Small Black started with a name and worked backwards: a housemate of singer/multi-instrumentalist Josh Kolenik came up with the moniker on a cold Portland, Oregon night. The name stuck when he returned to Long Island, New York and began collaborating with Ryan Heyner, an area musician and former member of the hardcore band Silent Majority who shared friends with Kolenik. The pair holed up in the attic of the beach house and surfboard shop Kolenik's uncle owned to record songs with vintage keyboards and samplers, spending late 2008 and early 2009 recording as Uncle Matt made surfboards underneath them.
Though Kolenik had played in several bands before Small Black, the mix of shoegaze and synth pop he and Heyner hit upon felt special, and the group's lineup was complete once bassist/guitarist Juan Pieczanski and Jeff Curtin from Kolenik's previous band, Slowlands, joined to bolster production and fill out their live act. Small Black released their self-titled five-song EP on their own CassClub label in October 2009, and released the U.K. single "Despicable Dogs" as well as a video for that song featuring Uncle Matt soon after. Following their performances at that year’s CMJ Music Marathon, Small Black signed to Jagjaguwar Records, which reissued the band’s debut EP with two bonus tracks in 2010. That year, they also released a split single with the like-minded Washed Out, with whom they also toured. New Chain, the band's first full-length, boasted a slightly more polished sound that reflected their consistent touring as well as their interest in hip-hop and arrived in October 2010. In late 2011, the band offered the Moon Killer mixtape as a free download from their website. The collection of new material was built on samples ranging from Pere Ubu to Nicki Minaj and featured multiple drop-ins from Das Racist MC Heems as well as remixes from Star Slinger and Phonetag.
After spending much of 2012 on the road, Small Black returned with May 2013's Limits of Desire, a more sophisticated-sounding set influenced by Talk Talk and the Blue Nile. They covered the latter band's classic "Downtown Lights" on the following year's Real People EP, which had a more dancefloor-oriented style and featured vocals from Frankie Rose. Small Black's passion for sophisti-pop grew on October 2015's Best Blues. Recorded by the band in their Brooklyn home studio and mixed by Nicholas Vernhes at the Rare Book Room Studio, the album included contributions from trumpeter Darby Cicci of the Antlers and vocalist Kaede Ford. Soon after Best Blues' release, Kolenik's Uncle Matt passed away, and the memory of him inspired many of the songs on Small Black's fourth album. Arriving on 100% Electronica in April 2021, the reflective Cheap Dreams found the band returning from their hiatus with an extra dose of goth to their synth pop reveries. In 2023, Small Black looked back with a pair of archival releases. They commemorated the tenth anniversary of Limits of Desire with a deluxe edition of the album, and also issued a deluxe version of their debut EP that included previously unreleased songs from their early beach house sessions.
Biography by Heather Phares for ALLMUSIC
Cheap Dreams
Small Black Lyrics
Jump to: Overall Meaning ↴ Line by Line Meaning ↴
that I can't afford
never felt the pain
but I knew the cost
well the futures here
and the futures gone
yeah you won the race
yeah, pride's a sin
never gave it up
cause it always was
my favorite one
Yeah I borrowed time
and you did too
but I'm not gonna change
my life for you
Keep all your
cheap dreams
Keep all your
cheap dreams
clways split the rent
but we came up short
month to month
until we were bored
Econoline through the void
I wasn't quite there
just fast asleep
in the space between
context & reality
yeah I never said that I was brave
there's just more shit that
I can take
Keep all your
cheap dreams
Keep all your
cheap dreams
Keep all your
cheap dreams
Keep all your
cheap dreams
In “Cheap Dreams,” Small Black dives into the complexities of personal struggle, self-identity, and the burden of expectations. The opening lines, “I was waging war / that I can't afford,” indicate a battle that the singer is fighting, one that demands more from them than they can give. This internal conflict seems to revolve around deeper issues of self-worth and the consequences of choices that are burdensome yet necessary. The line, “never felt the pain / but I knew the cost,” suggests a level of detachment from the potential fallout of this struggle—it's almost as if the singer knows what they should feel but remains numb to the emotional weight of their decisions.
