Happy Hearts
Okkervil River Lyrics


Jump to: Overall Meaning ↴  Line by Line Meaning ↴

Why must happy hearts break so hard, leave you curled up in the back seat of a car, staring up at the windshield? When will broken hearts learn how to heal? This boy I knew was five years older than me. His daddy'd left him when he was three. After we went walking by a stream, he held me down and made me feel as bad as he. Why must happy hearts break so hard, leave you standing in the darkness of the barn, staring at those rusty wheels? When will broken hearts learn how to heal? And everybody's searching for a place to put their love. See the people on the street? They go home and what do you think they dream of? Unconditional love. Why did you leave me? Mother, why do you sleep with him? He says he's smothering, then he comes back again, in our house for the weekend. Why must people's breaking hearts pretend? Why must happy hearts break so hard, leave you staring in the mirror at a bar? Leave you talking to yourself, because you can't talk to anybody




Overall Meaning

The lyrics of Okkervil River's song Happy Hearts reflect on the theme of heartbreak and the struggle to find healing after going through it. The song questions why happy hearts break so hard and leave the individual curled up or standing in the darkness, staring at something as simple as a windshield or rusty wheels. The singer in the song asks when broken hearts will learn how to heal, as they seem to constantly cling onto the pain of heartbreak.


The second verse of the song tells the story of a boy who was five years older than the singer and whose father left him at a young age. After they took a walk by a stream, he held her down and made her feel as bad as he did. This verse questions why people who have had such traumatic experiences, like abandonment and abuse in this case, continue to perpetuate the pain onto others. The lines "Why did you leave me? Mother, why do you sleep with him? He says he's smothering, then he comes back again, in our house for the weekend" further depict the struggles of those whose hearts have been broken.


The song concludes by questioning why broken hearts must pretend and why they can't talk to anybody. These lines depict the social stigma of talking about heartbreak and the feeling of being alone in the struggle to heal from it.


Overall, the lyrics of the song Happy Hearts by Okkervil River are insightful, thought-provoking and empathetic towards those who have gone through heartbreak. The song doesn't offer solutions to healing but rather offers a space to express and understand these emotions.


Line by Line Meaning

Why must happy hearts break so hard, leave you curled up in the back seat of a car, staring up at the windshield?
Why do hearts that were once happy have to shatter so painfully that they leave you huddled in the rear of a vehicle, gazing up through the windshield?


When will broken hearts learn how to heal?
When will hearts that have been broken discover how to mend themselves?


This boy I knew was five years older than me. His daddy'd left him when he was three. After we went walking by a stream, he held me down and made me feel as bad as he.
I knew this guy who was five years my senior, and his father had abandoned him when he was three. When we strolled by a creek, he restrained me and made me feel just as terrible as he did.


Why must happy hearts break so hard, leave you standing in the darkness of the barn, staring at those rusty wheels? When will broken hearts learn how to heal?
Why do happy hearts have to shatter so completely that they leave you standing in the barn, peering at the corroded wheels? When will shattered hearts figure out how to recover?


And everybody's searching for a place to put their love. See the people on the street? They go home and what do you think they dream of? Unconditional love.
Everyone is looking for somewhere to direct their love. Do you see the people walking down the street? When they get home, what do you believe they envision? Unconditional love.


Why did you leave me? Mother, why do you sleep with him? He says he's smothering, then he comes back again, in our house for the weekend.
Why did you abandon me? Mother, why do you sleep with him? He claims he's suffocating, yet he returns again, to our household, for the weekend.


Why must people's breaking hearts pretend?
Why do people with broken hearts have to feign happiness?


Why must happy hearts break so hard, leave you staring in the mirror at a bar? Leave you talking to yourself, because you can't talk to anybody
Why do happy hearts have to shatter so profoundly that they leave you gazing into the mirror at a pub? Why do they make you utter your thoughts aloud since you're unable to converse with anyone?




Lyrics © O/B/O APRA/AMCOS

Lyrics Licensed & Provided by LyricFind
To comment on or correct specific content, highlight it

Genre not found
Artist not found
Album not found
Song not found

More Versions