What You Are
Patty Griffin Lyrics


Jump to: Overall Meaning ↴  Line by Line Meaning ↴

All the ladies, on the lake they start to dance
Its been a long time, don't you wish you had the chance
What do you wish you were?
Do you wish you were the silence on the moon?
Nobody knows but maybe you will be soon

I used to think the sidewalk was the way
Always waiting for my lucky day
Over and over every patch of gray
One day inside me I was lucky anyway

What do you wish you were?
Do you wish you were the light of every star?
Nobody knows but, maybe that's just what you are

All night count all the singing stars
Alright is where you want to know you are
What do you wish you were?
Do you wish you were the light of every star?
Nobody knows but maybe that's just what you are




Nobody knows but maybe that's just what you are
Nobody knows but maybe that's just what you are

Overall Meaning

In Patty Griffin's song What You Are, she begins by painting a picture of a group of ladies dancing by the lake. She then asks a question to her listeners, "what do you wish you were?". She poses the idea of wishing to be nothing more than the silence on the moon, something that's unattainable but still worth contemplation. She suggests that maybe someday you'll become the impossible thing you wish to be, just as the ladies on the lake may have once wished they could dance but now have the chance to do so. Suddenly, the lyrics switch from talking to the audience to talking about herself. Patty confesses that she used to believe that the only way to success was by following the straight and narrow path - or the sidewalk in her case. But, through her realization of the fact that anyone can indeed find success, she's had a stroke of luck herself.


The chorus repeats the same question about wishing to be something, with the addition of a new idea: the "light of every star". She notes that nobody knows the answer to that question yet, except for the possibility of the person themselves. Patty ends the song on a similarly bittersweet note, questioning who and what you are, and suggesting that maybe it doesn't matter who you are, who you wish to be, or what you'll become, just that you may already be that impossible thing you once wished for.


Line by Line Meaning

All the ladies, on the lake they start to dance
Women on the lakeside begin to dance


Its been a long time, don't you wish you had the chance
Do you wish you had a chance after all these years?


What do you wish you were?
What are your desires?


Do you wish you were the silence on the moon?
Do you ever wish to be the quietness of the moon?


Nobody knows but maybe you will be soon
No one knows except for the possibility that you can be


I used to think the sidewalk was the way
I once believed that the street was the path


Always waiting for my lucky day
Always anticipating my good luck


Over and over every patch of gray
Repeatedly dealing with negativity


One day inside me I was lucky anyway
Even without good luck, I found contentment within myself


All night count all the singing stars
All night long, look up and count the stars in harmony


Alright is where you want to know you are
The aim is to know where you stand and be alright with it


Do you wish you were the light of every star?
Do you ever wish to be the shining light of every star?


Nobody knows but, maybe that's just what you are
Perhaps that's precisely what you are, but nobody knows


Nobody knows but maybe that's just what you are
Maybe that's exactly what you are, but no one knows


Nobody knows but maybe that's just what you are
Possibly that is what you are, but nobody knows




Lyrics © Universal Music Publishing Group, Sony/ATV Music Publishing LLC
Written by: PATRICIA J. GRIFFIN, CRAIG ROSS

Lyrics Licensed & Provided by LyricFind
To comment on or correct specific content, highlight it

Genre not found
Artist not found
Album not found
Song not found

More Versions