The exploration of solitude is also pronounced in the second stanza: “the future's here / and the future's gone / yeah you won the race / to be alone.” Here, Small Black emphasizes the fleeting nature of opportunities and relationships, hinting at a sense of competition or inevitable isolation. The phrase “you won the race to be alone” might imply that in striving for their individual goals or dreams, the people in the singer's life have inadvertently chosen isolation over companionship. This could reflect a broader societal theme where personal ambition leads to neglecting connections with others, resulting in a haunting sense of loneliness despite one's achievements.
In the lines “pride's a sin / never gave it up / cause it always was / my favorite one,” the singer grapples with pride's dual nature. While pride can be construed as a negative trait, here it’s presented with affection as a "favorite," indicating that it serves as a form of self-preservation. This pride may give the singer a sense of agency, even if it manifests as denial or resistance to change. The subsequent assertion, “I borrowed time / and you did too / but I'm not gonna change / my life for you,” reiterates a commitment to oneself, suggesting that despite shared struggles, the singer is not willing to compromise their sense of self or path for another person. The insistence on keeping “cheap dreams” serves as a critique of superficial aspirations, perhaps indicating that such dreams lack depth or genuine fulfillment.
Lastly, the closing verses evoke imagery of stagnation and numbness: “Econoline through the void / I wasn't quite there / just fast asleep / in the space between / context & reality.” This phrase captures a moment of disconnection, with “Econoline” likely referencing a journey or an incessant movement without a clear destination, indicating a struggle to grasp their reality fully. The metaphor of being “fast asleep” implies a failure to engage with life fully, lingering in a liminal space where clarity and purpose are elusive. The repetition of “cheap dreams” throughout the song encapsulates a critical stance on chasing insubstantial goals, emphasizing the importance of authenticity over shallow desires. Overall, Small Black’s “Cheap Dreams” weaves a rich tapestry of introspection, exposing the difficulties of navigating self-identity amid a backdrop of societal expectations and personal dreams.
Line by Line Meaning
I was waging war
I was fighting battles in my life
that I can't afford
that I cannot sustain or manage financially or emotionally
never felt the pain
I was unaware of the suffering involved
but I knew the cost
but I understood the consequences and sacrifices required
well the futures here
the moment of opportunity has arrived
and the futures gone
but it is fleeting and will soon disappear
yeah you won the race
you achieved what you set out to accomplish
to be alone
but your victory has left you isolated
yeah, pride's a sin
having too much pride is morally wrong
never gave it up
I held onto it fiercely
cause it always was
because it has always been
my favorite one
something I cherished more than anything else
Yeah I borrowed time
I took chances with my future
and you did too
and you also took risks similarly
but I'm not gonna change
however, I refuse to alter
my life for you
my lifestyle or choices for your sake
Keep all your
I want you to hold on to
cheap dreams
unrealistic or superficial aspirations
clways split the rent
we always shared the financial responsibilities
but we came up short
but we consistently fell short of what we needed
month to month
from one month to the next
until we were bored
leading to a sense of monotony and dissatisfaction
Econoline through the void
traveling aimlessly, as if in a timeless space
I wasn't quite there
I felt detached or absent from reality
just fast asleep
simply dreaming or oblivious
in the space between
in the intervals that separate
context & reality
the differences between situational understanding and truth
yeah I never said that I was brave
I never claimed to be courageous
there's just more shit that
it's just that there are more struggles that
I can take
I can endure and handle
Keep all your
I urge you to retain
cheap dreams
those shallow ambitions
Keep all your
I insist that you keep
cheap dreams
those unworthy aspirations
Lyrics © O/B/O APRA AMCOS
Written by: JEFFREY CURTIN, JOSHUA KOLENIK, JUAN PIECZANSKI, RYAN HEYNER
Lyrics Licensed & Provided by LyricFind