If I Stay
Shane Mack Lyrics


Jump to: Overall Meaning ↴  Line by Line Meaning ↴

Here I am in you bed again
Hanging on by a thread again
Saying thing I regret again
Things that shouldn't be said again
Going over the past and then
I'll have one my glass and then
Won't be long till I'm asking again
Baby can I come back again?
Can I come back again?

And I keep believing
That I am leaving you
And you know I can't even recall
Did we really ever love each other at all?
And I am going
But I am knowing
That I got to have one more day
'Cause it hurts if I stay
But it's worse if I stay away
I don't want to stay away

So here I am at you floor again
Standing at your door again
I made you feel like a whore again
It's gonna be a sad morning then
I tell you good bye and then
I'll watch you cry again
Until I drive by again
I say baby can we try again?
Maybe we try again
Just try again

I keep believing
That I am leaving, yeah
You know I can't even recall
If we really ever loved each other at all
And I am going
But I am knowing
That I got to have one more day
'Cause it hurts if I stay
But it's worse if I stay away

We're holding on until the good is all gone
Yeah you know that it's not all right
But it is not all wrong
I never meant to stay so long
I do never seem to say so long
Yeah, so long

And I keep believing
That I am leaving, yeah
You know I can't even recall
If we really ever loved each other at all
And I am going
But I am knowing
That I got to have one more day
'Cause it hurts if I stay




But it's worse if I stay away
I don't want to stay away

Overall Meaning

The song "If I Stay" by Shane Mack is about a relationship that is struggling to stay together. The lyrics suggest that the couple keeps going back and forth between breaking up and trying to make it work again. The singer is filled with regret for things he has said and done but also can't resist the pull of his partner. He acknowledges that it hurts to stay but it's worse to stay away.


The verses describe the cycle of the relationship with the singer returning to his partner's bed and trying to make things right again. He seems to be aware of the pattern but can't help himself from repeating it. The chorus explains his inner conflict about leaving for good. He wants to believe that he is ready to move on but he can't shake the feeling that he needs one more day with his partner. He realizes that the situation is painful but it's even more painful to be apart.


Overall, the song portrays a complex emotional struggle in a failing relationship. The singer is torn between his desire to leave and his need to stay, and he recognizes that the outcome is uncertain. The lyrics are emotionally raw and honest, conveying the internal turmoil that comes with ending a relationship.


Line by Line Meaning

Here I am in you bed again
I'm back in your bed again, unable to resist the temptation to see you and be near you.


Hanging on by a thread again
I'm barely hanging on, struggling to resist the urge to stay with you.


Saying thing I regret again
I keep saying things that I know I shouldn't say and will regret later.


Things that shouldn't be said again
I keep saying things that I know are hurtful and unnecessary.


Going over the past and then
I keep going over past memories in my mind, trying to make sense of our relationship.


I'll have one my glass and then
I'll pour myself a drink to help me cope with the emotions I'm feeling.


Won't be long till I'm asking again
It won't be long before I'm asking to come back to you again.


Baby can I come back again?
I want to come back to you again, even though I know I shouldn't.


And I keep believing
I continue to believe that leaving you is the best thing for both of us.


That I am leaving you
I am trying to leave you, but it's harder than I thought it would be.


And you know I can't even recall
I can't even remember if we truly loved each other in the first place.


Did we really ever love each other at all?
I'm not sure if our relationship was built on real love or just convenience and familiarity.


And I am going
I'm trying to leave you, but part of me doesn't want to go.


But I am knowing
But I know deep down that I need to move on.


That I got to have one more day
I need one more day with you, even if it means delaying the inevitable.


'Cause it hurts if I stay
Staying with you hurts because I know it's not good for either of us in the long run.


But it's worse if I stay away
But the pain of staying away from you is even worse than the pain of staying with you for now.


I don't want to stay away
I don't want to be away from you, even though I know it's for the best.


So here I am at you floor again
I'm back at your front door again, unsure if I should go in or not.


Standing at your door again
I'm standing at your door, filled with uncertainty about what to do next.


I made you feel like a whore again
I said or did something to make you feel used or disrespected again.


It's gonna be a sad morning then
I know that if I stay, we will both wake up feeling sad and regretful tomorrow morning.


I tell you good bye and then
I say goodbye to you, even though I don't want to leave.


I'll watch you cry again
I know that leaving you will make you cry, and that makes it even harder for me to leave.


Until I drive by again
I know that I'll be back to see you again, even if it's just driving by your house.


I say baby can we try again?
I want to give our relationship another chance, even though I know it might not work out.


Maybe we try again
Maybe we can try to make our relationship work, even though we've struggled in the past.


We're holding on until the good is all gone
We're clinging to our relationship even though the good parts of it are fading away.


Yeah you know that it's not all right
We both know that our relationship isn't healthy or sustainable in its current state.


But it is not all wrong
But our relationship isn't completely wrong, either - there are still good aspects to it.


I never meant to stay so long
I didn't intend to stay with you for as long as I have, but it's hard to let go.


I do never seem to say so long
I have a hard time saying goodbye to you, even though I know it's necessary.


Yeah, so long
Goodbye.




Contributed by Tyler T. Suggest a correction in the comments below.
To comment on or correct specific content, highlight it

Genre not found
Artist not found
Album not found
Song not found
Comments from YouTube:

@aphiwemagaya3279

He's so underrated, I love him

@farrinlavar

Shane was the main reason I bought the soundtrack. I check iTunes almost monthly to see if he will have an album on there.

@PEWPlays

Shane Mack! dbest! after watching SHELTER a Million times!

@FlackBenjamin

this is really beautiful.. listening while missing my love..

@violinmusicfan

his voice is so unique and interesting!

@Adamliaoyuxiang

His voice is so attractive!

@wonderjodig

very good great have to tell everyone i knew you would do it Lakrick listen to the other all the time good job

@cedriclaurent9

"Quizás mis manos hablaron demasiado. Quizás tus versos hablaron demasiado poco. Tus labios y tu nombre podrían ser los de cualquiera, y sin embargo eres tú. Eres tú, y no has hablado todavía, pero me has huido con la precisión del silencio, para jugar al dolor y a no saber dónde apareciste, dónde dijiste esperarme la última vez, para dejarme colgado de esta costumbre sin duda lo suficientemente absurda como para escribir sobre ella..."

@brito482

He's handsome!!

@Artsloverinlr

Very good song. This guy has a terrific voice. he really makes you "feel" every word. I am going to get as much of his music as I can from Itunes.

More Comments