How Could I Ever Know
Secret Garden Lyrics


Jump to: Overall Meaning ↴  Line by Line Meaning ↴

How could I know I would have to leave you?
How could I know I would hurt you so?
You were the one I was born to love
Oh, how could I ever know?
How could I ever know?

How can I say to go on without me?
How, when I know you still need me so?
How can I say not to dream about me?
How could I ever know?
How could I ever know?

Forgive me, can you forgive me?
And hold me in your heart
And find some new way to love me
Now that we're apart?

How could I know I would never hold you?
Never again in this world
But oh, sure as you breathe I am there inside you
How could I ever know?
How could I ever know?

How can I hope to go on without you?
How can I know where you'd have me go?
How can I bear not to dream about you?
Oh, how can I let you go?
How could I ever know?

All I need is there in the garden
All I would ask is care for the child of our love
Come, go with me, safe I will keep you
Where you would lead me, there I would
There I would, there we would, there we will go

Oh! How could I know?
Tell me how could I know?
Never to know you would ever leave me
How could we ever know?




How could we know?
How could I ever know?

Overall Meaning

The lyrics of Secret Garden's "How Could I Ever Know" narrate the struggles of a woman who had to leave her loved one, not knowing the consequences that it entails. She expresses her emotional torment at the pain she caused her beloved and how she never intended to harm him in any way. She then asks for forgiveness from her partner and pleads for him to find a new way to love her now that they are apart. The phrase "How could I ever know?" is repeated throughout the song, depicting the singer's lament at the choices she made and the unknown future that awaits her.


The song's lyrics bring forth an array of themes, including love, separation, regret, and the uncertainty of the future. The phrase "How could I ever know?" acts as a rhetorical question and emphasizes the emotional turmoil that the singer is undergoing. The song's melody is a blend of classical and modern instrumentals, consisting of an orchestra and Celtic-style pipes, which set a poignant and dreamlike ambiance that complements the lyrics' theme.


Line by Line Meaning

How could I know I would have to leave you?
I had no way of predicting that circumstances would force me to separate from you.


How could I know I would hurt you so?
I never imagined that my actions or decisions would cause you pain.


You were the one I was born to love
From birth, I was destined to love you and only you.


Oh, how could I ever know?
I could never have possibly known or even imagined what would happen.


How can I say to go on without me?
It's impossible for me to ask you to continue living your life without me.


How, when I know you still need me so?
I understand that you still rely on me for support and comfort.


How can I say not to dream about me?
I don't want to deny you the comfort of dreaming about me, despite our separation.


Forgive me, can you forgive me?
I hope you can find it in your heart to forgive me for any pain or hurt I've caused you.


And hold me in your heart
I want to remain in your thoughts and heart, even if we can't be physically close.


And find some new way to love me
Perhaps we can find a new way to love each other, despite our current situation.


Now that we're apart?
Now that we're separated, we need to find a way to move on while still cherishing our love for each other.


How could I know I would never hold you?
I never could have guessed that I would never be able to physically hold or touch you again.


Never again in this world
Our separation is permanent and irreversible in this lifetime.


But oh, sure as you breathe I am there inside you
Even though we're apart, my memory and love will always be present inside you.


How can I hope to go on without you?
It feels impossible to continue living my life without you by my side.


How can I know where you'd have me go?
Without you, I don't know which direction to take in my life.


How can I bear not to dream about you?
I can't bear the thought of not being able to dream about you, despite our separation.


Oh, how can I let you go?
I'm struggling to come to terms with the fact that we must let each other go.


All I need is there in the garden
Everything I need in life can be found within the beauty and simplicity of the natural world.


All I would ask is care for the child of our love
All I ask is that you continue to care for and cherish the love we created together.


Come, go with me, safe I will keep you
Let's embark on a journey together, where I promise to keep you safe and protected.


Where you would lead me, there I would
I am willing to follow you anywhere you lead me, no matter what the future holds.


There I would, there we would, there we will go
Together, we will go wherever life takes us, and we will always have each other's backs.


Oh! How could I know?
Once again, I'm struck by how unpredictable and unforeseeable life can be.


Tell me how could I know?
I long for someone to explain to me how things ended up the way they have.


Never to know you would ever leave me
I never could have imagined that you would be taken from me.


How could we ever know?
Together, we could never have predicted or foreseen what would ultimately happen to us.


