunnies
It's different from the movie

@ClovisPictures

7y↑1

I know.

@MrFloyd-jf6fh

7y↑3

Well, in reality you could say the movie cuts them off too quickly.

@lukebradford

4y↑2

I have to be honest, I'm not a big fan of this version. I'm so used to Dr Scott having a German accent... The soundtrack album's version is my favourite. Meatloaf sings the note in that, I believe, as well as Hot Patootie.

More Comments

just now