Harvest Moon
The Magic Lantern Lyrics


Jump to: Overall Meaning ↴  Line by Line Meaning ↴

If a heart breaks all alone
Does it make a sound
And would anyone listen if it was booming all around
Like the last tree crashing down
From a forest one tree now
We can see, but can't hear ourselves falling
But we can see, but can't hear ourselves falling babe
We circle around each other
Like atoms bend through space
Were solitary creatures
We crave a warm embrace
And we all need to be looked after
And to feel the bomb of laughter
But in crowds I feel lonelier than ever
But in crowds I feel lonelier than ever babe
Please stay a while and hold me
Forget what's been and gone
It's from the death of innocense
That true love can be born
And if not now than someday soon
Oh beneath the harvest moon
We'll lie and love again
Like old lovers do
We'll lie and love again
Like old lovers do
We'll lie and love again




We'll lie and love again
We'll lie and we'll love again

Overall Meaning

The Magic Lantern’s song “Harvest Moon” is a beautiful meditation on loneliness, human connection, and the power of love to bring two people together even in the midst of heartbreak. The opening lines of the song pose a question: if a heart breaks all alone, does it make any noise? The singer seems to be contemplating the idea that our pain is often invisible to others, even when it feels like it’s consuming us entirely. The allusion to the last tree in a forest crashing down is particularly poignant, as it highlights the idea that we can feel isolated even when surrounded by others. We can see them, but we can’t hear them, just as they can’t hear us.


The singer goes on to explore the ways in which we crave human connection, even when we feel like we’re solitary creatures. The desire for a warm embrace, to be looked after, and to feel the bomb of laughter all highlight our need for love and intimacy. However, the paradox of crowds is that they can often make us feel even lonelier than when we’re by ourselves. It’s in this context that the chorus comes in, urging the listener to stay a while and hold the singer. They implore their lover to forget what’s been and gone, and to embrace the idea that true love can be born from the death of innocence. The final image of lying and loving again like old lovers do reinforces the idea that love can conquer all, even in the face of incredible heartbreak.


Line by Line Meaning

If a heart breaks all alone
Does it make a sound if nobody is there to hear it break?


And would anyone listen if it was booming all around
Even if the heartbreak was loud enough for all to hear, would anyone actually listen and care?


Like the last tree crashing down
A sudden and loud end, like the last tree standing suddenly collapsing.


From a forest one tree now
From a large group, now only a single being is left.


We can see, but can't hear ourselves falling
We can see our own downward spiral, but we are unable to hear the sound of our own decline.


But we can see, but can't hear ourselves falling babe
Reiteration of the previous line, emphasizing the inability to hear our own demise.


We circle around each other
We move in each other's orbits, but never really connect.


Like atoms bend through space
Our paths are like the unpredictable movement of atomic particles suspended in space.


Were solitary creatures
At our core, we are solitary beings, craving connection and intimacy.


We crave a warm embrace
We long for physical comfort and affection from others.


And we all need to be looked after
We all require the care and attention of others to thrive.


And to feel the bomb of laughter
We need to experience the explosive relief of laughter and joy.


But in crowds I feel lonelier than ever
Even when surrounded by people, we can feel more isolated and disconnected than ever.


But in crowds I feel lonelier than ever babe
Reiteration of the previous line, reflecting the pervasive sense of loneliness in our modern society.


Please stay a while and hold me
A plea for intimacy and physical closeness, even if only temporary.


Forget what's been and gone
Let go of the past; it no longer matters.


It's from the death of innocence
True growth and transformation often stem from the breaking of our own naivete and idealism.


That true love can be born
Only when we shed our illusions and egoism can we truly love and connect with others.


And if not now than someday soon
Even if we cannot experience love and intimacy now, perhaps there is hope for the future.


Oh beneath the harvest moon
A reference to the autumn season, symbolizing the cyclical nature of life and renewal.


We'll lie and love again
Despite the pain and solitude, there is always the possibility of experiencing love and intimacy once more.


Like old lovers do
A reference to the comfort and familiarity of long-term intimacy and connection.


We'll lie and love again
Reiteration of the previous line, emphasizing the resilience of the human spirit and our capacity to love.


We'll lie and we'll love again
Final line of the song, underscoring the optimism and hope of finding love and intimacy once more.




Contributed by Asher E. Suggest a correction in the comments below.
To comment on or correct specific content, highlight it

Genre not found
Artist not found
Album not found
Song not found
Comments from YouTube:

taylor from earth

This guy is SO underrated. Wow.

JOHN ONKEN

Such great music- this is on my 6:00 in the morning commute along the Bay in my ears as the sun comes up

Kane

I love this song

Rose Marshall

the soundtrack of my study nights. love it ! the magic lantern rules !!

Themagiclantern

Thanks Marshall! Really glad you're enjoying the music! Hope you can it to a gig soon!

Steve McKenna

very fine. and the life going on in the background is perfect

JOHN ONKEN

And is that some very fast Travis picking Jamie's doing?

More Versions