How could I ever know?
Overall, I'm left questioning how I could have ever possibly known or predicted the twists and turns of life.




Contributed by Grayson R. Suggest a correction in the comments below.
To comment on or correct specific content, highlight it

Genre not found
Artist not found
Album not found
Song not found
Most interesting comments from YouTube:

Nevaeh Horst-Wade

LILY:
How could I know I would have to leave you
How could I know I would hurt you so?
You were the one I was born to love!
Oh, how could I ever know?
How could I ever know?

How can I say to go on without me?
How, when I know you still need me so?
How can I say not to dream about me?
How could I ever know?
How could I ever know?

Forgive me.
Can you forgive me
And hold me in your heart,
And find some new way to love me
Now that we're apart?
How could I know I would never hold you?
Never again in this world, but oh,
Sure as you breathe, I am there inside you,
How could I ever know?
How could I ever know?

ARCHIBALD:
How can I hope to go on without you?
How can I know where you'd have me go?
How can I bear not to dream about you?
Oh, how can I let you go?

LILY:
How could I ever know?

ARCHIBALD:
All I need...

LILY:
Is there in the garden!

ARCHIBALD:
All I would ask...

LILY:
Is care for the child of our love!
Come, go with me, safe I will keep you.

ARCHIBALD:
Where you would lead me, 
There I would,

LILY:
There I would, there we would,

ARCHIBALD and LILY:
There we will go.
Oh! How could I know?
Tell me how could I know?
Never to know you would ever leave me!
How could we know?

LILY:
How could I ever know



Danielle Ott

How could I know I would have to leave you?
How could I know I would hurt you so?
You were the one I was born to love
Oh, how could I ever know?
How could I ever know?

How can I say to go on without me?
How, when I know you still need me so?
How can I say not to dream about me?
How could I ever know?
How could I ever know?

Forgive me, can you forgive me?
And hold me in your heart
And find some new way to love me
Now that we're apart?

How could I know I would never hold you?
Never again in this world
But oh, sure as you breathe I am there inside you
How could I ever know?
How could I ever know?



xxmilktaexx

LILY:
How could I know I would have to leave you
How could I know I would hurt you so?
You were the one I was born to love!
Oh, how could I ever know?
How could I ever know?

How can I say to go on without me?
How, when I know you still need me so?
How can I say not to dream about me?
How could I ever know?
How could I ever know?

Forgive me.
Can you forgive me
And hold me in your heart,
And find some new way to love me
Now that we're apart?
How could I know I would never hold you?
Never again in this world, but oh,
Sure as you breathe, I am there inside you,
How could I ever know?
How could I ever know?

ARCHIBALD:
How can I hope to go on without you?
How can I know where you'd have me go?
How can I bear not to dream about you?
Oh, how can I let you go?

LILY:
How could I ever know?

ARCHIBALD:
All I need...

LILY:
Is there in the garden!

ARCHIBALD:
All I would ask...

LILY:
Is care for the child of our love!
Come, go with me, safe I will keep you.

ARCHIBALD:
Where you would lead me,
There I would,

LILY:
There I would, there we would,

ARCHIBALD and LILY:
There we will go.
Oh! How could I know?
Tell me how could I know?
Never to know you would ever leave me!
How could we know?

LILY:
How could I ever know?



All comments from YouTube:

deartotheheart

One of the most touching and heart breaking Broadway songs I have ever heard, how very sweet and melancholy. Ah I just can't help tearing up

Sugar Shark

Im here cause I’m singing it in voice lessions

Dave Ross

Though I agree in much theory, CHESS would like a word with you :-)

S B

I tear up every time I hear this song

BabserellaWT

26 years later and this musical is STILL making me bawl my eyes out. Oh, gosh.

Abigail Absity

I cried so much to this. If there was a song to play to my beloved if I died before him, this would be it. So much emotion!

BabserellaWT

*my eyes

E B

I wish the cast albums gave even an inkling of the experience of what this music is like live. Just... a whole show's worth of shivers. Breathtaking.

Purplefire0796

Eden Bachelder there is one but it is very bad quality

sunshi

I saw this musical being performed by highschool excellently. And I can tell you that, at 3:11, makes everyone cry. As they were dancing, they couldn’t touch or old each other, but at this moment, he was able to feel her one more time, and they embraced before her final goodbye. Such an amazing song.

More Comments

More Versions