Tell Me Why
The Four Aces Lyrics


Jump to: Overall Meaning ↴  Line by Line Meaning ↴

Tell me why, though I try to forget
Tell me why, why I think of you yet
I know I'll never be free
What has happened to me?

Tell me why, when we danced until three
Tell me why, why my heart couldn't see
I never dreamed of romance
Never gave it a chance

When I think of how you looked that day
In your gown of silk and lace
Should have known the day you came my way
That this was the time and the place

Tell me why I keep fooling my heart
When I know it was love from the start
Why don't we give it a try?
If you know, tell me why

When I think (why) of how (why) you looked that day (why)
In your gown of silk and lace
Should have known (why) the day (why) you came my way (why)
That this was the time and the place

Tell me why I keep fooling my heart
When I know it was love from the start
Why don't we give it a try?
If you know, tell me why





Tell me
Tell me why

Overall Meaning

The Four Aces's song "Tell Me Why" is a wistful ballad about a love that never came to be. The song begins with the singer trying to forget about their past love, but finding that they can't stop thinking about them. They know deep down that they'll never be free of this love, no matter how hard they try. The song continues to reminisce about a specific moment in time when the singer and their love were dancing until three, but the singer's heart couldn't see that they were meant to be together. They blame themselves for not recognizing it sooner, particularly when they think back to how beautiful their love looked in a gown of silk and lace.


The chorus is a plea for answers and action. The singer asks their love to tell them why they keep fooling their heart and not giving their love a chance. They know that it was love from the start and wonder why they don't at least try to make it work. "Tell Me Why" is a classic example of a love song that's tinged with regret and longing. The lyrics convey the pain of missed opportunities and the frustration of not being able to let go of a love that's passed.


Line by Line Meaning

Tell me why, though I try to forget
Explain why I'm not able to forget you even though I try my level best to do so?


Tell me why, why I think of you yet
Can you tell me why you are still in my thoughts, even after all this while?


I know I'll never be free
I have come to the realization that I cannot escape the feeling of being in love with you


What has happened to me?
Why do I feel this way? What caused me to fall in love with you?


Tell me why, when we danced until three
Please explain to me why, after dancing together until late at night, I still can't get you out of my head


Tell me why, why my heart couldn't see
I don't understand why, even though we shared a special moment, I didn't recognize my true feelings for you


I never dreamed of romance
In the past, I never really thought about or considered having romantic feelings for someone


Never gave it a chance
I never allowed myself to experience it fully or give it a fair shot


When I think of how you looked that day
When I cast my mind back to the day I first saw you


In your gown of silk and lace
You were wearing a beautiful outfit made of high-quality fabric


Should have known the day you came my way
I should have realized on the day I first met you that you were going to be important to me


That this was the time and the place
That our meeting was providential, with perfect timing and location


Tell me why I keep fooling my heart
Explain why I can't see the truth about my feelings and continue to deny them


When I know it was love from the start
Deep down, I am aware that I was in love with you from the very beginning of our relationship


Why don't we give it a try?
I am asking whether we should take the next step in our relationship and see if we can make it work


If you know, tell me why
If you have any answers or insights into my confusion about my feelings, please share them with me


Tell me
Overall, this song is an emotional plea from the artist asking for insight into their feelings, specifically regarding a complicated romantic relationship




Lyrics © BMG Rights Management
Written by: Marty Gold, Al Alberts

Lyrics Licensed & Provided by LyricFind
To comment on or correct specific content, highlight it

Genre not found
Artist not found
Album not found
Song not found
Comments from YouTube:

@d.od.3463

A great, great singing group. I was 9 years old at the time of this recording, and still, I loved to listen to their music. Of course, my Mom and Dad were great fans. We lived in Pennsylvania to where the Four Aces were from! Great music! I am 80 years old now, and my favorite song of theirs was "Love is a many splendored Thing"

@Pineapple9

In 1951 I was 6 years old. My parents and my older brothers were responsible for introducing this music to me and I will be forever grateful. I have been an entertainer in life and enjoyed very much doing songs by the Four Aces, Four Lads and solo artists. The VietNam War took a lot out of me and I haven't been the same since, but the memories that this music brings back to me is absolutely priceless.

@francisalanwormald6328

1951 I 13 & my 1st dance in cafeteria with my Dad as "DJ"..But I could sing along...4 Aces fan all my life... now at 79 yrs...they still thrill me.. as they did me & my classmates all thru high school....

@francisalanwormald6328

I 2nd my original laudatory sentiment...DISCOVER THE "ACES"!!!!

@rosemaryaloisio7125

Finally met someone older than me. <---78 yrs old. I too, always loved the 4 aces.

@jp3923

I enjoyed your comment immensely. Hope you are still with us. I am 79 also and have such great appreciation of the Four Aces and their music.

@joebiddy3699

Great song--Finally met 2 people older than me - 75

@rhynz0410

Francis Alan Wormald y

1 More Replies...

@vocalist898

What a lot of memories,In 1951 I was driving for Greyhound in Detroit,Michigan and when we were waiting to go out on a run we would go across the street from the garage to a resturant drink coffee and play this record.

@jeffryhammel3035

Just a cool story... thanks!

More Comments

More Versions