Too Good To Be True
Michael Peterson Lyrics


Jump to: Overall Meaning ↴  Line by Line Meaning ↴

(Michael Peterson/Gene Pistilli)

You were all she ever wanted, that was once upon a time
She was all you ever needed, that's what makes it such a crime
How you took her heart for granted, how you threw her love away
Now you still don't understand it, if you did, you'd never say

It was too good to be true
What did you expect a girl as good as her to do?
What do you think would make that woman go find somebody new?
She's not too good to be true
She's just too good to be true to you

Just because she never said so, doesn't mean she didn't see
Every time you stole an apple off somebody else's tree
Late last night that lipstick letter she left on the bedroom door
Said "You don't get it, and you ain't gonna get it anymore!"

It was too good to be true
What did you expect a girl as good as her to do?
What do you think would make that woman go find somebody new?
She's not too good to be true
She's just too good to be true to you

It was too good to be true
What did you expect a girl as good as her to do?
What do you think would make that woman go find somebody new?
She's not too good to be true
She's just too good to be true to you

Here we go!
It was too good to be true
What did you expect a girl as good as her to do?
What do you think would make that woman go find somebody new?
She's not too good to be true
She's just too good to be true to you
Oh just too good to be true to you





(c) 1997 Warner-Tamerlane Publishing Corp. BMI/High-Falutin Music
ASCAP

Overall Meaning

In Michael Peterson’s song “Too Good to Be True,” the lyrics revolve around a failed relationship where the partner in question took the other’s love for granted. The song starts off by stating that the woman was all the partner ever needed, but he still threw her love away, leading to the downfall of their relationship. As the song progresses, the singer explains how the partner did not comprehend the magnitude of his mistakes and how this made their partner look for love elsewhere. The partner’s failure to appreciate their love results in the realization that the woman was “just too good to be true to you” and that the relationship was always doomed from the start.


Peterson’s interpretation of how a failed relationship is a result of taking love for granted is relatable to many people. The lyrics are driven by a somber melody, that when coupled with Peterson’s voice, conveys the message beautifully. The song includes two verses with different messages, but they both convey the same underlying meaning. The absence of a chorus in the song increases the emphasis on the significance of Peterson's emotive voice and the melody to convey the song's message. Overall, Peterson’s song “Too Good to Be True” is a beautifully written piece that emphasizes the importance of appreciating love and the subsequent consequences that arise from not doing so.


Line by Line Meaning

You were all she ever wanted, that was once upon a time
At some point in the past, you were the sole desire of the woman you lost.


She was all you ever needed, that's what makes it such a crime
By losing her, you deprived yourself of the most fundamental need you had.


How you took her heart for granted, how you threw her love away
You failed to acknowledge or appreciate her love, and acted in a way that caused her to leave you.


Now you still don't understand it, if you did, you'd never say
You remain oblivious to the cause of her departure, such that if you knew it, you wouldn't admit it.


It was too good to be true
She was too perfect for your relationship to last.


What did you expect a girl as good as her to do?
How could you anticipate that she would put up with your behavior?


What do you think would make that woman go find somebody new?
What could possibly make you think that she would remain with you?


She's not too good to be true
She is indeed everything you knew her to be.


She's just too good to be true to you
She is too magnificent of a person to waste her love on you.


Just because she never said so, doesn't mean she didn't see
Even if she never explicitly mentioned it, she was aware of every single transgression on your part.


Every time you stole an apple off somebody else's tree
Each time you were disloyal either emotionally or physically.


Late last night that lipstick letter she left on the bedroom door
Last night, she parted ways with you by leaving a lipstick note on the door of the bedroom.


Said "You don't get it, and you ain't gonna get it anymore!"
The note essentially conveyed that you were never going to comprehend the enormity of your actions and the effect they had on her.


Here we go!
A phrase used in excitement or anticipation of a forthcoming event.




Lyrics © Sony/ATV Music Publishing LLC, Warner Chappell Music, Inc.
Written by: PETERSON, PISTILLI

Lyrics Licensed & Provided by LyricFind
To comment on or correct specific content, highlight it

Genre not found
Artist not found
Album not found
Song not found

More Versions