That Old Feeling
Pete Jolly Lyrics

In "That Old Feeling," Pete Jolly encapsulates the intoxicating experience of falling in love, using vivid imagery to convey the overwhelming emotions that often accompany romantic attraction. The opening lines introduce the listener to a powerful moment where the singer locks eyes with someone special. This connection ignites a sense of enchantment, symbolized by the "old devil moon" that the subject seems to possess. It signifies not just beauty but also the mysterious and sometimes mischievous nature of love, as it can both captivate and consume one’s thoughts. The moon, often a symbol of romance, takes on a somewhat sinister quality here, suggesting that love can also lead to vulnerability.

As the song progresses, the singer describes the dynamic nature of their relationship, emphasizing the heat and intensity of their attraction. The phrase "too hot to handle" implies that the passion between them is so intense it’s almost overwhelming, echoing themes of desire and urgency. Meanwhile, Jolly contrasts the brilliance of the stars with the subject’s sparkling persona, underscoring their unique allure. The expression "razzle-dazzle" suggests that this connection brings a sense of excitement and vitality, making it clear that the emotions stirred up in this romance are more mesmerizing than anything else in the universe. This highlights not only the singer's infatuation but also the almost magical quality that love can embody.

The metaphor of a "magic carpet ride" introduces a sense of boundless joy and escapism that accompanies love. As the singer expresses feelings of euphoria—flying high and feeling butterflies—these images evoke a childlike sense of wonder and innocence. The emotional rollercoaster is palpable; the desire to cry, croon, or laugh like a "loon" illustrates the complexity of feelings evoked by love. Each reaction signifies a release of pure emotion, revealing how deeply affected the singer is by the connection. This element of joy also hints at the dichotomy of love's power to elevate while also rendering one vulnerable to deeper emotional expressions.

In the final stanza, the narrative takes a turn, revealing a more profound struggle with the emotions tied to love. The insistence that just as one feels free, the “old devil moon” resurfaces suggests that romantic feelings are often inescapable. The singer is caught in a paradox where the very emotion that brings joy can also create a sense of entrapment or blindness—a love that blinds them with its intensity. This reflects the often-overwhelming nature of love, where one can feel liberated yet captive simultaneously, underscoring the complexities inherent in romantic relationships. Through these lines, Jolly paints a comprehensive picture of love as an irresistible force that can evoke joy, anxiety, and an overwhelming sense of being both uplifted and ensnared.