Edith
Rachael Yamagata Lyrics


Jump to: Overall Meaning ↴  Line by Line Meaning ↴

Oh Edith
You'll never know how much I wanted you
It was not appropriate...

Oh Edith
I loved you like a movie star
Driving in your car
Counting the waves with the top down

Oh Edith
I loved you like a waterfall
But you don't know this
I never told you...

No...no...no...no...no...no...

And I think of you
Whenever street lamps die
And I think of you
No matter hot I try
You doubted my tears
Haunted me for years

Don't you know... know...don't you know
Don't you know you murder me

Oh Edith
Do you ever think of me
When you're waking from a dream
Or walking down an alley way

I wanted to send you some rain for your birthday
But it wasn't up to me
Oh that's how it had to be
Not up to me

Oh Edith
You murder me
You murder me

And I miss you...




I miss you...
Miss you...

Overall Meaning

The song "Edith" by Rachael Yamagata is a heart-wrenching ballad about unrequited love. The song tells the story of the singer's love and admiration for a woman named Edith, who never knew how she truly felt. The opening lines of the song, "Oh Edith, you'll never know how much I wanted you, it was not appropriate" sets the tone for the rest of the song, suggesting that there was some kind of barrier or obstacle that prevented the singer from expressing her feelings for Edith. The song goes on to describe the singer's intense love for Edith, comparing her to a movie star and a waterfall. However, despite her deep feelings, the singer never had the courage to tell Edith how she felt.


The chorus of the song is particularly poignant, with the singer lamenting how much Edith's rejection has affected her: "And I think of you whenever street lamps die, and I think of you no matter how I try, you doubted my tears, haunted me for years." The repetition of "no matter how I try" suggests that the singer has struggled to move on from her unrequited love, and that Edith's rejection has left a lasting impact.


In the second verse, the singer reveals that she wanted to send Edith some rain for her birthday, but it wasn't up to her - "Oh, that's how it had to be, not up to me." This line suggests that there may have been external factors that prevented the singer from pursuing a relationship with Edith, whether it was societal norms or something else.


Overall, "Edith" is a deeply emotional and moving song that captures the pain and longing of unrequited love.


Line by Line Meaning

Oh Edith
Addressing someone who will likely never know how much they were wanted


You'll never know how much I wanted you
The person was not appropriate to pursue a relationship with


I loved you like a movie star
Expressing the intensity of love felt


Driving in your car
A specific memory associated with the person


Counting the waves with the top down
A vivid detail of a specific moment shared


I loved you like a waterfall
Another comparison to express the intensity of love felt


But you don't know this
The love was not reciprocated or vocalized


I never told you...
Reiterating that the feelings were never shared


No...no...no...no...no...no...
A repetition of the fact that the love was unrequited


And I think of you
Signifying that the person still holds significance in the artist's life


Whenever street lamps die
A specific trigger or memory associated with the person


No matter hot I try
Implying that the artist has tried to move on but cannot


You doubted my tears
The relationship or experience with the person was emotionally tumultuous


Haunted me for years
The impact of the experience has lasted a long time


Don't you know... know...don't you know
Expressing frustration with the fact that the other person may not understand or know the singer's feelings


Don't you know you murder me
The intense emotions surrounding the unresolved relationship are causing pain


Do you ever think of me
Wondering if the other person still thinks about the artist


When you're waking from a dream
Another specific moment where the other person may come to mind


Or walking down an alley way
Implying that the other person is still a presence in the singer's daily life


I wanted to send you some rain for your birthday
A specific gesture of love or care for the other person


But it wasn't up to me
Acknowledging that the artist has no control over the other person's life


Oh that's how it had to be
Accepting the reality of the situation


You murder me
Repeating the previous sentiment of the other person causing pain


And I miss you...
Expressing sadness and longing for the other person


I miss you...
Repeating the previous sentiment for emphasis


Miss you...
Finalizing the emotional impact of the experience




Contributed by Christian W. Suggest a correction in the comments below.
To comment on or correct specific content, highlight it

Genre not found
Artist not found
Album not found
Song not found