Why There's a Tear in My Eye
The Carter Family Lyrics


Jump to: Overall Meaning ↴  Line by Line Meaning ↴

I once loved a beautiful maiden
As fair as the blue skies above
And each night as we wondered together
The moon seemed to smile on our love
We vowed to be true to each other
And nothing could cause us to part
But we never once dreamed that the future
Held only a broken heart
Then there came the night when we parted
We quarrelled as all sweethearts do
And I learned what it was to be jealous
When she told me our love was untrue
She told me she had always been faithful
She swore that her love could not die
And then when I did not believe her
She kissed me and told me goodbye

Oh-de lay-ee oh, de lay-ee yo-de lay-ee

I found I had falsely accused her
And went back to make her my bride
And there in the door stood her mother
She told me my sweetheart had died
I went in and knelt down beside her
And there in the hush of that room
I prayed that my maker would take me
And send my soul down to it's doom
So now I have told you the reason
There's always a tear in my eye
For long weary years I've repented
But I'm longing to lay down and die
And I wonder if I'll be forgiven
When I face the master someday
And I wonder if I'll see my sweetheart
On that beautiful shore far away





Oh-de lay-ee oh, de lay-ee yo-de lay-ee

Overall Meaning

The lyrics of The Carter Family's song "Why There's a Tear in My Eye" tell a heart-wrenching story of lost love, betrayal, and regret. The song opens with the singer reminiscing about a past love, describing her as a beautiful maiden as fair as the blue skies. They shared blissful moments together, symbolized by the moon smiling upon their love. They made vows to be true to each other, believing that nothing could tear them apart. However, their relationship takes a tragic turn when they have a heated argument and she confesses that their love was never true. The singer's jealousy compels him to doubt her, leading her to kiss him goodbye and end their relationship.


The song takes a devastating twist when the singer realizes his mistake. He resolves to make amends and marry his sweetheart but is confronted by her mother at the door, who delivers the heartbreaking news that she has passed away. Overwhelmed with grief, he kneels beside her lifeless body and prays for his own damnation, haunted by years of repentance. The song ends with the singer contemplating forgiveness from a higher power and the possibility of reuniting with his beloved on a beautiful shore in the afterlife.


Overall, "Why There's a Tear in My Eye" explores themes of love, betrayal, remorse, and the consequences of one's actions. It reflects on the fragility and impermanence of human relationships and the deep emotional pain caused by lost love and regret.


Line by Line Meaning

I once loved a beautiful maiden
There was a time when I deeply loved a woman who was exceptionally beautiful


As fair as the blue skies above
She was as lovely as the clear, endless skies


And each night as we wondered together
Every evening, we would wander hand in hand


The moon seemed to smile on our love
The moon's glow seemed to bless our affection


We vowed to be true to each other
We made a solemn promise to remain faithful forever


And nothing could cause us to part
No circumstance could ever tear us apart


But we never once dreamed that the future
However, we never anticipated that in time


Held only a broken heart
Our love would only result in a shattered, pained heart


Then there came the night when we parted
One fateful night, we separated


We quarrelled as all sweethearts do
Like all lovers, we engaged in a heated argument


And I learned what it was to be jealous
In that moment, I experienced the feeling of jealousy


When she told me our love was untrue
She confessed that our love was in fact untrue


She told me she had always been faithful
She insisted that she had remained loyal throughout


She swore that her love could not die
She passionately vowed that her love for me would never fade


And then when I did not believe her
Yet, when I doubted her words


She kissed me and told me goodbye
She kissed me with finality and bid me farewell


I found I had falsely accused her
It became clear to me that I had wrongly blamed her


And went back to make her my bride
Filled with regret, I returned to reclaim her as my wife


And there in the door stood her mother
However, at the doorway, her mother stood


She told me my sweetheart had died
Devastatingly, she informed me that my beloved had passed away


I went in and knelt down beside her
In sorrow, I entered the room and knelt beside her lifeless form


And there in the hush of that room
In the solemn silence of that space


I prayed that my maker would take me
I fervently prayed for my creator to remove me from this world


And send my soul down to its doom
To condemn my soul to eternal damnation


So now I have told you the reason
Thus, I have revealed the cause


There's always a tear in my eye
Why there is an ever-present teardrop in my eye


For long weary years I've repented
Throughout many exhausting years, I have deeply regretted my actions


But I'm longing to lay down and die
However, I yearn to surrender myself and embrace death


And I wonder if I'll be forgiven
I ponder whether I will receive forgiveness


When I face the master someday
Upon confronting the divine master at a later time


And I wonder if I'll see my sweetheart
Additionally, I am filled with curiosity whether I will reunite with my beloved


On that beautiful shore far away
Upon reaching that distant, magnificent shoreline




Lyrics © O/B/O APRA AMCOS

Lyrics Licensed & Provided by LyricFind
To comment on or correct specific content, highlight it

Genre not found
Artist not found
Album not found
Song not found
Comments from YouTube:

Colin Bolton

I have the Bear Family box set, and I agree with you with this lovely track, could listen to this trio all day long,

jackuppercut

This song is a true reflection on our sad and beautiful world. Wonderful.

Dannys998877

@georgejonesfan93 Thanks very much for posting this nice audio clip. As for the confusion about the pictures....the picture posted at 1:07 - 1:17 is the Jimmie Rodgers who was an RCA Victor country star of the 1930's who is singing here. The different picture at 1:17 - 1:26 is the pop/folk/rock star of the 1950's and 60's, who also went by the name "Jimmie Rodgers." Both were very popular in their times,and they now have separate Wikipedia entries.

georgejonesfan93

@Dannys998877 Well thank you for pointing that out, I need to make a new video and I will, when I made this, my grandmother & I weren't sure on who was who because in her words "It was too long ago for me to remember" haha! I'm just glad you enjoyed it :)

David Christian

Just to get matters good and confused, there was a third Jimmie Rodgers. A Chicago based blues guitarist who played with, among others, Muddy Waters.

georgejonesfan93

Well I researched pictures of Jimmie on many different sites and that's what I got but I believe it's him because if you look @ 1:38 he looks the same in 1:18 lol

Dannys998877

@rxxreeves There have been two popular recording stars named "Jimmie Rodgers." One was the country singer ("The Singing Brakeman") who recorded for Victor in the 1930's, and the other was a pop/folk/rock artist who recorded for various labels in the 1950's and 60's. The younger looking one that you are asking about (the wrong one for this video) is the pop star.

Krodgers1031

Please take down the photo on this video.it’s not the right Jimmie Rodgers. I’m his daughter. This Jimmie died in 1933. Not the same. Both extremely talented. Just please research before you post.

rxxreeves

Great posting but isn't the video a little confused? Surely the gentleman who appears at 1:18-1:27 and 2:45-2:55 is the wrong Jimme Rodgers?

Scott Lee

The picture at 1:38 is not the great Blue Yodeler. That is a picture of the other Jimmie Rodgers no one gives a damn about.

More Comments

More Versions