Why
Melanie C Lyrics


Jump to: Overall Meaning ↴  Line by Line Meaning ↴

Why does the rain fall from the sky?
How can a sugar pill take this pain away?
I should have known that you would break my heart
You've ended something that didn't have a chance to start

Put out the stars
Rub out the sky
Look to the future
Wipe the teardrop from my eye
Shut off the sun
Put out the light
Want you to tell me how you're gonna make it right

Why am I crying over you?
Why?
'Cause there*s nothing else that I can do
Why do I always look a fool?
Why?

Wish I'd read the signs and left you well alone
God, I want to call you but I can't pick up the phone

Put out the stars
Rub out the sky
Look to the future
Wipe the teardrop from my eye
Shut out the sun
Bring on the night
Want you to show me how you're gonna make it right

Why am I cryin' over you?
Why?
'Cause there's nothing else that I can do
Why do I always look a fool?
Why?
Why am I crying over you?
(Tell me why. Why does the rain fall from the sky?)
Why?
'Cause there's nothing else that I can do
(Why do the tears fall from my eyes?)
Why do I always look a fool?
(Why does the rain fall from the sky?)
Why?




(Oh tell me why)
(Tell me why)

Overall Meaning

The lyrics of Melanie C's song "Why" tell the story of a heartbreak and the lingering pain and confusion that comes with it. The song starts with a series of questions that the singer asks herself, wondering why things turned out the way they did. She questions the very nature of things, such as why rain falls from the sky and how a simple sugar pill can take away physical pain. As she starts to reflect on her own situation, she realizes that she should have seen the signs that her heart was about to be broken. Despite this, she still finds herself crying and wishing things had turned out differently.


In the chorus, Melanie C expresses her frustration with the situation and her own helplessness. She wonders why she always ends up feeling like a fool in matters of the heart, and why she can't seem to move on. The second verse sees her admitting that she wishes she had seen the signs earlier and stayed away from the person who caused her so much pain. She wants to reach out and call them, but can't bring herself to do it.


Line by Line Meaning

Why does the rain fall from the sky?
Why did something as inexplicable as love come into my life only to bring me sadness and misery?


How can a sugar pill take this pain away?
How can something so trivial and insignificant as a sugar pill cure the deep emotional pain that you caused me?


I should have known that you would break my heart
Looking back, I realize that I was naive to think that you were capable of loving me in the way that I needed, and that you were always going to hurt me.


You've ended something that didn't have a chance to start
You put an end to our relationship before it even had a chance to flourish or grow into something beautiful.


Put out the stars
I want to erase every memory of you and the times we spent together; I want to wipe the slate clean and pretend that we never happened.


Rub out the sky
I want to forget the happy times we shared and the love we once had, and replace it with a blank and empty sky.


Look to the future
In order to move on from this heartbreak, I need to focus on the future and what it holds for me, rather than dwelling on the past.


Wipe the teardrop from my eye
I need to dry my tears and face this pain head on, rather than letting it consume me.


Shut off the sun
I want to shut myself off from the world and wallow in my own sorrow, with no hope or light to guide me out of this darkness.


Put out the light
I want to extinguish any remaining feelings of hope or love that I have for you, in order to move on and find happiness without you.


Want you to tell me how you're gonna make it right
I want you to take responsibility for the pain you caused me and make amends, in order to help me find closure and move on from this heartbreak.


Why am I crying over you?
Why do my feelings for you run so deep, even though you hurt me and we can never be together?


Why?
What could I have done differently to prevent this heartbreak, and why did it have to happen to me?


'Cause there*s nothing else that I can do
There seems to be no way out of this heartbreak and pain, and I feel helpless and lost without you.


Why do I always look a fool?
Why do I keep coming back to you and falling for your lies, even though I know you will only hurt me in the end?


Wish I'd read the signs and left you well alone
Looking back, I wish I had seen the warning signs and avoided this heartbreak by leaving you before it was too late.


God, I want to call you but I can't pick up the phone
Even though I long to hear your voice and talk to you again, I know that it will only lead to more pain and sadness, and so I must resist the urge to call you.


Bring on the night
I am ready to face the darkness and emptiness of my life without you, and move on to a brighter and better future.


Want you to show me how you're gonna make it right
I need closure and answers from you in order to move on from this heartbreak and find peace within myself.


(Tell me why. Why does the rain fall from the sky?)
I am struggling to understand why love had to bring me so much sadness and pain, and why I am left feeling empty and lost without you.


(Why do the tears fall from my eyes?)
I am unable to control my emotions and tears, even though I know that crying will not bring you back or heal my broken heart.


(Oh tell me why)
I am desperate for answers and understanding regarding the pain and heartbreak that you caused me.


(Tell me why)
I need to understand why I fell so deeply in love with you, even though you were never capable of reciprocating those feelings.




Lyrics © BMG Rights Management, Universal Music Publishing Group, Peermusic Publishing
Written by: MELANIE CHISHOLM, MARIUS DE VRIES, STEVE SIDELNYK

Lyrics Licensed & Provided by LyricFind
To comment on or correct specific content, highlight it

Genre not found
Artist not found
Album not found
Song not found

More Versions