Why Baby Why
The Cats Lyrics


Jump to: Overall Meaning ↴  Line by Line Meaning ↴

Love, you think would last
Can run away, become the past
It can be like the setting sun
That fades away when the day is done

Why, baby, why
Did you take my love and loose it?
Why, baby, why?
Why did you ever choose it?

Why did you make me cry
The day you turned away?
I never thought you'd say goodbye

Now what can I do?
To find a life, I shared with you
We'll never part, I want to care

Why, baby, why
Did you take my love and loose it?
Why, baby, why?
Why did you ever choose it?

Why did you make me cry
The day you turned away?
I never thought you'd say goodbye

Why did you make me cry




The day you turned away?
I never thought you'd say goodbye

Overall Meaning

The Cats' "Why Baby Why" is a beautiful expression of a broken heart after a loved one leaves. The lyrics urge the former partner to understand the pain left behind and question why they would choose to leave, making the decision to break up even harder. The song describes how love that you think will last can sometimes run away and become the past. A love that was once like the setting sun fading away when the day is done. The singer is puzzled and devastated that the love they shared is gone, and they cannot understand how their partner could turn their back and leave, making them question why they would make this choice.


The tone of the song is melancholic, reflecting the pain and confusion that comes with unexpected heartbreak. The line "why did you make me cry the day you turned away" is particularly poignant, expressing the singer's deep sadness and disbelief. Despite their love and hopes for the future, the partner they cared for has left, leaving the singer feeling lost and alone. The singer is left with the question of what they can do to find a life shared with their former partner, and wondering if they will ever find closure.


Line by Line Meaning

Love, you think would last
You believed that your love would endure over time


Can run away, become the past
But love can flee from you and turn into memories


It can be like the setting sun
Love can resemble the sun when it disappears over the horizon


That fades away when the day is done
As the sun fades away at the end of the day, love can also vanish when time has passed


Why, baby, why
Why did you have to act that way?


Did you take my love and loose it?
Why did you take my love and let it slip away?


Why did you ever choose it?
What made you decide to do this to me?


Why did you make me cry
Why did you cause me to shed tears?


The day you turned away?
When you rejected me?


I never thought you'd say goodbye
I never anticipated that you'd leave me


Now what can I do?
What options do I have now?


To find a life, I shared with you
To discover a way to continue the life we once shared together


We'll never part, I want to care
I'm determined to maintain the relationship and keep caring for you




Contributed by Abigail Y. Suggest a correction in the comments below.
To comment on or correct specific content, highlight it

Genre not found
Artist not found
Album not found
Song not found
Comments from YouTube:

@margaretheittensammer2585

Einzigartig die Stimmen ❤❤❤

@janlinders7790

Pure Dutch sixties Soul invented by The Cats. Awesome sung by Piet Veerman.

@jeannetteterhorst5272

Schitterend nummer waanzinnig mooi gezongen door Piet ❤

@margaretheittensammer2585

Einfach die Besten ❤❤

@ianmahdiansyah6232

Mantap legend thecats whybabywhy favoritku

@hubertgunpowder

Great song !! ♫

@musicisthekey2037

The Cats...., Hollandser kan bijna niet!! Geweldig die 'paling sound'!

@tanika159

wat gaat de tijd toch snel om nooit te vergeten deze prachtige music

@that70sgirl90

Love Those Cats! 🐱💖

@Mark_Moore60

Yeah, they are not bad are they 😀👌

More Comments

More Versions